Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Trauma (1.05) "Masquerade" Recap: "Boo, I'm gay!"

As Boone and Tyler walk back to their vehicle, Boone remarks the two men had acted like a married gay couple to which Tyler "maybe that's because they are on old married couple."

But they are two dudes! That's just freaky.

When Boone later compares the Castro to Sodom and Gomorrah, Tyler has finally had enough and explains to his partner exactly what he thinks of the Castro:

I just see people trying to live their lives and the Castro is filled with people who were beat up when they were a kid for being gay, kicked out of their house and disowned by their parents at age fourteen and just knowing there is a place like this even existed is a better alternative than offing yourself because you can't change who are, is why the come here.

He then pauses and says "That's why I came here."

Here is the scene:


Boone reacts by saying nothing, just staring off into the distance.

Later Tyler points out that they've been riding together for three years and asks if Boone hadn't ever wondered if Tyler might not be gay. Boone admits he had but that he's never seen a straight guy with sideburns like Tyler's (clearly, Boone has not been paying attention while driving around San Francisco).

The episode ends without Boone making any heartfelt speeches of acceptance or making any apologies, and it's not clear exactly where things stand between the two men.

Overall, I thought the show handled the topic quite well. Frankly, I thought it interesting that even though Boone had suspected his co-worker might be gay, that knowledge hadn't kept him from throwing around homophobic comments. That seems very real. (Imagine how homophobic he would've been if he hadn't suspected.)

Like Southland did with Officer Cooper, Trauma took a slow approach to revealing Tyler's being gay. Folks working at both shows told me that was because they wanted viewers to get to know the characters first before learning they were gay. Which translates to: our viewers are mostly straight men and we don't want to spook them off. Given how the show has struggled in the ratings, I can't say I blame them for taking their time.

The show also had a couple of very funny lines to leaven the heavy emotional scenes, not to mention all the bloody, injured folks we keep encountering. The first came when a woman dressed as a Playboy bunny runs up to Tyler and Boone's rig and declares "Sarah Palin's all messed up" to which a laughing Tyler replies "You're preaching to the choir."

The second best line comes right after when Boone tells the African-American man dressed as Sarah Palin that he looks nothing like the failed VP nominee to which the man replies "And you don't like anything like the firefighters on my calendar, but you don't see me being disrespcctful." Ha.

I actually interviewed Kevin Rankin yesterday and will have that interview next week. Rankin answered some of my questions about the episode and about Tyler including why he hadn't told his partner he was gay after three years. Of course, that's assuming the show isn't canceled this week.

Joseph's picture

Even if it is canceled

I hope you still run the interview with Kevin Rankin. I've grown to like the show, it's better than the alternatives that are on Monday night at that time, and last night was the series' best episode yet: Tyler coming out, the Lost Boy/Tinkerbell storyline (anybody else notice Larry Sullivan from The Trip as the boy's father?) and Cliff Curtis' Rabbit was shockingly not annoying.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
AddisonDewitt's picture

Larry Sullivan...

When I see Larry around in all his walk on small roles lately I get excited and yell out "Oh, he's a dancer! Oh, he's a dancer." ;-)

------------------------------------------------------------

If I bring out the devil in you, he was there all along!

Married since September 18, 2009. Wedded since October 10, 2009!

giovannif7's picture

The coming out scene

was well done, although it didn't really work (for me) within the context of the characters and the backstory. I don't get Tyler and Boone spending three years as full-time partners, the two of them riding around SF in a rig together, without the subjects of dating, relationships and sex coming up in conversation. Tyler just doesn't seem the type to hold back for three years, nor does he strike me as someone who would use gender-neutral pronouns or play the pronoun-switching game. In any case, it'll be interesting to see how this reveal affects the relationship between the two men, at least as long as the show lasts.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Knickie's picture

I have to agree. It makes no

I have to agree. It makes no sense at all that these guys have been so close for three years and the subject NEVER came up -- in San freaking Francisco? Huh?
the herald's picture

But the straight partner

said he suspected for quite some time.  I think most of us have had this type of relationship with someone, where you're friends and there's an unspoken agreement to just not bring it up.  It's a crappy double-standard, since the straight guy can talk about his private life all he wants, but will pointedly not ask the gay guy anything about his life.  And the gay guy, not wanting to make waves, is happy to oblige. Of course, in this new up and coming generation, that probably doesn't happen much anymore.  If you don't know what I'm talking about, you're quite lucky indeed. 

 

Have to say I disagree with you about the end, Michael.  The think the straight character made the snarky remark about his sideburns to let him know that things can basically stay the same between them; and then they both worked together to clean the ambulance.  I think they're at an uneasy peace.  Hopefully, we'll get to find out and see more.  This is the first episode I've seen; I thought it was pretty good.  

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
JC's picture

Trauma

I found the episode done well and thought that they advanced the character development of everyone quite well. As for the touching at the firetruck .. I know I'm gonna get blasted for it but he was in the right. It's one of my pet peeves about the gay community that they think they can come up and touch and feel you. It's an invasion of privacy and if it had been me (and yes I've done this ) I'd grab his arm and and twist real hard and say.. did I give you permission to touch me?. It's a behavior that should not be encouraged.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
The_Intangible_Fancy's picture

Are you seriously suggesting

Are you seriously suggesting that the proper response to being touched inappropriately is to physically assault and threaten the person who touched you?  Imagine if this was how everyone dealt with minor inconveniences and annoyances.  We would all end up in the hospital.

I agree completely that people need to be more careful about invading other people's personal space.  It is not pleasant when someone touches you in an intimate way without invitation.  But you deal with inappropriate touching by telling that person that you don't appreciate being touched, not with violence and anger.  Only if they continue to harrass you should you fight back.  Nothing wrong with self-defense.

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
the herald's picture

That's a bit psycho, dude.

Maybe push his arm away and say "don't do that" seems like a more appropriate reaction.  And I must say, I've never encountered a member of the "gay community" who acted like that with a complete stranger.  Actually, I take back.  I've had it happen and seen it with friends when the person was totally wasted or on something. In those instances, you should move away from them and have the class to just shrug it off.  

ClassDunce's picture

I think I may be developing

I think I may be developing a small crush on Rabbit... I liked the episode, you could see the coming out scene coming a mile away but it was still a fun episode.
Matt's picture

Scared straights

I feel as though the slow to come out thing is a bit of a blessing. It would be great if we could just have gay characters from the get go, but that's not really the point we're at as a society. While I do think the networks are trying not to "scare away" straight men, it kind of works in our favor. Say a straight man sees a character that's gay from the start they will always be "the gay character" to this man. Lets say in this case the man particularly doesn't really like the character, partially because the character is "the gay character." Now if the character is developed without actually labeling him as gay this straight man may find something in the character to relate to, and may start to like him. Now the character is revealed as gay, the guy watching is more likely to continue liking the character, even if he likes him slightly less. Basically my point is your more likely to get visibility with a character who comes out on the show, than a character who is gay from the start. Just my opinion.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Ed Kennedy's picture

A win, but...

OK, I finally got this watched, and I love that they didn't shy away from what you might see in the Castro on Halloween. It was there in all its fabulousness. And for the first time the fact they're spending the money in to film in SF was worth it. The city is a character in and of itself

I wanted to like this show - I really did. But I just don't care about the characters that much. Rabbit is the only one that has any dimension to me.

As for the coming out? Nice speech. Personally, I would have already thrown my partner through the door of the rig over that crap, because I'm so far beyond taking abuse in my life, but I recognize that's different for everyone. But it still didn't ring true to me, plus the whole thing was a throwaway, the way it was written. They never have to revisit it if it bombed, and I think that's fairly cowardly on the writer's part. But at $2-4m/episode, I might be a coward, too.

monica_ca's picture

I'm in love with this show

...but I'm afraid that it's only me and three other people who care to watch it every week :/I think that it might have gotten lost in a season filled with 47 new medical shows. I do think that it does an excellent job between balancing between the paramedics and other 'regular's and the patients that we only see for that episode. Every week we get enough of the cast that we actually care about them and want to watch the next week and find out more about them. I think at times that can be a really hard balance, and one that many shows don't ever 'get'.
Frank's picture

I still think Taylor Kinney should have played the gay guy

I mean come on with that name he can only play gay characters can't he? That would be the name Brian and Justin would have had if they ever had gotten married. ;-)