Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

"Brothers & Sisters" Episode 306 Recap: “Bakersfield”

McCallister Ranch. Kitty answers the phone, and it’s Robert finally returning her call. He’s obviously prepared for her to bitch away some more at him while he holds the phone away from his head and makes the “she so crazy” gesture to his colleagues. Instead, he’s no doubt surprised by the warm response he gets from her, as she tells him the happy news about having been picked by a birthmother. She says, “We’re going to have a baby in three months!” and I just keep groaning away about how ill-advised thinking like that is. Then she says, “I’m really happy!” Yikes! Again with the tempting T.V. fate talk. Just go pick out his tombstone already, why don’t you?

Stately Walker Manor. Nora opens the door, and by George … it’s George! As in George Lafferty. He says he was up all night wondering what would make a seemingly non-sadistic person like Nora drive all that way to make accusations about his dead wife. He figures there must be more to her story. When she tells him the affair took place 22 years ago, he figures out immediately that this is actually about his son, a.k.a. he-who-is-often-named-but-must-not-be-seen: Ryan.

End of episode. I’ll give it a B–. Of course, major points off for no Scotty. But other stuff was pretty well-handled, especially the Kevin/Tommy bout and the confrontation with George Lafferty. While I’m not so keen on the Internet dweeb duo so far, I’ve been complaining for so long about Sarah needing to get away from Ojai and get a decent story of her own that I can’t penalize them for actually taking the show in that direction. Not yet anyway.

What did you think of the episode?

Psionycx's picture

I gave it a "D"

Granted, I was put off right from the start by the (torturous) extended Justin/Rebecca/bathrobe scene. Am I alone in finding those two more tedious and unwatchable with each new episode?

The rest of the sub-plots were also a yawn. Factor in a complete absence of Scotty and I really just couldn't get interested.

Except when George was onscreen.  "Edible" doesn't even begin to describe the man.  What can I say? He's very much a mature muffin.

However, if this all continues I should be completely over B&S within 2-3 weeks.

Knickie's picture

A Liza Minnelli PILLOW?

A Liza Minnelli PILLOW? That's how they cunningly code GAY? What year is this? 1971?
Jake's picture

Third time's the charms

This is the third time they've featured the pillow. It's so very uptight, tightly wound corporate lawyer with Efd-up personal life who JUST HAPPENS to be a 'mo. At least, that's what the set decorator would have you believe.
Anthony D. Langford's picture

I Thought....

.... the thing about the pillow was so ridiculously stereotypical as to be offensive.  Overall, I gave the episode a C. I guess I don't subtract points if Scotty is there or not simply because in the context of the show I wouldn't expect to see him every episode. It's the fate of a Walker spouse. Heck, the show struggles to squeeze non-Walker Robert in every episode and I suspect they have no choice but to do that with him.

 

Oh and the guy who played George was pretty cute. 

Jeremymlad's picture

The Pillow

Are you kidding?  I would kill for a pillow like that.

No, that may be hyperbolic of me.  Let me think on it a sec...

Yes.  Yes, I would kill for a pillow like that.  (and I don't feel stereotypical)

nordic balance's picture

What is so wrong with a musical theater fan owning a LIZA

pillow?

Kevin doesn't need to be coded gay. He's OUT!

I think what's so funny about the pillow is that in most ways, Kevin is very  traditionally male but he clearly loves that pillow (despite how unlikely a thing it might seem to be for him to have in his house) which is why I think folks make such a point of it (Holly, Jason, etc).

I think the pillow is cute and I think it's cute that Kevin (who is a very masculine man) is comfortable enough with himself and in his skin to not be so worried all the time about what's "stereotypically gay" and what isn't.

He loves to cook and decorate and he loves theatre but no, you wouldn't necessarily know any of that by looking at him (if you were thinking in stereotypes) and I think THAT is what makes him more realistic.

It's like folks expect him to be chopping wood and chewing tobacco and smacking beer cans on his head or he's stereotypical.

How bout a happy medium?

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
Marea67's picture

Liza-Pillow

That pillow just belongs in Kevin/Scotty's place, just like the other 10 thousand little things, such as the books no one probably ever reads, but are just there to be decorative.

I dislike Justecca more and more, but I figured out that that is probably due to the fact, that their presence only emphasizes that they can be shown intimately together and Kevin/Scotty cannot.  

I think the episode wasn't bad, but it added nothing much either. It seems to be one of those 'in between' episodes.

There's a real start up to the Ryan story, some cracks in the perfect Robert/Kitty relationship, Tommy/Kevin is not solved (despite the faking), Sarah is getting back in charge. Just curious where it will lead.

Sadly: No Scotty, he might have added some spice to the episode, but I doubt it.

Best of all: No Holly.

 

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Alfred's picture

Bitches Anonymous

I love BA~!!!! That's the coolest line from this episode. And when Kevin says he's slapped Tommy. So funny. More BA sessions please!!I have no problem with JusBecca. They are cute together.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
zanefan's picture

Nora Remembers

I literally clapped out loud when Nora angrily reminded Kitty how inappropriate Robert's attack on her a few weeks back was, and how no one jumped to her defense.

Thank god SOMEONE on that writing staff is paying attention!

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
dcjeepguy's picture

Couger Alert?

Does anyone else see Sarah and Kyle hooking up?
virgo108's picture

I thought the same thing.

I thought the same thing.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Chuckles's picture

I was almost ready to give

I was almost ready to give this episode a D, maybe F, but then I saw the previews for next week and wouldn't you know it Senator Prettyboy is having and affair!! So it makes up for the ho-humness of this episode just a little bit. Although I will give points to the prospect of seeing Sarah take a note from Brenda on SFU and slut it up for us with those two hipster nerds.

Oh, and there should be nothing anonymous about being a bitch as every queen here knows how good it feels to be one.

Jake's picture

Trope

Having Robert cheat is a soap opera cliche - but given that every relationship that every Walker has features cheating (William on Nora, Tommy on Julia, Sarah's husband, Justin on his boss from the hotel with the drug buddy/skank, Kevin with Scotty while he was dating the actor, Kitty with her co-host while she was wit the fiance from NY). is a particularly B&S cliche - a really bad one that shows just how desperate and lazy the writers have gotten. This is just as bad as repeating the William Walker illegitimate child with Ryan or the Ojai financial drama from season 1 last season. The only potentially possible good thing would be to get rid of a cast member due to a cheating but given the writing, it will more likely drag out into a repeat of Tommy's affair.
boyd's picture

Definitely a D

Pretty much a dud episode for me. Contrived fights. No Scotty. And this internet startup plot would have been eye-rolling craptastic in 1998 -- but 2008?! Come on, writers. Do like 2 hours of research on start-ups and funding in this horrible economic moment we find ourselves in...

Now, George Lafferty. Totally yum! More of him, please!

And the pillow is great propping. It's one of the so-bad-it's-good conversation starters that you keep out because it's expensive and horrible. And clearly Kevin knows its expensive but can't seem to get rid of it or stash it in the guest bedroom.(Jonathan Adler needlepoint pillows run $150 to $200. And the Liza/"Disco Diva" pillow hasn't been available for more than a year.) And didn't he try to hide it before someone (Chad?) came over?

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Jake's picture

Craptastic Internet Startups

It just goes to show how really lazy the writers are - just as no temp agency in California would threaten to 'fire' a temp for refusing an assignment -- they wouldn't even imply it over a food company with little, if any need, for clerical help -- two dudes in a crappy apartment would never make it pass the vetting a recruiter would do for a placement agency. Sell his truck? Selling his truck, even if it were a Hummer, would barely pay the commission an agency would request for the placement of an MBA grad/former CEO. It has as much logic as a 50ish Pasadena housewife trying to start a $17M charity or that anyone would give her more than money for postage to do -- irrespective of who's wife she was.

 

They need to do basic routine research, learn simple logic skills, try to be more creative than rehashing their own plot contrivances (a Walker or a Walker spouse has an affair! Ojai is many millions in trouble! William Walker has an illigetimate child!). Please.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
dcjeepguy's picture

Affair?

I'm sure creative editing is supposed to make us think he's having an affair but your comment did remind me of my first thought when hearing Kitty's the vmail about the baby - it'll be special needs or not white. Of course just adopting a baby wouldn't be enough of a story line for BS.
zanefan's picture

The Baby

My hope is that the possibility of adopting a non-white baby will expose Robert's underlying racism.

Who am I kidding?  The man is God, I am sure the child will turn to pure solid gold as soon as he lays hands on it.

retropian's picture

Hmm. I detect a new meme for

Hmm. I detect a new meme for Kitty and the Senator. As Nora said, he'll pick ambition over family. Or, he'll balk at adopting, he doesn't really want to be a father again. He was only going along with it to please Kitty. Plus he'll admit he couldn't adopt a non-white baby, revealing why he's a Repub after all. Sarah will start having feelings for the blond dude. Oh sure she'll anguish over the age difference, and their business relationship, but then hey, he's young, cute and into her. Plus she has a thing for guys with long hair.
chuck's picture

Just watched this week's episode

and can't wait for the recaplet. This show is getting worse and worse and has pretty much lost me. When I prefer to see the Giants play than watch the episode live, that's a bad sign. I guess I still watch it for the overall good acting and to keep hope alive that something truly horrible and painful will happen to Holly to end the season with a bang. I feel so sorry for poor Luke Macfarlane. Such a cutie with nothing to do but get treated badly by his husband. And I couldn't follow anything about the Prop 8/Sacramento Tribune/governor-senator cheating story-line. About the only thing I'm really liking is that sexy guy playing George Lafferty.  He was totally hot as an FBI agent in 'Hannibal'.  Sadly IMDB says he's only in two episodes, for now at least...