Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

IMHO "Merlin" (1: 9): The Sword and the Stoner

I confess I'm still getting used to this whole "hoyay" thing. Gay subtext, I understand. But projected gay subtext where it can all be in the mind of the viewer? That's ridiculously open-ended, isn't it?

Still, even on the "wishful thinking" front, there wasn't much hoyay between Merlin and Arthur in "Excalibur," last night's episode of Merlin (although Merlin did admit, "You could say there's a bond between us").

Still, there were some serious Brokeback-Camelot sparks flying between Arthur and King Uther, who said to him, "You mean more to me than anything I know — more than my own kingdom, and certainly my own life."

Granted, the characters are father and son, which is admittedly very creepy, but if fans of Supernatural can overlook the fact that they're supposed to be brothers, I can overlook that.

And did you catch the way the Black Knight was eyeing Arthur?

Okay, that last comment was (1) truly icky, and (2) entirely made up, because, well, the Black Knight was a "wraith" — a dried and desiccated husk of a body that had been risen from the dead by the witch Nimueh for the purpose of getting revenge on Uther, who had killed the knight 20 years before.

Still, he looks pretty good for a desiccated husk, don't you think? 

I actually thought the episode worked quite well — which is a good thing because, frankly, some of the show's recent installments stank more than, well, a dried and desiccated husk that had been dead 20 years.

Or would that stink? Maybe not. Anyway, I digress.

What's fun about these "before-they-were-famous" retellings is having familiar plot elements show up in unexpected ways, and that's what happened again last night. When Arthur impetuously (as usual) challenges the Black Knight, both Uther and Merlin plot for a way to get him out of the fight (since, naturally, you can't kill someone who's already dead, so Arthur is certain to lose).

Merlin has the dragon help him create a magical sword with which Arthur can kill the knight — but it comes with a serious warning: only Arthur must wield the sword, or disaster will ensue. Kind of like when Adam Sandler does serious roles (or comedic ones, for that matter).

Meanwhile, Uther drugs Arthur and — of course! — insists on using the aforementioned magical sword. The dragon is so upset that he demands that Merlin hide the sword somewhere where no one can ever find it — like in a remote lake where we, the Camelot-savvy viewer, know Arthur will eventually get it back from the Lady of the Lake.

In short, we've got some nicely satisfying plot complications superimposed on top of the existing legend of Excalibur. 

Plus, we got to finally learn why Uther has such a stick up his butt about magic (because he made a deal with Nimueh to make sure he got an heir, but the price for his wish ended up being the life of his wife). I'm glad to know this, because Uther's irrational hatred of magic was really starting to annoy me. I'm also much less likely to do that whole "wish-bone" thing every Thanksgiving.

Oh, and the episode also had Anthony Stewart Head shirtless, which is a good thing if you're a fan (as I am). Anyone up for writing some Anthony Stewart Head/Victor Garber "over-50" slash-fiction? I'd read that.

Darrien's picture

Dessicated husks

All the dessicated husks in Britain look good. I put it down to us having a National Health Service. I promise you, once you've got universal health care in the US, it'll revolutionise your zombie movies. The ability to get collagen injections on a fixed-cost prescription charge means they're now dried-out hunks rather than animated corpses. One more reason to vote for healthcare reform...

Your line - 'I'm also much less likely to do that whole "wish-bone" thing every Thanksgiving' - after a hard day at work made me laugh like a drain. So many thanks.

Brent Hartinger's picture

And you made me laugh too!

So we're even... :-)

 

 

Check out my new fantasy website: TheTorchOnline.com. It's like AfterElton.com for fantasy geeks! And I Twitter

E.A.Y.'s picture

I'll admit that I can't

I'll admit that I can't remember any specific mometns of Ho-yay, but I thought this episode had a fair amount.  After something Merlin said, my mom, who normally just rolls her eyes at me whenever I mention slash, even commented "Wow. He's in love with Arthur."  So, even my mother sees it!  lol

Also, who've got to love the seen where Gaius gives Arthur the date-rape drug.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Chris's picture

I'll be honest, I didn't

I'll be honest, I didn't really see any Hoyay (nice term, btw!) until I came to episodes 10 and 11. Then the Hoyay was right in my face. It was kind of obvious. So, I guess wait to you see those two episodes back to back in two weeks. Those are the episodes that everyone points to as validation for A/M hoyay.
deegeezee's picture

I don't see why

this show gets weekly write-ups.  i'm as big a fan of sub-par fantasy series as much as the next gay (hello, i watch "The Seeker"), but this show has yet to show any noteworthy subtext, and there are other shows on TV that have ACTUAL gay actors, characters, and plotlines... not just innuendo.  (e.g. The Closer).  and i apologize -- to each her/his own and all that -- but i just can't get into this program!  and aren't its ratings supposed to be abysmal?
Darrien's picture

ahem

It does have actual gay actors in the cast. Obviously, the most open one isn't young and pretty, but he's still gay.
Bountiful's picture

good and bad

The hoyay annoys me. (What? Did I really just type that?) Arthur is such a jerk. And I know that's the point. He's supposed to be a jerk to make Merlin's plight more sympathetic. But shouldn't he have some redeeming qualities for Merlin to be so fond of him. And there clearly is real affection, there. I simply don't understand why.

But I liked the set up of this episode. I liked that it wasn't completely predictable, and it kept the tension high. On the other hand, the big mixup would have been solved if Gaius and Merlin simply used some basic communication skills! Considering that they are both on team magic,  and that Gaius is supposed to be Merlin's mentor, shouldn't they each consult with each other about important decisions? Recently it seems as if Gaius' role in the cast is to get in Merlin's way, rather than help him.