News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

"Project Runway" recaplet (5.07): Shut up and drive

 

Oh my. Ohhhhhh mymymymymymymy. Did anyone hear my heart break at about 9:58 last night?

More on that later. First, let's discuss the shilliest Project Runway yet, in which the designers are asked to design a product placement around Saturn cars. Done! Overall the designs were not bad, but attitudes left quite a bit to be desired.

We start off with a shot of that same effing Olsen Twin Elle Magazine hanging on a newsstand, which at this point is giving me kaka. I mean, we all know that the entire season is taped in like 5 days but do they really have to make it that obvious? At this point MK or Ash (what, like you can tell them apart?) is kind of like the designsketeers' guardian angel or something. "Every time an outfit zings, an Olsen gets her wings!"

Upstairs, Kenley and Keith are not doing well. Kenley is upset that her BFF Daniel was sent home (apparently her laughing at him on the runway was reality show magic), and Keith is prickly because he wants to teach the world to sing but nobody's picking up his tune, or something ... I don't know, I kind fell out of love Keith last week and now I have the strange urge to be cruel to him for disappointing me. I'm all Bitter Moon up in here.

 

Anyway, the emphasis this episode is on the granite block on Keith's shoulder and Stella's lack of inspiration ... prepare accordingly.

After the Culling of the Models (we lose two ... and how hot would it have been had they brought back the drag queens from last week as the models, with no explanation?), Heidi gets all Jumpin' Jack Flash ("I'm a kleine German woman ... in a grosse silver box...") when she tells the 'sketeers to go to the rooftop of an address on the West Side for their next assignment. I get excited for a brief moment when I think they're headed to Beer Blast at the Eagle (All-you-can-eat pasta buffet - "Eat It, F*cker!") but no such luck.

No, it's a parking garage, and on the roof they find a bunch of cheap American cars, Tim Gunn, and some guy from Saturn, who is basically Welsh Moby. But instead of playing them some killer white man's dance music and serving them tea, he tells them in his wonderful accent that they'll be making outfits out of the materials that are stuffed inside the cars. For a second I feel like I'm watching Torchwood, only without the sex.

It's a bit of a let-down that they don't actually have to use the cars themselves, because I'd love to see these guys have to chop-shop a mid-size sedan. But no, they stock up on loose seatbelts and floormats and haul their carts full of materials back to Parson's. The irony or course being that with the wheelie-carts full of stolen car parts they actually look like they belong on 34th Street.

Blayne and his spoils
 

Back in the workroom, it doesn't take long for things to get ugly, although not in terms of the clothes. Jerell uses the words "bustier" and "headlights" in the same sentence, which probably isn't advisable. Blayne (who has mercifully avoided -liciousing anything thus far) says that the mood is very "exspearmintal" in the work room ... which either means people are thinking outside-the-box or they have winter-fresh breath. I think it looks very Mythbusters, which is a good thing.

Speaking of prickly daddy-types, Keith makes a comment about "the f*cking judges" and says that he's going to tone things down this week. For an "innovation" challenge. Sounds like a good idea. Seriously, he's getting reeeeeaally annoying with his bitterness over the judging last week. Let it go, kid! You're still hot!

The other designers comment on Keith's attitude and after more whining he finally reaches what in our house is known as the "Waaaahmbulance" point. As in, "Waaah, waaah, waaah - somebody needs me to call the Waaaahmbulance!" Anyway, Keith's a code red, at this point.

Meanwhile, Suede (who is not actually using suede, which would have been a valid excuse for him to actually refer to himself in the third person, for once) mentions his dead father, and I smell another Paranormal State-style visitation coming. Seriously, not to belittle his losses, but let's get with it. First grandpa helps you grow lettuce for a drag queen and now pops is reaching out from the other side to help you saddle-stitch seatbelts? Someone call Chip Coffey, because this guy needs help.

Where'd you get those peepers?
 

Elsewhere in the workroom, the increasingly dour Korto is working on a pretty kickin' coat made of woven seatbelts. And the increasingly hot Terri (who has become my favorite in the past two weeks, if anyone cares) remarks that it looks like a scarecrow (because ... it does) and even drops a Jeepers Creepers reference, making her my favorite contestant in history. Jerell isn't impressed by her horror movie acumen, noting, "Terri has two faces and four patterns, that's it. Don't trust the bitch." Me-ow!

That night we learn a bit about Stella's boyfriend (Leathuh-daddy?), whose name is William but who goes by "Ratbones". Of course he does.

Showday! Keith has a full-on hissyfit when his model, whom he had expressly instructed not to sit down, sits down and rips the skirt. In her defense, the hair Nazis and makeup elves probably made her, but he's LIVID. He tries to fix it and tells her not to sit down, or even to breathe. Near-fame's a bitch, honey!

Meanwhile, Leanne is stuffing her model's underwear with muslin. Come on, guys, fess up: Who hasn't been there?

No comment.
 

They introduce guest judge Laura Bennett (from Season 3) and Rachel Zoe, from some upcoming reality show I'll never watch. You know, so much has been said about the horror that is Rachel Zoe that I'm not really going to comment other than to say that I've seen Cenobites who were more photogenic.

Showtime!

Jerell's hotness
 

The Best: Jerell's futuristic cigarette girl outfit is hot, as is Korto's Jeepers Creepers coat. Terri's is also pretty hot, but I wouldn't expect anything less, at this point. Leanne's is downright fierce - this girl may have stumbled out of the gate with her Spaghettios Airways stewardess outfit, but damn has she proven to be the Little Girl, Interrupted That Could.

Korto's dress
 

In the end, Leanne wins and Korto, who was a close second, looks characteristically thrilled to have placed in the top two. Seriously, someone get this girl a puppy before she makes me cry. 

Leanne's winning design
 

The Worst: Keith's is boring, but we saw that coming. Blayne's is just a monstrosity ... but we saw that coming, too. And what's up with the puckering at the top? Did he think his model was Carol Doda? Bodydysmorphilicious.

Blayne's dress
 

Stella's is at least different for her but at close range it's a total mess, construction-wise. And I'm sorry, Mighty Joe Straight, but you can't just remake your Olympics outfit again out of floormats. And using the Saturn logo on the chest?! This isn't an outfit for a car show model. It's a bit brown-nosey (like his USA was), and I don't like it.

Stella's dress
 

The Eliminated: This is when the wheels spin off the wagon for Keith, who gets a bit argumentative with The F*cking Judges and then plays the pity card, which is of course as effective as rubbing a pork chop on oneself before jumping into a lion's cage. He's a bit Mayor of Excuses Village, but remember, this is also the guy who broke the "I'm not here to make friends" cliche rule, so I guess it's not that big of a shocker. In the end he's eliminated and keeps his cool (he even says "Yeah, for sure!" to the judges after they boot him) until his confessional, where he finally breaks down and cries because he's going home for something that didn't even represent him and now he'll never get out of Utah. 

Keith's losing design
 

Ouch. Well, Keith, having lived in Salt Lake City twice myself (don't ask), I can sympathize with you on that last part. But gay men have been getting out of Utah for decades now and you can too if you go into one of these two fields: Clog-dancing or porn. Trust me, they work!

The Keith-O-Meter

Sadly, we have to retire the Keith-O-Meter this week, unless Suede somehow summons him from the Other Side to help him make fleurchons or something. So, finally, we finally get to see Keith's head, delivered to us by the well-dressed architect of his decline.

 

Planet RunGay Status Check

Oh, Fierce-Yet-Benevolent Overlord Christian Siriano, what to do? You've apparently been spending too much time judging the relative fierceness of teenagers' hair to keep your gays in check, because they're dropping like panties at a Robin Thicke concert.

 

And then there were three!

mixingchemicals's picture

um, Laura?

Laura really killed me in this episode.  She's all "this outfit had no concept!" to Keith, and all I can think is "um.. this is the exact dress you made in the third season.  Every. single. challenge."
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Rbl Prnc's picture

Exactly...

what i was thinking!
Walford's picture

But...

This big difference is everything Laura made was expertly finished, well-fitting, and attractive. That outfit Keith made was pug-ugly and unflattering.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
mixingchemicals's picture

Oh I completely agree.

Oh I completely agree.  Laura's tailoring was probably some of the best ever on Project Runway, and her models always looked completely amazing in her dresses.  But purely in terms of the dress's concept, I just had to laugh at this criticism coming from her.
Michaelangelo's picture

Oh, I absolutely agree as

Oh, I absolutely agree as well.  What does this mess say about his tailoring skills?  As flimsily constructed as it was, it may as well have been made with wet toilet paper.  Keith is a hotty, but his talent, in my opinion, was suspect. 
Lily of the valley's picture

it's the first time I all

it's the first time I all in all prefer the women on project runway (usually just liked one or two tops). I hopehopehope they don't keep Swayne just for ... I don't even know what. So it's up to Jerell to keep your gay wheel running. Personalitywise I like him and Terry the most - though I'm not sure if I would like to meet Terry - she frightens me a bit ;)

Designwise Leanne really could be the dark horse - or not so dark anymore after yesterday's challenge. I'm quite convinced we would have seen more of her (esp. during the drag-challenge) if she would wear makeup and had a more stylish hairdo.

My wish for the final three right now: Terry, Leanne, Jerell
(Would have been Korto just a few episodes ago - but she's annoying me increasingly)

Would they dare to have a women-only top three? Though I like him Jerell is always capable of producing something that could get him auf'd

dkellergrl2001's picture

Korto, Terry and Leanne

I love Korto, her designs and her taste level, but she's a Mrs. Sourpuss. I don't expect her to do cartwheels and tosh off witty remarks, every 10 minutes, like Jerell, but c'mon now.


Love me less, but love me a long time - Les Chansons D'Amour

Latherr's picture

Keith

So glad that Keith is gone. How boring could one person be? Boring, and crappily done to boot.

Now if only we could get rid of Blayne. Seriously.

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
Walford's picture

At last!

Someone who agrees with me about Keith. I was always afraid to criticize Keith for fear of all the people too blinded by his biceps to see him for what he was: a mostly crappy, one-note designer, a mean-spirited brat, and a poser. (What's up with trying to look like a 19-year-old straight kid from the trailer park?)

I won't miss him a bit.

Latherr's picture

Yes!

Let's mock the designers looks - seriously. Fashion Industry. You work there. Wifebeaters do noone any good. Ever. This goes for Jerrel's tank top things too. We need more Christians and Scarlets.
Walford's picture

Don't forget

We need to add to the list Keith's bandanas, track suits, and rat-tail. And throw on Blayne's tanks, too.
Latherr's picture

The rat tail!

Oh yes, as I was watching it I was going over my side of a yet-to-happen argument with a Keith Lover friend about that rat tail. Ick. It's not quite there, but it's coming along nicely. Utah is hardly an excuse. I live in Nebraska and still manage to wear Vivienne Westwood.

I didn't mention Blayne, because all of Blayne is wrong.

I'm feeling bitchy today.

netogeno's picture

Meltdown

Well, I wasnt expecting Keith to stay much longer, but I really didnt see him going down in a flaming ball of self doubt. Sigh. His outfit was not bad, but his attiude was. Thats what got him aufd. Double sigh.

Im in agreement that Korto, Terri and Leanne should go the finish. Kortos coat was fantastic. Terri and Korto have been consistently giving the best design in the competition. 

And, ugh, I cant believe Bravo gave the anorexic princess a show. Double ugh.

Rbl Prnc's picture

Leanne!!!

Really people?!?! Are we forgetting some of the mess that she has sent down that runway. Top 3: Korto, Terri, and Jerrel, in that order.  Korto has become quite the sourpus lately though.
Orestria's picture

Am I the only one who's

Am I the only one who's watched project runway australia? I'm pretty frightened that the US show has borrowed a challenge from it. Only there, they had to use car parts *and* had to make a sporty outfit. At least the results were better here, I think.

 

I'm disappointed that Stellah choose the challenge that was clearly a gift of the leather gods to try something different. When they announced the challenge, I thought she could rock it, maybe even win by herself for once

chuck's picture

More product placement

and now show placement too.  I can't believe ANYONE is going to be able to tolerate a full hour of Rachel Zoe.  I thought this was one of the worst episodes in five years even though three of the designs were actually decent.  Korto should have won this time, however.  I will miss Keith's hotness but I don't think he showed us much in six tries, though Miss Brooke is going to look stunning in that one dress he designed for her.  How much more 'Paris Is Burning] is Jarrell going to become?  He's already two snaps away from RuPaul, who I thought was unnecessarily bitchy to Keith last week.   No wonder he was in such a bad mood this time.

Flame's picture

How could you have missed it?!

Oh but Blayne did 'licious something last night! Something big! And you missed it? You didn't hear him call his mentor 'Timlicious'?! Bwahahahaha! It was priceless.  I was thoroughly embarrassed for them both.
Brian Juergens's picture

Oh, it got worse...

Yes, he did Timlicious, and followed it up with a "love your face" (!?). At the point in the recap above when I mentioned it, though, we were still blissfully liciousless and then too much stuff came up and I forgot. BUt YES, it was pretty hot, you're right. I don't know why, but the "exspearmintal" is my new favorite Blaynism. It should totally be a new gum flavor.
Chris S. 's picture

Ugh! The Cars! The Drama!

This episode wasn't great, but I'm glad we got to see the designers actually start to sweat and we finally saw dear Keith turn into the sleep villain that I predicted that he would be, although he whined most of the time and by the end of the episode I was ready to shove a stake into his heart. I know I'm in the minority, but I wasn't into his designs nor did I find him terribly attractive (Where's Paulo when you need him?). Anyway, I loved Jerrell's design and strangely, I could see it being worn by someone on the street and it look completely chic. My biggest problem right now, besides "I see dead people" Suede and "Hot Messlicious" Blayne, is Korto. I mean, I know the challenges are tedious, but damn girl crack a smile. Let people know that you actually have emotions. The interaction with Stella and her boyfriend was kind of sweet and I'm really starting to warm up to her again. I like that she went out of comfort zone, but her design when past comfort straight to hell and back again. My hope is that she will learn some better tricks before getting Auf'd.

Terri is my hot momma for winning this competition. Her designs have been among the best and I love her attitude. Jerrell is a close second and my sleeper is Leanne, I loved that Aeon Flux leatha outfit from this week.

Again, Project Runway seems to be slipping into obscurity with these challenges and I'm having to actually work to find joy in these episodes, also it seems that the current designers tend to whine a lot over the smallest things. I know your model dropping out is horrific in those circumstances, but suck it up and get through it! Having a meltdown over it doesn't do anything for you or your new model. The plugs, from Lipstick Jungle (which I won't watch), the Olympics (which I barely watched) or The Saturn Vue Hybrid (which I can't afford), have got to go. I can only state again, that PR isn't putting any effort into this season and these plugs must the be simply way out without complete depriving the audience of what they tune in for.
Knickie's picture

What is WRONG with this

What is WRONG with this show? In years past they would have given the designers sledgehammers and told them to whack the bejeesus out of those cars to get the material -- not FILLED the cars with junk and given them a shopping bag! Come on!
Guillermo Serritiello's picture

My suggestions on how to make this show better....

Formalized after a few of my random stream of consciousness posts on here based on last week's show. Just my take and a video of better days.... One clue: MF-ing walk-off :-)

http://springintoaction.typepad.com/media_guillotine/2008/08/suggestions-on-how-to-save-project-runway.html 

Guillermo's Media Guillotine: Entertainment, journalism, politics, and popular culture.

 

Alxmouse's picture

Year of Obama

I believe that the top three will be the three African Americans. Not only because it's teh year of Obama, but all three seem to have good yet different tastes, and an attitude to back it up.

ms.bossy's picture

Korto is being short-changed, hence the sour face

Korto's losing all her charm because she keeps coming up second. She should have won last week and this week as well.

I know it and I'm sure SHE does.

Hopefully she'll learn from Keith's demise and not turn into a self-doubting-model-bully. Poor little things, they are not supposed to eat and now, as per Keith, they cannot sit or breathe.

Michael 's picture

sorry, but I couldnt resist

Brian, your "ohhhhhh mymymymymymymymymy" at the begining of the article comes on the Texas chainsaw massacre remake, I know you didnt mean it but thats the first thing that popped into my head when I read that.(me and my lil brother play a game where one of us says a small movie line and the other one has to guess what movie it comes on, and I just couldnt resist!)

Guillermo Serritiello's picture

Who would have thunk Leanne had it in her? Carol Doda-I love her

Brian - This may have been your best recaplet to date: Carol Doda, the Welsh Moby, Robin Thicke, and that annoying MK magazine cover. I say MK as that little monkey seems to work the press much more than the other one.

Speaking of sisters, the little frumpy granola crunchy girl finally showed that she was not as delusional as the rest of this cast when it comes to talent/aesthetic superiority.

I feel bad for Keith (as I would for any other person) as I hate to see anyone cry like that as those are "end of the world" terms. I called this one weeks ago as not even his hotness factor could hide that he and Daniel (just to name a couple) were equally out of touch with how their work did not match their desire to be great. The guy got so arrogant without any reason. He may be all that and a bucket of chicken back in Utah, but this is New York and there is one of him in every size in the big city. And telling the model not to sit down, and then calling her on it. The back of that frock looked like an animal tried to bite its way out of it.

Poor Keith/Daniel/abstract girl really thought that they were really talented.... God bless their hearts. Factoid: DC has got to have more hot boys from Utah and they are all really nice. I hope that they are not like Keith when pressed a little. Also, Utah gave us Todd from Survivor, so there is still hope Keith. Start downloading that application from Survivor - Afghanistan/Egypt/Queens...

I marginally liked the show as what started as an overt and truly intrusive project placement, but had some of the would-be designers stepping up to the plate. I am seeing an all female final and hope that although the show has gotten beyond stale for me, that the remaining designers surprise us just like Leanne did yesterday. I still can't believe that she had it in her. And Cher-lite has a man at home who luves his leatha/hatched faced beauty. Was the outside call a PR first? First working out and now this

TOTAL IRRELEVANCE: Is it me or is Tim looking more glum than Korto? He seems so over this show and what was up with that red and white shirt? I am no Sergio Valente (that one goes to the cheap seats), but that shirt was almost Henry from ATWT-worthy. Heidi's second dress was on fire!!!! I can't help but to reiterate that I'd like to tell us who she's wearing. While I was disappointed to see that Rachel mess and even my beloved Laura (GODDESS!!!!) taking over for Nina (probably was getting canned that week), their commentary was good. How can you not love Laura giving Keith the WTF are you saying look?

Guillermo's Media Guillotine: Entertainment, journalism, politics, and popular culture.

http://springintoaction.typepad.com

Keith's picture

Coming from a fellow Keith ...

He was one of my favorites in the beginning (and yes, I was semi-blinded by his buffness), but I began to lose interest in Keith when he became a bit snappy and made excuses for his tripups.

But I swear, at the end of this episode, I wanted to give him the biggest teddy-bear hug like no other. It was a bit unnerving seeing him cry like that. I hope he does make it big in NYC; it seems like fashion is his heart.

Hollywood Marie's picture

a brief summary of thoughts

  • Jerrell's model needs to stop slouching.  That was a great dress.  I also liked his hat.  Why is he so ignored?  They never focus on him.
  • Leanne's was also fabulous, despite her past efforts.  Give credit where it's due.
  • Terri's was f-in' hot.  Why didn't we see more of that?
  • Korto's looks EXACTLY like those old seatbelt purses that were hot for like 5 seconds in 2001.  Why is that considered original?  I also thought it was totally unflattering.
  • Suede's and Blayne's were so-so.
  • Joe is super boring
  • Stella should stick with what she knows.  She did in challenges where it made no sense, but now in the leathah challenge, she went girly?  Huh?
  • And Keith...oy, where to start?  I've never liked him, he's whiny and the least attractive man on that show physically (yes, terrible clothes...and just not even someone I'd look twice at) and personality-wise.  Seriously, there are (and have been) much hotter boys on this season -- what's with all the Keith love?  Thank you, Michael Kors for calling him out.  Buh-bye.
  • Yes, why weren't the designers asked to rip apart the car?  That would have been much more interesting.