Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

"Ugly Betty" Is Freaking Fabulous (and Gay)

uriewilliams.jpgromijn.jpgindelicato.jpg

Near the end of last night's episode of Ugly Betty, after being rejected by his mother, Marc St. James (Michael Urie) announced to Betty (America Ferrera) that he is "freaking fabulous."

Indeed, Marc is a fabulous character (with all of the various implications conveyed by that word), but even more fabulous is Ugly Betty the show. Now nearing the end of its freshman season, Betty has established itself as arguably the most queer-friendly program in the history of broadcast television.

It's not just that Ugly Betty is set in gay-friendly Manhattan in the gay-friendly world of fashion. Nor does the fact that it features three queer character make the show so extraordinary. That doesn't mean that every Thursday night millions of Americans don't tune in to laugh at Marc's sarcastic quips, check out transgender character Alexis Meade's (Rebecca Romijn) sexy new figure, or smile at the pre-adolescent antics of is-he-or-isn't-he, tap-dancing, show tune-loving Justin (Mark Indelicato).

No, what makes the show so extraordinarily gay-friendly is that its sensibility is so gay — and not just its fashion sensibility. Every week, Ugly Betty delivers a message about self-acceptance and being true to oneself, and it reminds us that mere tolerance isn't enough. No, in Betty's world, true understanding and acceptance are what this show is all about.

While not every GLBT person grows up feeling as if they don't belong, while simultaneously dreaming of a better life where they do fit in, it's probably fair to say that more feel that way than don't. It's all of these elements combined that make up the queer sensibility percolating throughout Ugly Betty, and that is what makes the hit dramedy so extraordinary.

Ironically, the character who most embodies the show's sensibility isn't Marc, Alexis or Justin; it is the straight Betty Suarez herself. Betty is the quintessential outsider: the ugly duckling whose beauty is on the inside waiting to be spotted by the right guy. She is the outcast with her nose pressed to the window wanting to be on the inside with the cool kids who reject her.

Week after week, while trying to fit in or be who she thinks others want her to be, Betty gets involved in some scheme, only to learn by the episode's end that being yourself and carrying yourself with pride is the only way to truly live. She is the perfect reflection for Marc, Alexis and Justin, who each yearn and strive to be accepted and loved for exactly who they are.

Best of all, Betty is the character with whom most viewers best identify. It is her journey in which the audience is most invested — and most probably don't even realize just how much they are identifying with such a gay sensibility.

But Ugly Betty's extraordinariness goes beyond this. So often in the past, gay characters on television shows were used in only one way. There was the funny gay, the evil gay or the sainted, best-friend gay. Yes, they occasionally had their "own" episode where they fell in love with someone, but, of course, it never worked out, and the next week they went right back to being funny, evil or sainted.

Marc may be funny, and he may be Wilhelmina Slater's (Vanessa William) "seeing-eye gay" and "evil" henchman, but he's never meaner than Willy herself. And, as viewers saw when he bonded earlier in the season with Justin about their shared interests and struggles, he, too, has a heart.

Justin may be precocious, obsessed with fashion and, yes, swishy, but his family loves him fiercely, and neither he nor they make any apologies for who he is. Rebecca Romijn's Alexis may be stunningly beautiful, but the show never lets you forget for long that this is a person facing down some of society's most ingrained prejudices.

On Ugly Betty, each of these characters is just as fully fleshed-out as any other character. Most importantly, their sexuality is not a punch line to laugh at or something used to make the other characters — or the audience — feel uncomfortable.

In last night's episode, perfectly titled "Don't Ask Don't Tell," the show's gay sensibility blazed especially bright. Marc finally told his mother (played wonderfully by Patti LuPone) that he is gay.

Not wanting to disappoint her, he had misled her for years, having various women — including co-worker Amanda (Becki Newton) — pose as his girlfriend. But when his mother said of Justin, "I don't even know what that is; he's just so swishy," Marc was finally compelled to tell his mother the truth about himself. His mother responded by saying, "I have no interest in knowing the real you."

Marc wasn't the only child rejected last night. Alexis again heard her father Bradford Meade (Alan Dale) discuss her sex change with utter contempt, calling her "the son I wish I'd never had." Her brother, Daniel (Eric Mabius) was hardly better, consistently referring to Alex as "him" or "my brother" with only slightly less contempt than his father. But by the episode's end, he had made considerable progress and finally wrote an accepting letter in which he referred to his sister as "her."

So in one episode, Middle America witnessed a coming-out, two parental rejections based on sexual orientation and transgender issues, a defense of a swishy pre-adolescent, heard the praises sung about one's chosen family, and delivered a message that being honest about who you are is nothing to be ashamed of.

You can't get much more queer — or freaking fabulous — than that.

Joseph's picture

I love Ugly Betty!

Last night's episode was simply fantastic -- laugh out loud hilarious and delicately moving at the same time. Michael Urie, Becki Newton, Vanessa Williams and America Ferrera all deserve Emmy nominations. Thanks, Michael, for this wonderful article.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Michael Jensen's picture

You are more

than welcome. Between Ugly Betty and Brothers & Sisters, ABC is lightyears ahead of every other network--as we'll be discussing come Monday!
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
ChrisP's picture

Loved This Episode

Thanks for another great Best Gay Week and your article on Ugly Betty. As far as I’m concerned, Betty comes right after Brothers & Sisters for the best show on TV.

I have been a fan since the beginning and It does just keep getting better and better. Your article was pretty dead on concerning the interplay of the characters, but I think that Daniel’s problem with Alexis really isn’t a sexuality issue as much as a manifestation of the love / hate relationship that they had before this all happened. Daniel’s relationship with Alex (before Alexis) was always one of hero worship / resentment because Alex was always better at everything and their fathers favorite. Alex loved his little brother but resented the fact that no matter how many competitions he won or how good he was at the things that mattered to their father, once the real Alex was known, he would never be accepted by their father and Daniel would take over as the favored son.

I think that after Alex’s death, Daniel had started to discover how much he resented Alex as well as how much he truly loved him, but a person can get a little pissed off when they have been put through all of that grief for nothing and they also find out that the person that they loved so much never really let them know who he was. Alexis on the other hand was so busy nursing her resentments and plotting her revenge that she didn’t really give any serious thought to how she felt about Daniel deep in her hart.

I think that the conflict that arises from these issues is going to be the story line for them for most of next season. As a gay man with two straight male siblings, this is the story line speaks to my own experience coming out (minus the coming back from the dead as a woman and being wealthy).

Just as an aside. When Wilhelmina left that vodka just out of Claire’s reach with her handcuffed to the bed, I wanted to jump into the TV and rip her hair out. I haven’t felt that way while watching a TV show since Dynasty.

I LOVE this show.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
H's picture

Great article! I also love

Great article! I also love this show, and last night's ep was hilarious!
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

Betty is a Goddess!!!!!

I adored last night's show too. Fascinating that it took subjects usually delivered in a soggy-as-a-wet-cruller "very special episode" of some earnest series or other and made points no "serious" show ever could. "Ugly Betty" makes us root for the self-acceptance of characters who aren't even likeable. And it shows that REAL acceptance can be found in Jackson Heights. We all wish we had a family like Justin's when we were his age.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Thom's picture

At last some ground is being broken.

Last year I had a conversation with Michaelangelo Signorelli about Brokeback Mountain. I remember feeling that as great as that movie was, I didn't have the feeling of seeing something groundbreaking.

Ugly Betty, on the other hand, is truly groundbreaking. Str8 America has seen more "Gayness" this year than ever before in the Media. And it is a "Gayness" that is always done with sensitivity and a solid message of acceptance. Every week the show says very plainly, and with just the right amount of bitchiness "How dare you tell me what is NORMAL!"

Thanks for continuing to champion this show Michael.

Michael Jensen's picture

Well, it's a great show and

to be perfectly honest, I didn't realize that right away because I didn't get its sensibility.
Anonymous's picture

arthurs-1

I think Michael Jensen is getting confused between "camp" and "gay". Ugly Betty has a camp sensibility, not a gay sensibility. It will only have a gay sensibility if it shows a male-male relationship as opposed to a number of drama queens making declarations about their sexuality.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Willy's picture

I cant wait

I ave heard so much about this show! Its going to take a while - but I really cant wait for this programme to hit South African TV.
Michael Jensen's picture

We'll have to agree to

disagree. Obviously the show also has a camp sensibility, but that doesn't also exclude the gay sensibility that I discuss and that has nothing to do with camp.
Anonymous's picture

Great article, great episode!

I do have a quibble though: Daniel refering to a sibling as "he" when he knew that sibling for most of his life as a man and is being treated like crap by her now despite his trying to be supportive and loving is "nearly as bad" as Bradford telling his child he wishes they'd never been born? That's a little harsh. I agree with Chris P's comment. Don't get me wrong; I certainly think Daniel needs to work on his tolerance- but just being a transsexual doesn't exuse everythng Alexis does, and you can't deny she's been a bitch to people who don't deserve it. (Read: her brother and mother. Wili, too, but in a different way.) Regardless, watching the desperation for both her and Marc to have acceptance they can't seem to get is heartbreaking, and really makes for some wonderful messages I wish the world would pay attention to more. So thank you for this! All that's left now...is to wait desperately for new episodes. Ah, well. Can't wait to see how things keep playing out!
Anonymous's picture

crap ARTICAL

Yes Marc is gay. But how is that to say that it turns the whole show gay. I mean if there are men and women kissing together in it how is it gay. The fashion part is rather camp but still it is a straight comedy. I wouldn't be watching it if it was gay. I have to say that is a crap no good lying artical

Recent Comments