Like a Prayer. For no other reason than that I think she could take that song to a whole 'nother level...and she wouldn't even need the gospel choir.

...or Emma. Or Kurt.

Okay, it's obvious I'm just trying to work my favorite Madonna song into the episode, but depending on how their storylines go, it could fit with quite a number of them.

 

"Open up your mind and then open up your heart. And you will see that you and me aren't very far apart." - Blessid Union of Souls

Jane Lynch would KILL that song! You can just see everything falling apart around her and just break out in a very emotional number. I think it would be best suited for Janes stong vocals. Am I crazy or does You Must Love Me just scream Sue Sylvester??

... we have meetings????

I'll have to remember not to watch that episode. I don't get anything about Madonna. I think i've only liked maybe one song of hers and that's it.

...plus, I still have no idea why people call her 'madge'

Will Schuester: Take A Bow

Terri Schuester: You Must Love Me

Emma Pillsbury: Cherish

Sue Sylvester: This Used To Be My Playground

Finn Hudson: Crazy For You

Quinn Fabray: Hung Up

Rachel Berry: You'll See

Noah 'Puck' Puckerman: Justify My Love

Kurt Hummel: Beautiful Stranger

Mercedes Jones: Dress You Up

Tina Cohen-Chang: Who's That Girl

Artie Abrams: Open Your Heart

Principal Figgins: Holiday

Cheerios & Football Team (led by Mercedes & Kurt): Vogue

...Rachel and Noah/Puck should sing ISAAC.

And Jenna Ushkowitz can definitely sing that G in GLEE's version of TONIGHT from WEST SIDE STORY. That's just a scripted "fluke" to make Rachel look and sound like a better singer than Tina.

These choices are lame. There has to be some connection between a character, their storyline and the song. For instance how about a Rachel/Emma "Crazy for You" duet dedicated to Finn and Will, but it's not just them performing the song together, but a split screen dream sequence kind of thing. Papa Don't Preach is a no-brainer for Quinn.

I think it would be perfect for the two of them to do Papa Don't Preach as a duet. Puck out on the football field, and Finn most likely in the glee rehearsal room. Both of them want to do the right thing.

This would have to be before poor Finn learns a bit more about the birds and the bees. Once he figures out he's not the baby daddy he's not going to be a happy boy.

by Terri, as she watches Will and Emma together after the baby deception is exposed.

I think it would make perfect sense for Quinn to sing 'like a virgin', given her background as the leader of the celibacy club. Mercedes would do a great job of 'Papa dont preach', I think that song would sound better with her than with Rachael. Just on a side note, didn't Moulin Rogue cover a lot of Madonna songs.

Someone in the love triangle (well, more of a square, now) should deliver a heart-broken rendition of Frozen. Or maybe Emma.

Quinn could try Material Girl.

And that gorgeous Latina Cheerio who's only had one line might break out with La Isla Bonita.

Loleatta Holloway did a cover version for the "Virgin Voices" Madonna tribute CD. Mercedes could probably top her. Rachel: Borderline Puck and Rachel as a split screen duet suggested by others: Burning up or Open your heart...maybe both as a mash up!!! Kurt: Get into the Groove or I love New York Artie: Human Nature Quinn: I know it or Live to tell

Somebody should sing Borderline. Rob Thomas slowed it down and sang it with just a piano and it was eerily awesome.

I can see Rachel getting something like Hung Up referring to her non-relationship with Finn, and maybe she's trying to move on. I see Papa Don't Preach going to Quinn, because clearly whole baby swap business is not going to happen, this isn't The Young and the Restless. I feel like it's going to come to a head when Quinn decides she wants to keep her baby. She could sing that whole verse, "He says that he's going to marry me, and we can raise a little family...." and it could really be about Finn or Puck depending on whether or not Finn's found out the baby isn't his.

Okay, so Like a Prayer might not go over so well considering it's supposed to be a high school, but they have to work in Vogue and Express Yourself. And I would love to see someone sing Take a Bow, but I get hung up on that line, "You took my love for granted."I can't think of anyone that really applies to.

And of course, Kurt needs a song, because it's the Madonna episode. Material Girl would be good, or Vogue like someone else said.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CUwSJkzo5Vw It's Sondheim!

Will: Power of Goodbye (after he hopefully dumps Terri's ass) or Live To Tell

Terri: Love Don't Live Here Anymore

Emma: True Blue

Sue: More (from "Dick Tracy")

Finn/Puck: Love that "Papa Don't Preach" duet idea

Quinn: Bad Girl

Rachel: Open Your Heart

Kurt: Vogue

Mercedes: Like A Prayer

Tina: Frozen

Artie: I'll Remember

http://popwatch.ew.com/2009/11/04/glee-video-soundtrack-signing/

And Dianna Agron once again confirmed she will be performing "Papa Don't Preach" in episode 10.