Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Raiders of the Lost arc

Here's a riddle for you: When's a gay character NOT a gay character?

Answer: When he's been dead for a year!

Last night it was revealed on Lost that long-dead character Boone (Ian Somerhalder) was a homosexual. Or, at least, he was in airports -- because the only reference made to his sexuality was when his beeotch of a sister, Shannon (Maggie Grace) snapped at him for "hitting on random guys" while waiting for their ill-fated flight. And really, it just came across as a snippy sibling trying to get a rise out of her brother. Somerhalder (who is not gay) played full-on gay in the naughty-college-kid romp Rules of Attraction.

So this is the "gay character" that the folks behind the show were going on about in their podcast? PTTHHHHH!! That's pathetic. Bringing back a dead guy for 5 minutes just to make a vague reference to his sexuality doesn't constitute a gay character or gay storyline or anything -- it's just strange.

And wait, wasn't he sleeping with his sister, anyway? Before they both died, I mean? For crying out loud -- next thing you know the show will have a flashback featuring Eleanor Roosevelt.

Can someone who knows what's going on explain this?

In the meantime, here's some racy footage of Somerhalder in Rules of Attraction, including his make-out scene with James Van Der Beek from Dawson's Creek. It's in French, which makes it even naughtier!

tjpeople's picture

Looks like I beat you to it Brian... :P

copied from my new comment on the other LOST post http://www.afterelton.com/blog/michaeljensen/possible-lost-spoiler
----------------
Now it has to be the best episode for a LONG time, really clever and gripping.

But the only close to gay reference (unless in totally blind or something) was

"Boone asks Paulo if he can take a seat from their table but Shannon walks off continuing to yell at Boone and we can clearly hear Shannon saying that Boone should stop flirting with random guys." (from wikipedia)

Now as much a i would LOVE Boone to be gay he is DEAD! and even though that hasn't stopped people in the past it does seem very much like a throw away line, cause it was not like he was ACTUALLY flirting, just being polite!

Oh and did i forget to mention he was in love with his step sister!

If this is the best LOST writers can do I'm really annoyed. "Ooo we need a gay character - well this one is dead, how about him?"

-----------------------------

In other thoughts

Ian Somerhalder <3 hehe

------------------------------

also another bug? Initially when I posted (on the new site design) the line breaks would not be kept, then it was fixed and now you can select input format - however its the wrong way round, if you select html its does rich text and visa versa (i could be wrong but im pretty sure)

tjpeople's picture

bug?

also another bug? Initially when I posted (on the new site design) the line breaks would not be kept, then it was fixed and now you can select input format - however its the wrong way round, if you select html its does rich text and visa versa (i could be wrong but im pretty sure)

nordic balance's picture

Interesting they picked Ian

"Somerhalder was called a Gay Hater, by Gaywired Magazine and LOGO TVs News Site — 365Gay for having stated that after kissing a man in the movie The Rules of Attraction, he did not want to play other gay roles. Somerhalder hit back at the reports stating that some of his best friends were gay and that he only referred to the kissing scene in a negative way because the press had blown the whole thing out of proportion and he couldn't give an interview anymore without being asked about it."

Source

If any of you guys have Rules of Attraction on DVD you gotta listen to his commentary, what a creep. Hot, but a creep.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Matty's picture

re: Interesting they picked Ian

That whole situation was blown out of proportion. Ian used to answer 5 fan questions every week on the website <http://www.iansomerhalder.net/> and he said repeatedly that he wasn't anti-gay at all. He just said that as a straight guy he found it weird to kiss a guy with whiskers, and then the press went crazy with it. I really think he was sincere when he said he wasn't homophobic and felt bad that he got that reputation. He was also in a tv movie about Matthew Shephard's murder because he thought it was important. He's said that if he were gay that he would be out and proud about it too. I don't think he's homophobic at all. :)
nordic balance's picture

He is not gay....

Boone was not the gay character. His sister(Shannon)in the first season hinted to him being gay but it was revealed that it was just her being her usual bitchy self. It was just brother-sister squabble, the gay character is one of the Others....and he isn't dead, yet ^_^
nordic balance's picture

Boone's not gay--sorry

As far as I can tell, you've just misunderstood the context of Shannon's line. She had a long history of belittling Boone, and was just the kind of jerk who thinks that calling someone gay is an effective insult--but that doesn't mean that he atually was gay. He had already slept with her by the time they got to the airport, so I think that her saying that he's flirting with guys is another way for her to denigrate him rather than a sign that he really was gay.
Jay's picture

Oh, that's kinda cool! Ever

Oh, that's kinda cool! Ever since the show started i've had a little dream scenario in every episode that me and Boone were lovers! Very interesting...I hope it's true, if it is God must be answering my prayers lol.

Andros's picture

Brian I don't want to be

Brian I don't want to be nitpicking but the video is not in french. I'm a french canadian so I would know ;)

In my comment in the Grading the networks article I said that Lost was not a positive(not neutral either) gay influence show. This week proved me that I was right. The producers hyped the gay character for this week episode. What we got was some kind of insult from a sister to her brother because it sounded that way. Boone is hardly gay. Maybe bisexual IF (and that is a big if) Shannon was telling the truth(doubt it). I was not expecting a gay wedding on this week episode but THAT wasn't a revelation of a gay character. Seeing how they handled this week episode, I'm not expecting something good when a real gay character will be on LOST.

nordic balance's picture

French, Smench

Nit-pick away, Andros! I wasn't sure that it was French but was hoping someone would correct me with the actual language, because I had absolutely no clue what it was! And yes, the episode (although otherwise pretty awesome) boasted a pathetic "gay character" revelation -- the only reason we had any expectation is because they talked it up last week in their podcast (I linked to it in my post). All talk, no action. Blech.
Brian Juergens's picture

Erg...

That last post was me -- the site signed me off and attributed it to anonymous. Again, everyone -- the reason that we're grousing is because the folks behind the show made a big deal about there being a "gay character" revealed on this episode (check out the link in the post). I thought that Shannon's comment sounded exactly like you did -- a bitchy comment, nothing more. But what else could they have been talking about?
nordic balance's picture

The producers didn't make a

The producers didn't make a big deal about a gay character. In fact, they weren't even being serious about it, and literally said not to hold your breath for a gay character and not to look for one because no one would say, "Hey, I'm gay." Somehow, people who either can't comprehend things in a non-literal manner or are looking to start some trouble said that the producers said they were introducing a gay character without mentioning the context of them not being serious or the accompanying disclaimers. Then others just repeated this false assertion.

No one was meant to be revealed as gay, and Boone specifically wasn't meant to be revealed as gay (especially since Shannon has made a gay-innuendo-as-insult comment before in 1.12 when she asked if Locke was Boone's new boyfriend). I mean, you can still speculate, but the episode didn't confirm anything about anyone's sexuality.

Matty's picture

Lost

Shannon made a comment like that in season one too... I think she was just being a bitch though because there's been nothing else to indicate him being bi. I think it's pretty dumb if they said that was going to be a big gay revelation.

However, I'm sure that some scenes were cut from this weeks episode. I was looking at the production stills, and there are pictures of Claire, Nikki and Paolo together, but that scene was never aired - Claire was only in the episode for like 3 seconds and didn't even have any lines. Maybe they cut the gay revelation scene too?

tjpeople's picture

Maybe...but

Would they cut scene a week before airing? The podcast was by some people pretty high up and they seemed to know there stuff, if it had been cut I'm sure they would have know...
nordic balance's picture

French??

It is Spanish, not French!