News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Gay TV Recap: "Picking Teams" is Greek's gayest ep yet


There are some spoilers below, though nothing major. The ep isn't available yet on ABC Family's site, but it should be eventually, as well as on iTunes.

Last night's "Picking Teams" was the gayest episode of ABC Family's quietly groundbreaking college dramedy Greek thus far, with our until-now stealth gay frat pledge (Calvin) revealing a little about his family and coming out to his first friend at school. Overall the episode was gay-friendly to a fault (more on that later) and a good sign that the gay supporting character is considered more than set dressing.

The main story dealt with a common underdog theme: not getting picked for sports. The two rival fraternities are locked in a competition (remember the beer pong episode) fueled mostly by posturing over a girl, but we won't get into that. The important thing is that our hero, Rusty (Jacob Zachar) and his only friend Calvin (Paul James) are both expected to play intermural hockey for their respective houses.

In an unexpected turn, Calvin's dad shows up. Uh-oh: typical scenario, right? The gay guy is bad at sports and his clueless dad is pressuring him to play because he's afraid his son is a pansy? Actually, no -- much as the show to this point has handled Calvin's story a bit differently than most gay teen plots, here the situation is unexpected. It turns out that Calvin was an All-State hockey player, and although he now doesn't have much interest in the sport, he was actually a total jock, which made his father proud.

But there's another twist...

Dad knows that Calvin is gay and has no problem with it. In fact, he's pretty supportive and talks about civil unions and stuff. Sure, he obviously still wants his son to be a "man's man," but it's one of those rare occasions where gay and manly aren't immediately dismissed as being mutually exclusive. Dad wants Calvin to get all the great experiences and friendships out of his fraternity that he did when he was there (if not the chair-sex that he rather ickily alludes to early-on), and he worries that Calvin's not being out in his frat might keep him from fully enjoying his time there.

Calvin replies that when he came out in high school he suddenly became "that gay hockey player" and he doesn't want that to happen again, because he hopes that being gay isn't the most interesting thing about me (he must be reading T.R. Knight's press releases!). But by the end of the episode, Calvin decides to tell Rusty, and the two have a very sweet scene as Rusty wrestles with processing the information while still making it very clear to his friend that he cares about him. We're left with a sense that Calvin has a lot of tough choices and hurdles ahead of him as he navigates his frat and school as a gay man, but he has his wits and his friend as support.

This was one of the most optimistic depictions of a coming-out that I've ever seen on TV. There were no tears or fights or disowning or suicide attempts or any of that -- if anything, the gay story is being handled too well, if there is such a thing. My boyfriend and I turned to each other several times during Calvin's scenes with his dad and said, "Yeah, right!" -- but hey, maybe things are getting easier for kids these days to come out earlier and with more conviction, and really, we've seen the agonized approach plenty of times by now. Greek seems determined to allow its gay character to be more than just a coming-out story, and it's high time a teen-focused show took that step.

We also had another chance meeting between Calvin and his as-yet mysterious loverboy, who tackles him for a few moments too long during the game. Ah, foreplay. I just hope they keep a good amount of focus on Rusty and Calvin or change up the main sorority sister storyline stat, because it's getting a bit dull -- it's like a Bratz Doll Dynasty Playset. Otherwise, I've found my guilty summer pleasure.

  • brian's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Cylon's picture

    My boyfriend and I turned to

    My boyfriend and I turned to each other several times during Calvin's scenes with his dad and said, "Yeah, right!" -- but hey, maybe things are getting easier for kids these days to come out earlier and with more conviction, and really, we've seen the agonized approach plenty of times by now.

    Also, it's not like he was coming out to his father right then; his father already knew. For all we know, he did have trouble accepting it when Calvin first came out in high school, but by now he was ok with it.

    Evan's picture

    Out Gay Athletes

    The L.A. Times did a story about gay athletes a few days ago.  Some have great experiences others do not. 

    http://www.latimes.com/sports/la-sp-gay28jul28,1,1775077.story?coll=la-headlines-sports

    brian's picture

    thanks

    We had a post on this in the works that's up now -- thanks!
    perrythaler's picture

    I can understand where you

    I can understand where you might think that this is unrealistic, and maybe it is for his situation, but judging by my own experience, coming out isn't always tears and agony - it's different for every person.  It is nice to see that portrayal on TV (although I haven't actually SEEN it... I really need to find out when this show is on).
    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    brian's picture

    Absolutely

    My own experience was/is much closer to Calvin's than many people I know (for which I'm ever grateful), and again, I'm really glad to see such a different and refreshingly angst-free take. But our initial knee-jerk reaction was the "yeah, right!" response, which is probably due to conditioning more than anything else. Well, that and the extra helping of snark we had for dinner. As Cylon pointed out above, who knows -- there may have been issues between father and son when Calvin came out, but the show chose to move past that, which is fantastic considering that often when characters come out the show doesn't know what to do with them. Here we have an out character who's presumably going to be dealing with all sorts of other issues and problems, being somewhat out already.
    Timothy Kincaid's picture

    Mystery Lover Boy

    I'm interested to see where this is going. 

    I had to back up twice to hear his comment after Calvin said, "You can get off me now".  It was, "call me later?"  He also said something similar in the beer pong episode right before Calvin crashed from chugging all the beers.

    I'm not sure whether these guys are hooking up every week or not.  It could be a little clearer.

    One more thing guys... I don't know if it has changed since I was in college, but we HATED it when someone referred to a house as a "frat".  That was considered a slur.  Polite terms included "fraternity", "house", "greek system".

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    Kong Chang's picture

    If you read the TCA that

    If you read the TCA that Michael wrote about, one of them covered the Greek thing and Paul James did say/mention that the character of Calvin will most likely have a steady boyfriend, Heath, played by Zack Lively. So, although both actors are straight in real life, they play very well off of each other, for what little we see. Hopefully, with the new 10 episode extension, we'll get more into their relationship.

    I hope so too. I really love this show.

    KC

    Maintainer of Luke MacFarlane Fansite

    tjpeople's picture

    If only Rusty would get in

    If only Rusty would get in touch with his gay side


    Malcolm in the Middle fan?

    Check out: http://www.malcolminthemiddle.co.uk

    justaloe's picture

    TCaaaay

    OK I must be a little behind on my acronyms because I don't have any idea what TCA means and I don't have a clue as to where to find that Paul James quote.
    michael's picture

    TCA is short for the

    Television Critics Association. I just got back from their July Press Tour which is where I got the info about Calvin on Greek.

    User login

    Recent comments

    After Elton home page on logo online