Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Ask the AfterElton Flying Monkey! (June 10, 2008)

Q: I just saw Spring Awakening. I thought everyone involved was so talented, and the small gay storyline was sweet. The Monkey recently listed his favorite gay movies, so I was wondering if you had a list of favorite gay plays. I do not mean plays with just gay sensibilities (like Hairspray), but shows with actual gay storylines or important gay characters. Much like Hollywood, it is surprising there are so many gays working behind the scenes and yet so few gay-inclusive works. – Joey, Portland, OR

A: Great question! I confess I haven’t seen every gay play on stage (and as Jeffrey proves, movie adaptations aren’t the same thing!), but I’ve seen quite a few.

(For the record, I liked Spring Awakening’s music and energy, but I didn’t know what to make of its clunky, clichéd plot (based on ancient source material). Ironic? Sure didn’t seem like it. I confess the rapturous reviews didn’t resonate with me at all.)

Anyway, I’m ranking the plays I’ve seen into three categories. They are:

Gay plays I loved – deliriously, passionately, enduringly!

Angels in America

Angels in America: A Gay Fantasia on National Themes
When Pigs Fly
La Cage Aux Folles
Falsettoland
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof *
The Glass Menagerie *
Lonely Planet
Avenue Q

* Major characters are gay, but closeted

Gay plays I Thought Were Seriously Overrated

Spring Awakening

Everything I’ve ever seen by Terrence McNally (including Love! Valor! Compassion!)
Rent
Spring Awakening

Gay Plays I Didn’t Like Much at All

March of the Falsettos
A Language of Their Own
Naked Boys Singing!

Discuss!

Have a question about gay male entertainment? Ask the Monkey!

 

j U d E's picture

Thore and Jo's reaction.

Thank you Brent!

I was wondering how you got to hear from Jo Weil knowing about his 29th place on the hot 100 list! That's cool, he reads AE (or knows about it) and wrote to you! And Thore has reacted too! That's really awesome! Bravo!

Hallo Thore und Jo - wenn ihr dies liest, seid gegrüsst von einem Fan aus Brüssel! *grin*

----------------------------------------------------- 

R.I.P. - Heath Ledger [1979 - 2008]

Dane Hill's picture

Jo and Thore...

I do believe that I liebe them even more now. Shiste.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
BSGnut's picture

Thore's comment is so cute!

I love how he says it's "nearly incredible."

Both these guys just exude charm at every turn. I hope AE is working on an interview (please, please, please).

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Joseph's picture

Yes, an interview, please!!!

And I think I just fell in love with both of them just a little bit more!

Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
LolaRuns's picture

Writer interview

I thnk what would interest me even more is if one could get an interview with the writers or the production company. No offense to the actors, but I think it would be intensely interesting to see what exactly the writers were trying to achieve with a certain storyline and how they perceive the characters
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
j U d E's picture

Tricky interview

Quote:
I thnk what would interest me even more is if one could get an interview with the writers or the production company. No offense to the actors, but I think it would be intensely interesting to see what exactly the writers were trying to achieve with a certain storyline and how they perceive the characters

I agree! That really would be interesting.

I too, would love an interview with Jo and/or Thore though. But I think it's going to be tricky to have just Thore for instance, as his English does not seem advanced enough. Jo on the other hand (from what I read here) is apparently more at ease, not only in English, but generally. I think that was obvious in the interviews or tiny (Christmas) clips we've seen.

But the bestest.. would be writers and both actors, but I guess that's too much of a good thing to hope for. Still, I'm sure something should be possible! I mean, now that we know that Thore and Jo know about AE and that they know how to contact AE!

I wonder though, how much the writers actually welcome so much hype around their characters. It sure puts more pressure on them too, or do they ignore the fact that this Ollian-phenomena is taking place?

I think it's just awesome and I'm dying to know what all conerned have to say about it. Jo and Thore seem to be proud (and they have every right to be!), but I'm sure for Thore at least, it must be weird to have so much attention suddenly, as he is fairly new to the acting-business. I hope he'll be able to cope with it and doesn't lift off the ground and gets all bizarre.. if you know what I mean.

Guys, keep your feet on the ground! We love you, but do not get bigheaded, 'kay? :o)

----------------------------------------------------- 

R.I.P. - Heath Ledger [1979 - 2008]

LolaRuns's picture

I think that's why writers

I think that's why writers (not just VL, but also any show, HO, ATWT, etc) would be more interesting to me.

 

As for hype, from everything I have heard the VL writers aren't the kind to be swayed much by audience reactions (particularly not of the fickle internet kind) in either the or the bad way too much. I also believe that within Germany the hype around Tom and Ulli was much larger than anything Ollian related has been so far and that they also got certain amounts of international attention for their lesbian couples and the enthusiasm of the fans was definitely comparable.

 

So while I'm sure it is nice to know that a story is loved, but I do not get the impression that it would be this out of the ordinary for them. Particularly since internet attention does not affect their ratings and therefore doesn't really gain them all that much.

 

Still, it would be very interesting to read their thoughts, how they are writing the story, what they think the reaction from their (non-internet) audience is, whether the way such stories are received have changed compared to the times of Tom and Ulli, whether being on a public channel allows them to always have at least on LGTB storyline, whether they think that there are still actors in Germany who don't really like playing gay characters, whether they watch any of the other soaps with gay storylines, whether there are any things they would never write for a gay character, whether they have ever included any real life experiences into a storyline etc.

 

I don't think that language should be that much of a problem though. They could always have somebody do the interview in German and then translate it back. And again, this is not just about VL, hearing from the writers of a show is always interesting.

Maxine's picture

How great is it that Jo and

How great is it that Jo and Thore both responded to being in the top 100 of hottness. And how brilliant is it that they know about, and I suspect browse this site.

I've read that Jo's English is somewhat stronger than Thore, so bless his sweet little heart for responding in English. And that 'nearly incredible' quote of his is so damn cute!!

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
nordic balance's picture

Jo's English

Jo worked as an actor in something in the States for a while, so it doesn't surprise me that his English is probably pretty good.
Terence Steiner's picture

The Invention of Love

I would like to also include Tom Stoppard's The Invention of Love, a heartfelt play about A.E. Houseman. It was especially surprising for me since Stoppard is neither gay and is usually and decidedly not heartfelt.

But, Brent, I think Tom Wingfield is a bit of a stretch.

 

 

dgchgo's picture

I thought he meant the Gentleman Caller!

When I read the list with the asterisks, I thought, "Which character in The Glass Menagerie is the closeted gay?" And, really, it could be either Tom (who is the stand-in for Tennessee Williams, after all) or Jim, the Gentleman Caller.
Brent Hartinger's picture

I saw a production of GLASS

I saw a production of GLASS where Tom was played as subtext-y "gay," and now I can't imagine the play any other way. Honestly, all the lines read perfectly as if Tom is gay. That's why he has no interest in women and why he can't tell Amanda where he's been and why he eventually has to leave...Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com
GaySpouseDotCom's picture

Great Gay Plays or Musicals

From the ones I have seen, I would also include among great plays or musicals with gay themes and/or characters:

  • I Am My Own Wife
  • A New Brain
  • Bent
  • Visiting Mr. Green
  • The Laramie Project
  • Take Me Out
  • A Man of No Importance
dgchgo's picture

Good choices

I haven't seen all of the ones you mention, but I have seen I Am My Own Wife, The Laramie Project, and Take Me Out. Brilliant, all of them.
Terence Steiner's picture

The Laramie Project

I would definitely agree with The Laramie Project as being amongst the greatest. Thank you for mentioning it.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
cosmolake's picture

One more moment in gaycentric theater

All of these are good to great examples of theater that brought LGBT lives into the light.  One more I would offer for the list is Torch Song Trilogy.  Who knew that Fierstein could predict the future, that we would see in our lifetime significant numbers of gay men and lesbians migrating toward nesting and raising kids?  He should have bought lottery tickets.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
afhickman's picture

"It's just one f**king thing after another!"

afhickman

"It takes a village (to make Village People)"

Love "The Invention of Love" and practically all things Stoppard, but my favorite gay play, bar none, is "The History Boys," by Alan Bennett. It also made a great film (the quote in my subject line is uttered by Russell Tovey). I recently saw a performance of a Harold Pinter play called "The Collection" that was also quite good. It reminded me of something I'd seen on TV, and when I looked it up I was reminded of an earlier production (1976) that starred Malcolm McDowell and Lawrence Olivier as the lovers, with Alan Bates and Helen Mirren in supporting roles. It was obviously rather ahead of its time! The production I saw starred Richard Coyle, Gina McKee, and Timothy West.
Terence Steiner's picture

Simon Gray's Butley

If you liked Pinter's The Collection I recommend you watch Simon Gray's Butley with Alan Bates and Jessica Tandy. It is also out on DVD.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Smartypants's picture

Don't forget 5th of July

Lanford Wilson was including strong gay characters long before many other playwrights. His "5th of July" has a loving gay couple, one of whom is a paraplegic Vietnam vet. Another fun show that hinges on an unexpected gay relationship is "Deathtrap". Interestingly, Christopher Reeve played gay in both shows -- the Broadway debut of 5th of July and the film version of Deathtrap.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Apollux's picture

The Full Monty

"The Full Monty" had a first-closeted-then-out gay couple among the main characters, just like the movie it is based on... And they get the best romantic song of the play.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Joseph's picture

Gay Plays and Sexy Presidents

One of my favorite gay plays is "Butley"--the 1974 film version has Alan Bates brilliantly recreating his stage triumph as the misanthropic gay literature professor. And I thought it was generally conceded that the sexiest U.S. President was Franklin Pierce? Though I suppose if you have a thing for bears, U.S. Grant or Grover Cleveland might be more your speed....

 

 

 

Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/

dback's picture

Franklin Pierce & other thoughts

Future epitaph: "It seemed like a good idea at the time."

 I remember seeing a picture of Franklin Pierce in one of my kids books about the Presidents, and lingering over his picture.  He had gorgeous curly dark hair and really beautiful features.  Unfortunately his personal life was beset by tragedy, and he wasn't a very good President.  (To cut him a little slack, the Civil War was looming, and probably very few Presidents could've finessed that situation.)  I'm surprised that no one mentioned that, aside from his looks, James Buchanan is often rumored to have been gay, and had a relationship with a man in Washington D.C. (nicknamed "Miss Nancy").

"Fifth of July" was the first gay-themed play I ever saw, and I never quite recovered from the cable showing of it with a steamy kiss between Richard Thomas and a shirtless, sweaty Jeff Daniels.  So I'm very fond of it.  But I'm also fond of lots of the others mentioned, including "Naked Boys Singing"--hey, it's exactly what it says it is.  (I was in the front row of that one with the adorable and very talented Tomm Orr singing "Perky Little Porn Star"--when he started doing gymnastics and flips, and his prodigious endowment started swinging, I thought, "Great, how'm I going to explain it at work if I get a black eye?")

My favorite gay-themed plays are "Him" "Is This Seat Taken" "The Isoceles Heart" "The Duboce Triangle" "Thus With A Kiss" "Darts and Flowers" "Pure"...oh wait a minute, I wrote or co-wrote all those.  :)  Who knew!

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
dgchgo's picture

President Buck & Honestly Fugly Abe

So sad that our two gay presidents (at least the ones we know about) fall into the "fugly" category. At least Abe was one of our great presidents (and he did have those thighs!).
dgchgo's picture

Those are my choices?!

Your comment, Joseph, re: our "bear" presidents reminds me of that line in Postcards from the Edge, where Shirley MacLaine tells Meryl Streep she could have had Joan Crawford or Lana Turner as a mother. Paraphrasing Meryl's reply: "Those are my choices?! Ulysses ... or Grover?"
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Joseph's picture

I am quite honestly...

...rolling on the floor laughing my a** off!!! Thank you!

Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
dgchgo's picture

My job here is done

I'm totally about making you ROFL[Y]AO, Joseph!
David Ehrenstein's picture

That production of "The Collection"

that you mention with Alan Bates, Laurence Olivier, Malcolm McDowell and Helen Mirren is absolutely superb. I do believe it's available on home video. It's my very favoirte Olivier performance, especially for the moment when he explains of McDowell "He's a slum boy you see. I happeneed to be in a slum one day and. . .there he was." While not actually being gay himself (though I suspect he's a Kinsey 2) Sir Harold is one of the very few straights who understands the dynamics of gay relationships. (See also The Servant and his grievously underrated remake of Sleuth.) And yes I worship the ground Alan Bennett walks on as well. In additon to The History Boys (with the yummy Russell Tovey and the heartbreaking Samuel Barnett) there's his superb screenplay for An Englishman Abroad directed by John Schlesinger and starring my favorite bisexual, Alan Bates.
afhickman's picture

Don't ge me started on that "Tea and Sympathy"

afhickman

"It takes a village (to make Village People)"

A movie that should have been a play, but wasn't, is "Sunday Bloody Sunday," which was also directed by Schleshinger.  Maybe it could be rewritten as an opera, like "Brokeback"?  By the way, we've forgotten to list "A Taste of Honey" as one of the breakthrough gay plays.  And, while we're at it, we might as well include "Hair," which prominently featured a gay/bi character or two.  Someone did mention Joe Orton, but forgot to specify "Entertaining Mr. Sloan." 

To top it all off, I still find "The Ritz" funny!

dgchgo's picture

Speaking of "The Ritz"

I didn't like The Ritz (the movie -- I've never seen the play) all that much, but Rita Moreno's rendition (massacre?) of "Everything's Coming Up Roses" is priceless. In fact, when Patti finished singing that number (brilliantly) on the Tonys, I leaned over to my friend and said, "Well, she's no Rita Moreno ... ." That's what way too many Showtune Nights at SideTrack will do to your train of thought.
dgchgo's picture

Boy, do you have a great job!

Dear Esteemed Monkey --

Thanks for the information from Cameron Graham of Paradise Falls and The Day Laborers. I'll have to catch up with DiGrassi now, too; Cameron must have been just a teenager when he did that!

I can totally see the resemblance with Martin Sheen, not only in looks, but in the stillness and naturalness of their acting and the depth that they bring to their characters.

BTW: How fun it must be for you, Monkey, to have had the opportunity to talk with all these wonderful actors through the years! My avatar is turning green with envy.

Brent Hartinger's picture

It is truly an honor

And oftentimes very very fun! Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
David Ehrenstein's picture

Other Gay Plays of Note

The Madness of Lady Bright by Lanford Wilson.

As Is by William M. Hoffman.

The Destiny of Me by Larry Kramer.

The West Street Gang by Doric Wilson.

 Suddenly Last Summer by Tennessee Williams

 

and the collected works of Joe Orton

Alxmouse's picture

Stamos in Caberet

I saw John Stamos (who plays the bisexual/gay MC) and Molly Ringwald play the lead characters in Cabaret at the Studio on 54th a few years back. It might have been the wine or the chocolate cookie but the performance brought a tear to my eye as the curtain closed.
j U d E's picture

My Night With Reg?

I saw it in London a few years ago and it has been aired on BBC since.

----------------------------------------------------- 

R.I.P. - Heath Ledger [1979 - 2008]

Frank's picture

Just came back from London

where I've seen 'Avenue Q'. I think it's one of the best shows I've ever seen and ranks right after Wicked. It was so funny and so true. I also agree about the Glass Menagerie. For me too, Tom was a closeted gay from the beginning, especially as Williams said that he based the character of Tom on himself.

 

 

As for the interviews: Why not try to get an interview with out actor Dennis Grabosch who plays gay Roman Wild on AWZ? He's been living in London for years and speaks English fluently, so there shouldn't be a language problem at all.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
afhickman's picture

Tennessee Williams (TW) IS Tom Wingfield (TW)

afhickman

"It takes a village (to make Village People)"

And, no, that doesn't stand for Torchwood. Although the Woodies probably would have appreciated Tennessee's taste for the macabre. Tennessee Williams was born Thomas Lanier Williams. He started life in Mississippi but moved to St. Louis with his family as a teen. Hence his nickname, Tennessee. [I'm joking!] His mother was a Southern belle and his sister was mentally ill (unlike Laura, who had pleurosis). Sound like anyone we know? The parallels are pretty hard to ignore.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings