Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Project Runway 412 Recap: "The Finalists Take to the Tents"

I didn't really enjoy the judges' comments, but it was equally clear that they knew that either of the designers could have gone on to Bryant Park (well, in fact, they both did, but that's another story).

Then they asked Chris why he should go to Fashion Week. He responded, "I think that it might be interesting to have a point of view from outside the fashion world. Personally, I think my head would just blow off. I don't know." Remember this; it will matter later.

Then they moved on to Rami's designs. Nina praised the draped dress and criticized the coat. Michael pointed out the evening gown wasn't very practical and the fit in the hip area wasn't very flattering. Nina brushed that aside, calling the dress "a fantasy."

Then Heidi asked Rami why he should go to Fashion Week, and he replied, "This is who I am, this has been my calling since I was six years old." He sounded controlled but emotional.

This is the moment when, in my opinion, Rami won this competition. I don't think either collection dominated. Both were brilliant and interesting. I believe they chose Rami because in that moment he positioned himself as a fashion designer first, last, and foremost, whereas Chris identified himself as a fashion outsider. Michael, Nina, and Heidi even talked about how there have been successful designers who came from a costume design background, but Michael didn't look convinced.

Notice how I slipped the fact that Chris lost in there? It's because I couldn't really say it; I'm still in denial. I can't tell you how much I was pulling for Chris, and wanted to see him continue in the competition. I know he did show at Bryant Park. I'm sure this exposure did nothing but good for his career, and his classy post-auf interview didn't make him look too upset with the outcome.

But my interest in the final winner just went down a notch.

So, who will it be? Jillian, Christian, or, Rami, and why? Distract me from my grief with your guesses.

Metabaron's picture

Klump Junta Strikes Again

I totally saw this coming. The judges were ALWAYS biased against Chris. Rami while technically good showed no inspiration in this latest collection. Chris is ALWAYS Surprising. The Klump Junta is continuing to drag down Project Runway. The Winner last year paled in comparison to Ulie and that red haired woman. So we are left with boring Rami, ridiculous Christian and the WINNER Gillian. GILLIAN IS THE MOST TALENTED OF THE FINAL THREE.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Liz T's picture

i could not.......

i could not believe it when they announced RAMI was going to fashion week. i really thought it would be chris. shame.
Randommer's picture

I knew it. It was so obvious

I knew it. It was so obvious last episode that they wanted to oust Chris then and there, but Cavalli loved the dress so much. Rami was always going to the final, even though Chris's stuff is far more singular.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
duckiestoy's picture

It was painfully obvious

It was painfully obvious they wanted Rami in the finale competition.  I don't really know what they have against Chris but I doubt he could've done anything to satisfy the judges and get in the final three. 

Bill - Atlanta's picture

Well, I'm not sure if anyone

Well, I'm not sure if anyone else noticed. But it sure looked like Chris was getting ready to give Rami a congratulatory kiss when it was announced. I think during the break or even off camera, a possible relationship may have bloomed. They do make a cute couple.
Dalodnod's picture

Nose Jobs and Puffy Shirts

Chris will be fine. But I still don’t get the news that he “showed” at Fashion Week as a lure/plant/whatever to keep bloggers and fans off track. Did he show or NOT? According to Nina Garcia, she is hiring Chris to outfit her for next Halloween. Again I am confused. Is this a compliment? BTW’s: you Rami haters need to chill. He’s sex on a stick and yummy. Jillian still reminds me of every good nose job I saw in High School, and it will be no surprise if Christian “wins”: even though his stuff is way to similar to his former Boss Alexander McQueen’s unending, unwearable “Puffy Shirt” ensembles.
RJ88's picture

Sex on a stick, but no talent

Don't you see that's why people are so bitter about Rami staying and Chris going?  Rami may be sex on a stick, and that is the only reason he is one of the top three.  If Chris looked like Rami (or if Rami looked like Chris), Chris would have been going to Fashion Week officially. 

I don't know if it was Nina, Michael, Andy Coen, or all of the above that wanted sleep with Rami, or if the producers thought that gay men and straight women would be so turned by him they would forgive his total lack of creativity.  Either way, it was his sex appeal that kept him on the show, NOT talent.  

db's picture

RJ88 Is off base with this comment

"Rami may be sex on a stick, and that is the only reason he is one of the top three.  If Chris looked like Rami (or if Rami looked like Chris), Chris would have been going to Fashion Week officially. "

 RJ88--I think you're really off-base here.  Sex appeal has NEVER been the critieria on this show.  The finalists are NEVER the sexiest.  If you look at the past finalists it will certianly confirm this. 

Also, to say Rami has no talent is just silly.  His dresses are always stunning even if they're not especially innovative.

daverd's picture

Did he Show at Fashion week?

New York Fashion Week was 1 February to 8 February this year, over two weeks ago. It started even before the show in which Sweetpea was eliminated. Therefore to not spoil the suspence of who would be in the final three, all five designers showed a full collection during the fashion show. Live bloggers gave their impressions and Entertainment Weekly reviewd all five collections with pictures in their Feb. 22nd issue. I'm sure other magazines covered them as well. So while Sweetpea and Chris are not still in competition with the others, their collections were seen in New York during Fashion Week. In my opinion, if Chris had said the black stuff was Yak or Monkey hair or even fake hair and if he had included one of his colored outfits he would have beaten Rami. The judges fell out of love with Rami several episodes before this one.
proudtobedad's picture

Sweet Pea and Chris???

Does anyone know if we'll ever get to see their full 12 pieces on the show, or as dvd extras or anything? I'd love to see what they did... Or if you have a link to photos, that would be great!
trump_mom's picture

annoyed

i am really disappointed. i love Chris and what is really annoying is that Rami is already an established designer. His clothes have been photographed on paris hilton, lindsey lohan and jessica alba, among others. why was he even allowed on the show? i do know that Chris showed way more intergrity and grace then Rami did. Rami criticized Chris' clothes. What an a** hole Since we all know that the reunion was filmed after fashion week, and the whole whose going to win charade between Rami and Chris was just a sham, it makes sense why Rami was acting all nice. he knew he had won. again.. what an ass... I still wonder tho why Chris was wearing an "R" around his neck during the reunion show...i hope that doesn't mean that Rami won the whole damn thing..UGH! Anyways, love you Chris!
dgchgo's picture

Jeff: Rami's boyfriend?

I've only watched the "Rami @ home" segment once, but it sounded to me as though he introduced Jeff as his boyfriend. Comments, anyone? 
Flame's picture

Re: "Now, let's confront

Re: "Now, let's confront the human hair issue. Chris used human hair to trim out several pieces in his collection. For some reason, this creeped out Tim, the judges, and many viewers. And I don't get it. "

Well, for me and most of the people with whom I have discussed this, much as we adore Chris, our initial instinctive reaction was total revulsion because it immediately brought back thoughts of the fabric, blankets, etc. the Nazis made of human hair.

That said, however, when I stopped and thought about it, I was fine with it, because like the many natural human hair wigs and hair extensions used these days, this hair was presumably obtained voluntarily, and the reason behind using it in these contexts comes from an entirely different place than those acts of horror.

daverd's picture

Pictures of Project Runway finale show.

I found over a 100 pictures of the finale collections at http://www.ambrel.net/2008/0208-projectrunway/index.html (sorry i don't know how to link it). Also a review and five pictures of each collection at http://fabsugar.com/102970. I found both by typing in 'project runway new york fashion week' on Google and they were many more links I didn't look at. Hope they satisfy.
db's picture

Rami deserved to win

The reactionary posts on this are pretty ridiculous. I really like Chris and I like his designs but Rami deserved to win as much as Chris. Both their designs (that we saw) were pretty amazing. I hate to see the venom spewed at Rami. The fact is--though the judges kept criticizing him for draping his dresses (even the ones he got knocked down for) were ALWAYS beautiful--even stunning. They looked great on the models and many women I know would love to wear them. The fact that we liked Chris so much shouldn't make us blind to Rami's atributes. Also, we don't know why he referred to the person we're assuming is his lover as his "friend." We shouldn't jump to some weird conclusion that he's closeted. I know other gay and straight couples that refer to their partners and "friend"--why are we all so quick to jump on these tiny things?