Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Ask the Flying Monkey! (November 09, 2009)

Q: I have to admit, being a Heroes fan, that I have a celebrity crush on Milo Ventimiglia. I was doing some digging and discovered that he played a gay teen in a collection of short films called Boys Life 2. However, just because an actor plays a character doesn't mean that the actor is supportive of said character. As such, I was wondering as to whether or not Milo has ever spoken openly about gay issues? Is he a friend or foe to the gay community? – Teddy, State College, PA

A: Another softball question! Maybe I won’t commit suicide after all.

Ventimiglia, who also played gay in the 2005 movie Cursed, is definitely a friend, at least if you believe him in his 2008 interview with The Advocate.

Milo Ventimiglia

As for me, I still haven’t quite forgiven the actor for the incredibly stereotypical gay character in one episode of the 2007 web series he directed, It’s a Mall World:


Hey, I feel much better about life now. Thanks, folks! (The Xanax helped.)

Let’s do this again next week, shall we?

A Note from the Monkey: Last week, I wrote that The Big Bang Theory’s Jim Parsons was straight. In the comments following that column, a person posted pictures of Jim attending a ceremony and on a red carpet with the same man they believed was his boyfriend. We asked Jim’s publicist if the actor was, in fact, straight and, if not, would he do an interview with us. The publicist said, “We don’t comment on our client’s private lives,” and Jim declined to do an interview at this time.

Have a question about gay male entertainment? Send it to aftereltonflyingmonkey@yahoo.com! (Please include your city and state and/or country.)

beero's picture

The

conservative vote, you know the ones that hate us the most..well maybe not so much in Britain but I am thinking this pertains to the USA mainly.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
I_cant_believe_its_not_butter's picture

The conservative is the

The conservative is the anti-gay vote.  The hypocrisy is the anti-gay vote. But they are not allies?

beero's picture

If you are gay

And work in politics Con or otherwise and you actively vote down reforms that would help gay people then you are the enemy and need to be outed, The only reasons a gay politico would voted down a bill to help homos would be if he was self hating or he was trying to appeal to the voters purely to keep his job.

 

You would be suprised at how many vote purely on that reason and not for the greater good of a country.

 

I personally have little to worry about in that respect as all the three major partys in the British parliment have openly gay MPs and are pro gay rights.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
mastertv's picture

About Matthew

I know he is ... since Traveler but I don't like the idea that some people try to out him.
mel's picture

Gossip

Now I feel kind of bad bringing the Jim Parsons photos up (even two times), I didn’t want him to feel uncomfortable. But I can’t lie I’m curious about the private life of my favorite actors/actresses/singers although I know it’s none of my business and they’ve the right to privacy. It’s just hard to live in a world filled with gossip magazines, TV shows, and internet sites and not love gossip. At least for me.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Scott Tracey's picture

Really Could Care Less

Although I could really care less if Matt is gay or not, out or not, I do have to say thanks for talking about it again. Why? Because logging onto AE and seeing shirtless Matt Bomer on the main page is a glorious thing.
Madeleine's picture

Rubbed the wrong way

I enjoyed this week's column, particularly because I admire and agree with AE's policy on outing (except for when it came to Adam Lambert). but this line really bothered me: "Get it together, Brent. You can do this. Just a few more questions to answer. Then you can commit suicide in peace." I've personally known people who have tried to commit suicide, and I don't think it's anything to joke about. At all. Ever.

 

You too can be saved by the blog! www.savedbytheblog14.blogspot.com 

I may be straight, but I'm not narrow.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
db's picture

Oh Madeleine please....

Most of us know people who have committed suicide or who have tried--and if I couldn't laugh about it I would kill myself.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Madeleine's picture

Well sorry for being sensitive!

One of my students recently tried to kill himself, and it really shook me up, so I just can't get why someone would make a joke about it.

You too can be saved by the blog! www.savedbytheblog14.blogspot.com 

I may be straight, but I'm not narrow.

Brent Hartinger's picture

I'm not making a joke about your friend's suicide

I'm sorry your friend attempted suicide. As others have said, we've all experienced that at one point, and it's imaginably sucky. But I wasn't writing literally. When someone says, "Oh, I could kill you!" they're not really saying they're going to kill that person, or saying that murder is funny.

 

But you're grieving. I get that. It's absolutely okay to be sensitive about these things. You have nothing to be sorry for.

 

Check out my new fantasy website: TheTorchOnline.com. It's like AfterElton.com for fantasy geeks! And I Twitter

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
Madeleine's picture

Thank you.

Yes, I got your private message, thank you for responding, as you are really the only person I wanted to hear from.

Yes, I realize that you weren't making a joke at my friend's expense, or that you weren't trying to be insensitive. I'm not even really trying to accuse you of that, as I understand it was meant lightly. I was articulating how I felt in response, so that you would know how some people (or maybe just me it seems) reacted. I meant no disrespect.

I realize that I'm more sensitive about this than others, and that everyone has their own boundaries. That's OK. But (like you said) I'm not sorry for how I reacted.

You too can be saved by the blog! www.savedbytheblog14.blogspot.com 

I may be straight, but I'm not narrow.

db's picture

Sorry if I sounded insensitive

I am very sorry that you're having to go through this.  I have, unfortunately, had a few people I knew succeed and it's the most horrible thing to wonder "why, could I have done something, etc... and unfortunately in many cases there is just no answer for that.  I hope your studient is doing better, it's good he wasn't successful.  But one of the few ways I've gotten through some really terrible experiences is through humor.  I would rather have even inappropriate, mistimed humor than no humor at all.
GaySpouseDotCom's picture

When Mr. Closet dates Mr. Out...

I think if you are kissing someone and there is photographic evidence and one of the kissed forthrightly confirms an existing or past relationship, then it is not fair to invalidate the years in the life of a non-actor to try to validate the ambition of an actor. Are you supposed to dismiss the out person to cover the other? And at that point how much is it just enabling the perpetuation of the idea that being gay/bi is bad? I personally cheer the out person who isn't ashamed to reflect the reality of their life. That said, I can understand a site like AE that wants to encourage actors to use it as a venue to come out not wanting to out anyone.
Brent Hartinger's picture

Just to be clear...

That's really not our motivation for our stand -- that we want to encourage actors to do interviews with us, so we treat them better. Sure, that might be a nice karmic reward someday, but the fact is, any major actor coming out is going to go to PEOPLE anyway. We take the stand we do for (1) legal reasons and (2) because it reflects our values.

 

 

Check out my new fantasy website: TheTorchOnline.com. It's like AfterElton.com for fantasy geeks! And I Twitter

beero's picture

To be fair

He's not making light of the pain you feel, Its just something people say. I say it, lots of people say it. We cannot censor and pussy foot around people and ourselfs for the sake of hoping never to hurt someone.

Sorry for your pain but nothing should ever be off limits to humor, that path can only lead to a people in fear of offending others and other people using it to control what we all say, and thats no way to live.

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
Madeleine's picture

Not sure this was addressed at me...

...but if it is, I think that there needs to be limits to humour. Certainly some topics, including sexual orientation and suicide are too personal to make jokes about?

You too can be saved by the blog! www.savedbytheblog14.blogspot.com 

I may be straight, but I'm not narrow.

Crawfish Po Boy's picture

That's great for you

I don't believe in censorship, ever and I think context/intent should always be a part of evaluating someone's comments. Always.

I don't believe there should be boundaries to what you can say in an article on this website or any other.  There is a cultural ethos we have here on A.E. about how we deal with nudity and profanity but beyond that it seems to be anything goes. 

I appreciate that you might not want to make jokes about certain topics vis a vis your own experience but myself and many other humans actually see humor as a way to deal with those topics that are tragic and depressing in our lives.

As someone who has struggled with depression since 2nd grade and more than once considered suicide (though happily never attempted) it is in fact the ability to laugh about it, make fun of it, tell "slitting my wrist" jokes that helps me deal.

I don't think I'm an anomaly in that regard.

Everyone is different but one of the most amazing qualities of human beings, I think, is to find comedy in tragedy and to joke our way out of the depths of despair.  Holocaust survivors joke about it because it's proof they are alive, they survived.  Women who have survived rape joke about it because it takes the power away from the rapist.

Again, if it's offensive to you then you definitely should not tell such jokes but you can't prescribe what is right or good or useful or appropriate or even funny to/for others.

Clearly we know enough about Brent to know that he wouldn't take ACTUAL suicide lightly but we also know that he has a bit of a snarky sense of humor so given the context and the messenger (as it were) I don't see why he'd need to be admonished or censored.

I respect your right to state your discomfort with his comment I just felt the need to offer a different view point

 

Average (5 votes):
see individual ratings
Madeleine's picture

Suicide jokes

These are just my own boundaries, I was just letting Brent know how I felt about the joke. Obviously I know he didn't intend it to be offensive, but I don't think intent makes up for consequences. If it did then I would have to stop telling people to shut up when they say "that's so gay" because they aren't intending it to be hurtful.

I find it interesting that I'm getting flack about censoring humour from readers on a site that takes gay jokes, or gay people being the punchline of jokes very seriously. Should we tell all those straight dudes who joke about their buddies being "fags" that it's OK because we can joke about ourselves? What about all those prison rape jokes? Guess we can't tell people those aren't funny since it's just a joke.

If you don't want to take offense to something, that's your perogative, but some people are hurt by jokes, and I don't think comedians have free right to insult people under the guise of humour. Racist jokes aren't funny, neither are homophobic ones and I would put suicide jokes in the same category.

I joke about serious situations too to relieve tension, but I have to draw the line somewhere. I think making a joke about suicide makes light of it, and having known friends who've tried to kill themselves I just don't think that's funny.

You too can be saved by the blog! www.savedbytheblog14.blogspot.com 

I may be straight, but I'm not narrow.

db's picture

Limits on humor

Personally, I think the minute we put limits on humor--say "these things are beyond the pale and cannot be made light of" all the bigots win.  I think sexual orientation and suicide are both open to humor.  If we can't laugh at these things they become so large as to be insurmountable.
beero's picture

I think we

Should just agree to disagree on that point then.
biotite's picture

Golden Girls

I LOVED golden girls. wondering what that did to me...I do fit perfecly on the akward and non-sporty type of gall. i'm laughing so hard imagining those evil old ladies plotting to turn a generation of boys gays. I do see a lot of crazy people taking this serius...some people just dont have a sense of humor. And Ahoy monkey so many "is he?" questions on the same editon you must be hyperventilating. sit back and have a banana split.
AddisonDewitt's picture

Shocking Rumor!

The rumor I keep hearing is that author and blogger Brent Hartinger is VERY gay and in a secret long term relationship with AfterElton.com editor Michael Jensen. Who knew a guy with a goatee and quite the masculine physique would be SO gay??!! I mean Snicks maybe... but Brent?! I am shocked! Monkey can you help me out?

------------------------------------------------------------

If I bring out the devil in you, he was there all along!

Legally married Sept 18, 2009. Wedded Oct 10,2009.

Average (7 votes):
see individual ratings
Brent Hartinger's picture

Show me the photo!

Even then, I may not comment. ;-)

 

 

Check out my new fantasy website: TheTorchOnline.com. It's like AfterElton.com for fantasy geeks! And I Twitter

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
AddisonDewitt's picture

Proof

I'll do you one better on this!  A private source pointed me toward this link which has a lot of videos adding fuel the fire. Check it out!

 http://www.afterelton.com/taxonomy/term/1205

------------------------------------------------------------

If I bring out the devil in you, he was there all along!

Legally married Sept 18, 2009. Wedded Oct 10,2009.

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
ceares's picture

Truthfully

we don't have the right to know most if not all of the things tabloids and on-line gossip sites post about celebrities. But, if they speculate about (presumed) straight celebrities and not about (presumed) gay ones then that not only screams hypocrisy, it says that being gay is such a terrible thing that even gossips won't talk about it. If Jennifer Aniston and Joe Blow are seen having coffee together, or hanging out at the pool or where ever, there is instant speculation about their relationship. One outing between two straight celebs and mags everywhere scream they're in love/eloping/having quints/whathaveyou.

Helicopters followed Brad Pitt and Angelina Jolie around when they were filming Mr. and Mrs. Smith trying to catch something just on rumors they were attracted to each other, even though Brad was still married. Yet how often did Lindsey Lohan and Samantha Ronson go out together, hold hands, snuggle, frickin move in together and it was all 'shhh, don't say that'. You had Lance Bass, going out and to gay bars with an openly gay man and still, 'we'll wait until he says he's gay'. Any of those instances could just be friends hanging out but only the same sex ones are taboo to speculation by the media. By acting like it's a horrible, shameful thing that will ruin an actors career and even their life it anyone even suggests it, then that's exactly what it remains.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Bill Smith's picture

Brent, does PBS count as a network?

If PBS counts as a network, then the throat-scorching, mind-blowing kiss between Richard "John Boy Walton" Thomas and a 27 year old Jeff Daniels at the beginning of the filmed version of out playwright Lanford Wilson's "Fifth of July" in the summer of 1982 predates the other "first kisses." This play also starred a young Cynthia Nixon and won Swoosie Kurtz a Tony Award. On Broadway, Jeff Daniels got to kiss Christopher Reeve every night when he played the Richard Thomas role (hotcha!!!!!). The play was remarkable not just for the kiss, but because it portrayed the gay couple as just another couple in a wild and wacky family, ala "Modern Family." If you haven't seen it, it's awesome.
Brent Hartinger's picture

PBS is definitely a network...

But they're a network of affiliates that all choose their own (sometimes different) programming. I guess I would ask: how many affiliates did this play on? Knowing how gun-shy PBS is (and was in the 80s/90s), I'd really be curious!

 

But mostly, I find this endlessly fascinating that just when I think I've pinpointed the "first," someone says, "No, wait!" It really IS a complicated question! Thanks for sharing.... :-)

 

Check out my new fantasy website: TheTorchOnline.com. It's like AfterElton.com for fantasy geeks! And I Twitter

Bill Smith's picture

American Playhouse

It was part of the American Playhouse series, which showcased a lot of gay-themed play adaptations, such as "Andre's Mother," "Cat on a Hot Tin Roof" (the Jessica Lange/Tommy Lee Jones version), and "Tru," so my guess is that it played on a fairly wide range of affiliates.  It even played on Alabama Public Television, where as a scared lonely 17 year old kid in rural Alabama I learned for the first time that I wasn't the only boy in the world who wanted to kiss another boy.  That teleplay is one of those "means the world to me" things, right up there with "Brokeback Mountain" "Leaves of Grass," and afterelton.com.

 

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
bannik101's picture

I know it wasn't the first

but it was the best - for me at least.

Tales of the City, also on (some braver) PBS stations.  It was the first time I saw two men "really kiss" or at least really kiss the way I knew men would and could.  It was so sweet then I thought "Oh my God, this is TV!"  I guess you could argue that it was so WOW that it took me out of the story but not really.  It was remembering that this was TV and not a night at the club that made me take pause.

I ran to the phone as soon as the episode was over, called my local (DC) station, and thanked them for showing it.

bambino italiano's picture

Who among us have not gone through some personal tragedies?

Unless we isolate ourselves from the world. Somewhere,somehow, someone is going to make light of a situation that will offend someone. I do not know Brent personally, however, I read enough of his columns to know that his intention is not to make light of a tragic situation. It's not consistence with what I have read from his work so far. If we are going to social networking, regardless if it's on internet or on a person to person basis, we can either ignore or see shadows lurking everywhere.You are certainly entitled to your opinion. However, I will definitely believe that the out of context statement made by Brent was not directed at you or anyone who experienced suicides tragedies. The fact that you took exceptions to that statement is because you are still feeling the pain for your loss and for that my heartfelt condolences to you.
Samwise's picture

"some of my best friends are

"some of my best friends are the internet!" LOL! Consider this quote stolen.
Allyndra's picture

Ditto! I thought the same

Ditto! I thought the same thing.

Liz T's picture

outing, outing, outing.....

oh man. outing, outing, outing. i have come to realize that actors act for a living and thats why they are famous. PERIOD. people see their movies/shows for them, not for who they are dating in real life, or whatever ...

but as i have said before, it's very tricky. I am out and would be happy if closeted actors didn't exist, but...they do. mainly for the reason of their career being ruined. then again, it's like "oh if they came out, they could change the industry, change minds, yadda yadda, be more happy with themselves..."

I sometimes have to take a step back and put myself in their shoes...sort of.

I'm not a public figure, but i also am not out to every person i come across. there will be people who will never know i am gay and i have my reasons, like anyone, for not telling them.

that makes me sound like a hypocrite then when i go on about how proud i am of being who i am, right? then why don't i just come out to everyone i cross paths with?

not as simple as people think it should be. it's very tricky. therefore, i've realized i can no longer be upset when someone is closeted or decides not to comment.

I have no room to damn these people

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
David Ehrenstein's picture

There's a huge difference

between ordinary everyday gay people and people in "the public eye." If you're going to be in show business it means that you want everyone to know your face and your name. And if you're successful they're going to want to know who's behind that face and that name. It's for this reason that actors hire publicists -- to "manage" their image in the way that best suits them. Complicating matters, howver, is a media culture that subsumes EVERYTHING. Those photos of Bomer are "out there," and so are postings about him. It's a bell that cannot be unrung. What's done with it on this site is another matter. If his show features gay characters we'll talk about it , no matter what the sexual orientation of the actors involved. As for Bomer himself, the ball's now in his court. His "name" is out there. But the "details" are not. Will they be of interest? What will he have to say? Stay tuned.
Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
StuartAlanJones's picture

I would like to see every gay doctor come out, every gay lawyer,

every gay architect come out, stand up and let that world know. That would do more to end prejudice overnight than anybody would imagine. I urge them to do that, urge them to come out. Only that way will we start to achieve our rights." - Harvey Milk (1977)

And in our celebrity-obsessed culture, I think it's reasonable to add gay celebrities to that list.

I don't agree with forcing someone out of the closet, unless they're actively anti-gay, but I can't help but think of the the phrase: "If you're not part of the solution, you're part of the problem", especially after watching this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tuWJ6LQ9R4U

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
I Miss D'Anna's picture

double post

double post
I Miss D'Anna's picture

one more thing about outing

The argument that being in a high-profile career means that one surrenders any right to privacy commits the naturalistic fallacy -- that is, it concludes "ought" from "is." We can indeed correctly say that someone in the public eye will have his private life made public, but that says nothing about how things should be. If invading someone's privacy is wrong, then it's wrong, regardless of our current state of affairs.

  I think it's fair to say that it's a shitty time to be alive. From Glenn Beck at the extreme to the more common experience of a society that's a little too cold and corporate. I can't imagine saying that society's disregard for a celebrity's privacy carries any moral value, or sets any worthwhile precedent for how we should treat gay celebrities, once you think about how bad the rest of society is.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
dback's picture

Holy crud, Ernest Hemingway was adorable!!

Who KNEW?!? Certainly not I. Damn, another one for my "born 70 years too early" list. (Tab Hunter and 60's singer Chris Montez are both high on that list as well.)
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Joe's picture

Matt Bomer

I feel bad for him. I'm sure he just wants to have a successful acting career, and now this has come up, and it could de-rail his career.

However, how widely talked about are these pictures? I mean, are we just a tempest in a teapot here? Are we only talking about this on gay-dominated websites? Provided this never makes the mainstream press, he could just continue to ignore it with little impact on his career.

I like to think that if I were to become famous, I would be out from Day 1, proudly stating who I am. But then I think, wow, you are right there, ready to grab the brass ring, starring on a tv show, about to potentially rake in millions and millions of dollars, but that could all die this instant if I come out. Will it kill me to wait a few years, so that I can secure my fortune first? I can see why they don't want anything to disrupt their plans.

Now, if this becomes tabloid fodder, his best bet would be to immediately confirm it and say that he doesn't want it to be the only thing that defines him (the TR Knight defense). Trying to hide it once it goes mainstream will only make things worse for him.  

Lior's picture

Rumor

I heard that Brent, of The Flying Monkey fame, was gay. Is this true? ;-)
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
James Hillis's picture

This...

...made me laugh. ty
BreckRoy's picture

About those Bomer pictures...

I went to the University of Texas in Austin, TX (with some of Bomer's Klein H.S. classmates, actually, as we're the same age, but he obviously wasn't a topic for conversation then) where a lot of people are figuring stuff out and others are just enjoying the ride. They also get drunk a lot, cause that's what kids from party schools often do, and there were lots of men on men and women on women kisses whilst said drunkeness was going on. Often as part of a bet or drinking game and less often but still sometimes with a camera that captured it (I'm sure it's even more common now with cell phone cameras and video). And as anyone who has ever seen two drunk straight guys kiss, it, like a KiH or SNL skit, get's kind of raunchy (they overdo it with the tongue and the open mouth for humorous purposes). SO...Bomer, who is clearly drunk off his ass in the second, full face photo, open mouth kissed a dude. Maybe he's gay, maybe he's not...but he's not openly out. Leave the poor kid alone!
Gabrielle's picture

Matthew Bomer

I dont see why Matthew Bomer is considered ''closeted''. Being in the closet to me is -- blatantly lying about your sexuality, keep denying that you're gay, having a fake relationship with a beard, etc. He has done NONE of those things. He just chose not to talk about his sexual orientation. It's his business and I respect his choice. Plus, considering that if an actor is out in his personal life, why is he considered ''closeted'' by the general public? Do all gay actors owe us an ''I'm Gay'' headline on the cover of People magazine?

 

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
waz's picture

British TV Gay Kiss

As a 40something gay man I can clearly remember gay kissing in The Naked Civil Servant  (about the life of Quentin Crisp) which was shown in 1975 (The follow-up An Englishman In New York is due to be aired soon)

I also remember a TV serial called Penmarric shown in 1979 that featured lots of gay kissing.

I don't remember it causing too much fuss at the time either? I'd imagine British people older than I can recall shows from the 1960's?

Darrien's picture

Hmmm

I think the first gay kiss on TV was in a Play for Today back in 1971. But I can't remember the name of it. Very vaguely, I think it was about the love that dare not speak its name set in a gritty Northern town. The odd thing for a Play for Today, from that time, is that it might have had a happy or an oblique/might-be-happy ending. I keep on thinking it starred John Salthouse or John Duttine, but I'm probably getting my Plays for Today all mixed up.

On a tangent, the first actor to do full-frontal male nudity on the BBC was the incredibly beautiful Christopher Neame in 1973/74. Again, it was a Play for Today and I think it was called something like The Spider's Web. Unfortunately, I never saw it. Which is a great pity, because I met him several year later and damn I would have loved to have seen him naked! An entirely pleasant, generous and genuinely kind (straight) man - but sheesh he rocked sex appeal to its foundations. (Sorry about that, I was just lost in my own dream there for a second.)