News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

"Brothers & Sisters" Finale Recap: “Prior Commitments”

New recapper reporting to you, just in time for the big Brothers & Sisters finale. I feel like a relief pitcher sent in at the bottom half of the 9th inning. Wow, listen to how butch I sound with all that sports talk. I hope my father’s reading this. Papa, can you hear me?

Before we get to the recap proper, I want to send ABC a big “we heart you” for not shying away from a gay wedding, during May sweeps no less. We all know how sweeps months typically mean big goings-on in the TV world as part of the networks’ no-holds-barred efforts to drive bigger ratings. Frankly, all those TV finales through the years have merged in my mind into one big wedding/massacre/childbirth/amnesia/trial extravaganza — and that’s just the sitcoms.

But the fact we’re actually getting a big sweeps finish for a primetime series revolving around two men getting hitched is something truly remarkable — and definitely worthy of celebration. I’m thinking Kevin-Scotty floats in all Pride Parades this year, or maybe creating a new national holiday in their honor, something that’s even gayer than Earth Day. Who’s with me?

We open mid-angst at the Walker family manse during some special family meeting (tellingly sans Rebecca or Kevin) that Nora’s called, and you know it’s something serious because they’ve bypassed the usual wine for hard alcohol. What? You didn’t actually think those tall glasses of OJ everybody’s drinking in this scene weren’t laced with something stronger. I can spot a Harvey Wallbanger when I see one.

Everybody’s fully immersed in their problems from last week — Sarah and Tommy squabbling over what a back-stabbing beyotch Holly is, Kitty waiting to talk to her fertility doctor about McCallister’s tireless campaign to knock her up good and proper, etc. Oh, and Justin’s sulking, because at this point the poor doofus has no idea what he’s supposed to feel about Rebecca, and can you really blame him?

They decide not to wait for Kevin and get on with Nora’s big announcement which is … Sarah’s not a biological Walker either! And she’s gay! In fact, she and Kitty have been sleeping together for weeks, are getting married, and already pregnant with quintuplets, two of whom will be raised Republican, two Democrat, and one Libertarian, thereby doubling all dramatic finale storylines and tripling the show’s ratings!

Of course that didn’t actually happen, other than in my own weird imaginings, but it’s just a reflection of how, even though it’s been handled pretty well, I’m still not on board with the whole faux-incest storyline and don’t know if I ever will be. I worry this is going to give network bigwigs the idea they can save big bucks on hiring romantic interests for their shows simply by monkeying around with existing characters, even if they’re family members. Are you really ready to see Bree hook up with Andrew?

Anyway, Nora tries in her own delicate way to break the news about Rebecca, but before she can get it out we hear from Justin — clearly the type who likes to remove band-aids in one quick, excruciating swipe — who blurts out, “Rebecca’s not our sister.” And for those slow on the uptake, he further explains, “Dad wasn’t her dad.” Next he’ll explain that Holly’s not their mother.

Mouths drop, then the freak-out erupts, with lots of “OMGs” and Sarah being only too happy to blame it on Holly. Just then, Kevin (Matthew Rhys) finally arrives, and seeing them all gathered, assumes Scotty (Luke MacFarlane) spilled the beans about the upcoming nuptials and they’re meeting to help with the planning.

He proceeds to assign wedding-planning duties, announcing that Tommy can throw in free booze from the winery, Scotty can do all the cooking himself (!), and since Kitty writes speeches for a living, they’d like her to officiate at the ceremony. Because nothing is quite as touching at a wedding as a statistic-filled, focus-grouped, sound-bite-friendly political diatribe written by a paid hack from a failed campaign.

Kitty, surprised, asks if Kevin is engaged to Scotty, and he jokingly responds no, it’s somebody he met just last night, which I figure they all know is a joke because it’s not like Kevin’s suddenly become a lesbian.

When Kitty questions if he and Scotty are getting married, Kevin draws the distinction that it’s “not married … committed,” which I, in all seriousness, appreciated they threw in here because I think it’s important to emphasize for the general public that while it might look for all intents and purposes like a marriage, it’s still technically a depressingly “separate and even then not equal” arrangement in most states.

Kevin explains that they’re going to have the ceremony that coming Saturday at the Walker house, since he and Scotty don’t want a big “fairytale shindig” — a plan which bewilders me because if it were me, I’d want a huge, glitzy wedding with tons of guests so that I could finally start recouping the $34,789 I’ve spent on other people’s wedding gifts.

When Kevin wonders why everyone’s less than forthcoming with their good wishes, they drop the Rebecca bomb on him.



User login

Recent comments

Put AfterElton.com headlines on your site/blog:

After Elton home page on logo online