News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

American Idol's Un-Fabulous Return (Season 7 Premiere)

American Idol is back for its seventh season but if you're looking to catch a glimpse of the next Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood, Clay Aiken or Chris Daughtry you need to sit back, do your taxes, write a novel, contemplate what's living in Amy Winehouse's hair and then return in a couple weeks once the audition rounds are over.   

There are two camps of people that watch American Idol: those that find glorious joy in seeing the painfully tone deaf humiliated on national television, and those that truly enjoy watching a rising star in the making. I tend to fall somewhere in between. 

I will freely admit that I've been an American Idol Addict since its inception and I'm man enough to admit that I cried big baseball-sized tears when my girl Kelly Clarkson took the crown in Season 1 (chalk it up to the confetti and pyrotechnics)!  I'm also smart enough to know that while Idol has changed the landscape of reality television, it's come with a price.

The overbloated premiere took to the streets of Philadelphia and even though it's the "City of Brotherly Love," we witnessed not one noticeably gay contestant. Even worse, we barely saw any male contestants audition or make it through to the Hollywood round at all. Sure there was the Bear Cub that dressed like Princess Leia and a drag queen or two but overall the men were scarce in Philly.

That had me thinking... Has American Idol learned its lesson and decided against openly ridiculing the effeminate contestants?  Are Simon and Ryan done with their witless gay jokes? Is mocking the sexually ambigious a thing of the past? Is the visual absence of LGBT contestants a sign of things to come or did the gays of Philadelphia learn a lesson from season's past and stay home?

Love it or hate it, American Idol is back.  You can run, you can hide, but I doubt you'll be able to avoid this reality monster.  If you thought Idol was on too much last season, just wait to see how Fox fills that huge gaping hole in their winter schedule left by the ongoing Writer's Strike.  Brace yourself because it feels like something wicked this way comes.

kmantoni's picture

Witless Gay Jokes

Only time will tell Ducky. I doubt they're gone for good.

-K

Dan McCallum's picture

Gay Joke Update

Hey KMantoni, if you caught last night's episode you know that the gay jokes made a return appearance.

The 19 year old virgin who's never been kissed told his story and as he was getting ready to leave Simon said: "Avoid Ryan on your way out."

We all knew it was too good to be true.

brian's picture

well thank heaven for that!

Here I was worrying that the boys had lost their edge.

Bully, Simon!

I prefer when Joel makes fun of Ryan on The Soup because he picks on Ryan's size, without the gay-baiting. (And as we all know, short people are HILARIOUS.)

daverett's picture

Hrmph...

...he snorted, sitting up straighter in his office chair.

kmantoni's picture

Oh well

I liked Virgin-Boy (or is it Molested-Boy)! I was stunned when he didn't make it but they let Fingernail-Collector and Car-Accident-Chick through.

As much as I like to pick this show apart, I still can't WAIT until next Tueday!!!

-K

 

daverett's picture

I agree...

I thought the whole father-wearing-the-locket-that-fit-his-son's-key thing just a little too creepy.
daverett's picture

Anyone else see the last audition on American Idol last night?

As Leo Marlowe was speaking to the judges, he said something to the effect that his mother always said she'd raised the perfect homecoming queen - it was just too bad it wasn't one of her daughters.

Do we finally have an out gay contestant?


User login

Recent comments

After Elton home page on logo online