Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Rachel Maddow reads Rick Warren


Apparently I haven't done a good enough job sharing the wonder and glory that is Rachel Maddow with the guys at AfterElton.com, as she did not win — despite my passionate campaigning on her behalf — as the site's favorite lesbian.

I admit I love her for her butchy adorableness and world-class mind, but her politics aren't bad, either. Take, for instance, Friday's episode of her show over on MSNBC, where she sliced, diced, skewered, and eviscerated the choice of celebrity anti-gay preacher Rick Warren to pray at Barack Obama's inauguration next month.

Details and the video clip, after the jump.

Rick Warren: Just because it seems natural doesn't mean it's best for you or society. I'm naturally inclined to have sex with every beautiful woman I see, but that doesn't mean it's the right thing to do. And why should I rein in my natural impulses? And you say, well, because I have natural impulses toward the same sex, I shouldn't have to rein 'em in; well, I disagree. I think that's part of maturity. I think it's part of delayed gratification. I think it's part of character.

Rachel Maddow: See, if you can just wait long enough for that gay gratification, eventually you might be able to delay away the gay. Maybe. Keep talking, sir; you are making the job of making the case against you so much easier.

She goes on to quote Andrew Sullivan and John Aravosis — just a little silky subversion, since both men are prominent political bloggers who have the gay themselves:

Andrew Sullivan at the website of The Atlantic magazine took note today that Warren's church runs a group aimed at curing gay people of 'the gay." Ask responsible mental health professionals and they'll tell you that's quackery....

And she quotes Aravosis as saying gay people can't even belong to Warren's oh-so-famous mega-church, or, to quote the church's website, "Someone unwilling to repent of their homosexual lifestyle would not be accepted as a member of Saddleback Church."  Comments Rachel:

This means Barack Obama has just asked that the spiritual clarion call at his swearing in should be delivered by a man who will not allow 'unreptentant' gay people to join his chruch. Whose church runs a program, in fact, to try to 'cure' gays, who says gay relationships are the equivalent to child molestation and incest.

The common political wisdom is that this invitation to Rick Warren can't possibly be rescinded. No! Obama has plighted his troth with Rick Warren. And people who don't think gay relationships are like incest and that gay people can be cured? They should just endure. Get over it. Rick Warren's gonna be the invocation speaker, okay?"

That is the common political wisdom here, but I think the people who make up common political wisdom are maybe underestimating the anger of the gay community here, and the national liberal and centrist regret specifically about Proposition 8 in California.

She says they also seem to have forgotten Jeremiah Wright. In addition to Obama's eventual repudiation of his former pastor during his presidential campaign, he also rescinded an invitation he made to Wright to pray at the announcement of his candidacy.

Hmmm, she says again; "Didn't want a distraction on an important day for Obama. Hmmm. So, is it really truly politically impossible that Rick Warren's invocation invitation will be rescinded?"

I don't know. All I know is Rachel Maddow dishes out some uncommonly good political wisdom. I'm glad she's playing for our team. 

There's plenty more in the clip:

db's picture

Love, Love, Love Rachel Maddow

One of the few women I would consider going straight for (I said consider, I wouldn't really do it).
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Christie Keith's picture

A lot of my straight friends...

by which I mean, straight women, say they'd switch for Rachel.

I of couse don't have to switch, just get her away from her partner, LOL.

And, you know, arrange for her to know I exist. ;)

bambino italiano's picture

There's limit to being inclusiveness in politics.

Bigotry, racism, sexism, murderers, child pornographers and so on should not be inclusive in a government that try to appeal to wider support base. By doing so, you are selling your soul to the Satan. Obviously, the Obama administration aware that, perhaps  the LGBT support group has no whereas to turn to. Unless there's a hugh publicity protest to held on the inauguration day. How are the LGBT in US is gonna send a loud and clear message to the Obama administration to stop marginalized them?
Craig Young's picture

Is that your diary on Daily Kos

http://www.dailykos.com/story/2008/12/21/174451/88/444/675879 If so, I think it is brilliant.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Christie Keith's picture

Yes, that's me...

and thank you!
Liz T's picture

off topic...kind of...

ok, i didn't see it anywhere on here, but i saw a scroll thing on cnn earlier....but it seems melissa etheridge doesn't think rick warren is a homophobic jerk or something and that they are good friends...  O_o

did anyone else hear/read about that? just found it......odd.

VioletFemme's picture

Etherige

Yeah, I read the same thing on Towleroad. She apparently supports Obama's decisiton to "reach out" to the evangelical community. http://www.towleroad.com/2008/12/rick-warren-def.html

 

 If By Gay You Mean Totally Freaking Awesome, Then Yeah, I Guess It's Pretty Gay

--Des Ark

 

 

kcwin's picture

Did she hit her head? Wasn't

Did she hit her head? Wasn't she the one giving Elisabeth Hasselbeck a hard time on The View for her view on gay marriage? And this guy who directly supported Prop 8 is her friend? I gues she's one of those gay friends that he claimed to have.
Bobbyjoe's picture

Wake Up, Melissa.

Yeah, but Warren was supposedly "nice" to her and told her he was a big fan and now she's all "Oh, let's all give Rick Warren a chance, peace and love and cooperation, etc., etc."

Yep, I know I'll welcome him with open arms... that is as soon as he publicly (and not just in private with a celebrity) renounces his work for Prop H8 and all the denigrating things he's said for years about gays and lesbians, including just last week when he told Dateline NBC that even if it were unquestionably proven that homosexuality were 100% biological, he'd still be agin' it.

Oh, wait... he's not renouncing any of those things?  You don't say.  So I suppose we should be the ones to compromise and maybe it'll be such a nice example to him and he'll eventually come along, like maybe in ten or twenty years, and...  Good GOD, does it ever end?

Looks like Warren knows how to play Etheridge even better than she plays her own guitar.

Hunter R.'s picture

America's Pastor?...Puh-lease

Rick Warren is so much more repugnant and offensive to me than any of the James Dobsons out there because unlike those figures, he self-righteously masquerades as a so-called "progressive evangelical" because of his would-be noble advocacy for "non-traditionally evangelical" causes, which basically amounts to taking two "bold" positions: one for Peace in Darfur, and one for the importance of environmental priorities, which are supposed to be progressive because they challenge the rest of the fundamentalist Christian right. Perhaps it's just me, but saying that genocidal holocaust and global warming are serious problems doesn't really seem like too much of a bold or gutsy move. Which brings me to my critique of him, which is that in reality, he's not substantively any different than those other evangelical hate-mongerers. The mere fact that he has so nobly and selflessly acknowledged awareness of genocide and the environment doesn't mean that he isn't a right-wing zealot. He himself even admitted that underneath the phony progressive image, he's truly a social reactionary when he described the difference between himself and Focus on the Family founder James Dobson as amounting to merely "a matter of tone", which basically means that they have the same beliefs, but different ways of expressing them (i.e. different layers of bullshit to pile on top of them to make them seem more mainstream and less out of left, or should I say 'right', field). So to get back to why I hate Rick Warren more than I hate James Dobson, it comes down to two prosetylizers holding the same backward views, one who sugarcoats them in order to gently coerce otherwise rational non-extremists to subscribe to them, and the other who proudly and concisely lines out his beliefs with a minimum of B.S.

I couldn't be happier that Obama chose Rick Warren for two reasons: 1) because the fact that Rick Warren will be doing...whatever hokey shit he'll be doing at the Inauguration doesn't change anything about the fact that Obama is a self-proclaimed "advocate for gay and lesbian equality", and 2) because FINALLY, it's caused more people to realize what I've known all along: that Rick Warren is not this "fresh", "new", "progressive", "different", "non-extremist", "non-traditional" evangelical that his hokey book and all it's glorious success has made him out to be, but that in reality, he just boils down to the same old, divisive, and petty garbage from the Christian Right.

America's Pastor? I think not.

-------------------------------------------------------------

"There are two types of straight people in this world: the ones that hate you to your face, and the ones that hate you behind your back." -- Brian Kinney ("Queer As Folk")

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Psionycx's picture

Warren has a great PR machine

You're entirely correct Hunter.  Most of his "progressive" views are "duh" items that anyone who doesn't live and breathe the so-called "Culture Wars" grasps the signicance of. While taking a stand on these sorts of issues differentiates him from the likes of Dobson, Graham and Robertson it does not really show that he's a nicer guy.

Warren is playing the marketing game, and doing very well at it. He wants to appeal to the younger Evangelical crowd, many of whom do care about these issues even if the Evangelical Old Guard does not. By taking a bold stance on these sorts of thing Warren increases his appeal to the under-40 crowd at the same time as the other Evangelical big wigs are stuck with a rapidly greying followers.

What truly annoys me though is that his marketing power extends to controlling his press coverage. Over the course of this controversy a majority of the media coverage does not mention any of the vicious insults he's aimed at the LGBT community.  They just make it sound like he is opposed to same-sex marriage, which one would expect from a conservative minister and even imply that he supports civil unions (which in fact he does not).

Thus Warren comes across as a principled preacher while we look mean-spirited and exclusionary. It really illustrates just how we are not on the ball when it comes to spin, certainly not compared to someone like Warren.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Hunter R.'s picture

Right!

Yes, thanks for your extensions of my comments, they're so insightful! You're so right that the media has given him such a free pass, and I believe in part it's because they (and Obama, also) were looking for a preacher that they could fawn over and could present to the rest of the country as being a perfect epitome of a progressive, yet religious figure (cf. the media-created label of "America's Pastor" and Obama's choice of him to symbolically assume that label by praying at the Inauguration).

Psyionycx, this is how freakishly alike you and I clearly think: while you were agreeing with me here, I was agreeing with you on an entirely separate post. That, I think, is too cool!

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

"There are two types of straight people in this world: the ones that hate you to your face, and the ones that hate you behind your back." -- Brian Kinney ("Queer As Folk")
TheFabulousThomasJ's picture

Is It Me?

. . .or does Rick Warren seem to be channeling the Armistead Maupin look?

Betcha our favorite gay writer loses his moustache and haircut style quick!

Eddus's picture

Oh Maddow

I just love her!
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings