Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

"Saturday Night Live" riffs on gay marriage, prison rape, flamboyant backup dancers and more

As though having Paul Rudd and Beyonce on as guests weren't enough, SNL pulled out all the gay-adjacent stops this weekend with an episode that referenced gay people, gay sex or gay cartoon lions in some way or another in nearly every segment of the show.

Things started off innocently enough with a skit about a family who kisses one another a lot, including father/son and brother/brother, which ended up with Fred Armisen trying to swallow Andy Samberg's face. Fair enough, been done before. But as the night wore on the skits got weirder ... for more (and for more video), click on through the jump.

Next we had a "Scared Straight" sketch where Keenan tried to freak out three high school vandals by repeatedly stressing how badly they were going to be raped in prison. ("There's gonna be a whole variety show up in there.") After that a sketch of four guys on a road trip remembering old times included Jason Sudekis having sex with a male cab driver and Paul Rudd putting his cell phone up his ass for a sexual thrill. And the Digital Short with Rudd and Samberg painting one another's nude portraits was heavy on the creepy.

By the time we got to Weekend Update and Snagglepuss appeared to speak about Proposition 8, we were well on our way to the gayest episode in the history of the show. (We learned that Snags is in fact married to the fey little alien from The Flintstones.)

But that's not all! A Beyonce video shoot introduced Samberg, Justin Timberlake and the New Guy as flamboyant backup dancers (in leotards and heels) who struck poses right out of a ball vogue-off and spoke like hissing sissies out of a 1972 exploitation film. 

But the gayest (and, overall, strangest) skit came last, when Rudd and Bill Hader played parking attendants disgusted at the Proposition 8 protesters gathered outside their garage. They started out by saying they don't get the whole gay thing but "live and let live" but then of course started going into detail about how they engage in casual gay sex but "just for laughs". The back-and-forth escalates until Rudd proposes to Hader with a ring and reveals his father gave his blessing and he's already booked their favorite B&B for the honeymoon.

I think (think) that this was a comment about how some people want to enjoy rights that they're not willing to fight for. Which is a fair comment to make, definitely. But the emphasis on gloryhole sex and rough trade cruising (when these guys were apparently dating and in love) made it feel like the sketch was an excuse for some more gross-out humor about gay sex more than anything else.

Did anyone else catch the episode? What did you think? And hey, weren't there supposed to be two new female cast members joining this week? Maybe they were off helping Darryl Hammond cut limes for the afterparty or something. And am I the only one who found it ironic that there were two sketches on the inability of gays to marry and yet the musical performance was a song called "Put a Ring on It"?

AddisonDewitt's picture

Gayest show with some good and some bad...

Brian I think this week's episode was heavy on the gay content as you said, but some was good and some was bad. I agree that the streotyping was a little heavy and that is something that needs to be worked on, but the Snagglepuss commentary with Kazoo was great and the Beyonce video had me rolling on the floor laughing. The prison rape is usually par for the course and the regular sketch really doesn't work anyway, Keenan is the weakest cast member. Rudd was so game and really fell into the ensemble in a good way since the clunkiness of the hosts' bad acting usually stands out unflatteringly. He fit right in. Rudd is a big supporter of gay rights though and I think I speak for many of us, that our community has a great ability to laugh at itself and that is a great thing. On the other hand, the last sketch could have been better with the casual sex/gloryhole reference.
AdamO's picture

For sure

I agree that the ep was a bit of a mixed bag.  Lots of gays but also lots of stereotypes-- but then again, SNL is a pretty equal-opportunity stereotyper (stereotypist?) and, yeah, the ability to laugh at ones self/community is definitely key.  Overall, I'm pretty sure the sheer handsomness of Paul Rudd might have managed to flip this one to an up arrow for me. Maybe.
Metabaron's picture

I didn't like it at all

First, I really didn't laugh at any of the segments. I thought they were poorly written. Second, I thought most of them were really homophobic. They were either perpetuating Gay stereotypes and/or engaging in "Gay Panic". The skits were done with an over-the-top subtext of irony that made sure to declare "Paul Rudd IS NOT GAY".

I hadn't watched SNL for long time, but I decided to check it out because Rudd was hosting.

Distingué Traces's picture

Yeah, that was a disappointment

Yeah, that was a disappointment from two favorite performers. The sketches just weren't that funny. Worse -- most depended for what laughs they had on an "ick" response to nudity, guys kissing, or just the idea of homosexuality.

Quite a letdown.

No, not "distant gay traces" -- it's distingué traces!

Charlie Fish's picture

...

Maybe I was reading too much into it, but I found it quite refreshing that this being the first live episode of SNL since the election (and the Prop 8 passing), they decided to have as many sketches as possible be gay themed. To me, it felt like a GIANT hug to the gay community, as well as a slap in the face to those who wince at the mention of homosexuality and the idea of two men being intimate. I mean, c'mon, the FIRST live sketch featured heavy-duty man-on-man lip locking. I LOVED this episode.
seanb's picture

That's actually what I was

That's actually what I was thinking - that they intentionally gay-themed it as a "shout out" so to speak.  And that it might well have been in response to Prop. 8.  I know a lot of people won't agree with this, but I think we've got to get past the sensitivity about stereotypes.  Most comedy is BASED on stereotypes of one sort or another.  The key question is this:  is the humor meant to demean the subjects?  Or is it meant more affectionately or inclusively?  I thought the SNL skits were all meant affectionately. 
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings