Gay Reality Roundup: "Big Brother 9" and "American Idol" Two-fer Tuesday
Wow, what a difference a week makes y'all! I come back from vacation to discover that Big Brother 9's homo-hamster Joshuah takes verbal cues from Jane Fonda and likes to use Amanda's Father's suicide against her. Real stand up, respectable behavior... way to represent! On top of all that, it was revealed that the pink streak in supposed straight boy James' hair might be due to his recently leaked gay porn past. Even worse, since Neil Garcia's sudden departure, the gay interest in this show has dropped significantly. Many of us reality fans were doing pirouettes at the chance to finally see two gay men have a showmance on national television. We here at AfterElton.com wanted to cover it as much as possible but now that Joshuah is shacked up with Sharon and all BFF with the girl, the gay aspect of the show is less interesting. That doesn't mean though that the show is boring. If you were to chart the number of screaming matches, house guest hookups, and naughty bits shown this season it far surpasses any other American version of Big Brother to date but I feel its come at a price. While the show has always been kind of trashy and the bastard stepchild of reality shows it's been consistent in that there are major game players and minor characters. This season is the exact opposite, they cast for character, titilation, scandal, and horniness with little regard to playing the game. That's annoying. Tonight after the Power of Veto competition (which Joshuah and Sharon killed - btw) the house guests were given a glimpse of the happenings in the outside world. After learning that McCain and Obama are the new front runners, Joshuah was most excited to learn about that trainwreck Britney Spears. To be honest, I'd love to hear that juicy nugget myself if I was locked away for 3 weeks already. The gang were then give a cryptic message about the Hudson River Virus which I'm certain was a sexual health warning to the bed hoppng horndogs instead of a shout out to fellow CBS show, Jericho. Is HRV code for gonorreah or some other STD? All I know is that I'm hoping CBS has set up a free clinic just beyond the walls of the Big Brother house because these kids have been dirty birds this season. Those that have subscribed to the live feeds or who watch the Showtime After Dark series have been given an eyeful already!
Aside from Joshuah and Sharon winning POV and deciding not to use it this week (leaving Alex & Amanda as well as Matt and Nat on the chopping block), the only other excitement was watching Amanda and Allison have simultanous medical emergencies. I'm sure it was scary as Hades to watch Amanda collapse and have a seizure and to see Allison ballooning like Violet Beauregarde but these guys acted like it was a life affirming and changing experience. These people need to get out more often. Tomorrow night one couple will leave and endure the icy stare of The Chenbot ... so until then let's talk about The Boys of American Idol!
While some may have been talking about whether or not Idol finalist David Hernandez swings our way thanks to pictures of him working in a gay bar (allegedly), or whether or not ultra flamboyant Danny Noriega is wearing Jessica Alba's face, today everyone is talking about little cutie-patootie David Archuleta and his rendition of John Lennon's "Imagine." I'd like to scoop this kid up and put him in my pocket, not in a "one rubs the lotion on ones self" kind of way, more in a "dance monkey dance" kind of way where he just sits in a glass box in my room and sings on cue... Archuleta for the win! Back to Alba-esque Danny Noriega, this week he tamed his head whips and retired his two snaps around the world for Simon and I really found Danny very entertaining. I think he's way too showy and cabaret for Idol but his personality makes him good TV. Maybe he'll grow on me as Christian from Project Runway did. Only time will tell. Oh, as for David Hernandez... the kid can blow! Hope everyone doesn't mind the combined post of Big Brother 9 and American Idol but unless either show gets significantly gayer I'm thinking this is how we'll proceed. So what did you think of the shows last night? Can Joshuah redeem himself after the Mount St. Vulgar erupted? Will vile Adam's calling Joshuah a "faggot" to another player make it to the broadcast? Can little David Archuleta survive the attention a show like Idol can put upon him? Is Danny Noriega all show and no talent? Let's chat in the comments section and don't forget to tune in tonight as the Top 10 girls perform and one couple is eliminated when Idol and BB9 continue.
Submitted by on Wed, 2008-02-27 10:19. |
User login![]() Recent comments
Recent blog posts
New forum topics |






Oh, I think you are giving
Oh, I think you are giving Joshuah far too hard of a time. He apologized to Amanda for his comments and admitted they were out of line and in the heat of the moment. The conversation where he did this was edited by CBS to make it look like he was continuing to be a cold bitch, but that's not how it actually went down. He didn't pretend to like Amanda, but even he realized he took it too far. So give him some credit. Besides, Amanda forgave him, and he showed genuine concern for her during her sickness last night. I would think nine seasons of edited nonsense would teach us all that nobody is quite the caricature the network presents them to be.
Believe Me
I understand the power of reality editing but watching the videos from the live feeds of not the arguement but his conversations prior to the arguement he's been pretty evil behind the scenes as well. He was joking about Amanda's Dad's death for a while and I agree he blurted it out during the hottub confrontation in the heat of the moment and he regretted it but I don't think by any means the man is a saint.
I'm not saying he's a horrid person but let's not make him out to be some great gay character because he felt bad his actions would be seen on television or that he had genuine concern for another human being in the time of crisis.
None of it matters because the nastier it gets the more entertaining it gets... for some (including me at times). I heart Big Brother and I still enjoy watching Joshuah on the show.
Joshuah
He was joking about Amanda's Dad's death for a while and I agree he blurted it out during the hottub confrontation in the heat of the moment and he regretted it but I don't think by any means the man is a saint.
Didn't say he was a saint.
Didn't say he was some "great gay character."
I only said I don't think it's fair to vilify him for that one statement, especially since he expressed genuine regret for saying it and for hurting her feelings. That's all. Nothing more.
I loved Danny last night. He
True, David does have his
True, David does have his flaws as do everyone else int he competition. The difference is David always picks a great song for himself each and every time we see him sing, every other contestant so far has picked atleast one song that was horrible for their voice. He also sings better then every other idol, as the judges say he has a really pure voice. The third thing he has going for him is that he is 17. Some of the 21+ contestants are making the same mistakes as he is and they have 5+ years more experience then he does.
Truth be told I never had a favorite from the beginning of any Idol season. I saved my judgement for after they pick the final 12 then pick my favorite but sorry, this year it is defenitiley David. The only thing hurting him right now is the fact that he is a mormon, his parents seem to be just as bad as Brittany spear's parents(they seem to whore him out any chance they get)and a combination of both could be a real disaster for him in the long run :-(
Not bashing David...
...because he is talented and has a great voice, but he probably has more experience than anyone else on the show except for Michael and Carly. He's been singing on stage since he was 11 or 12. He even won Star Search. And he borrowed heavily from Eva Cassidy for his version of "Imagine" last night. It was still great, and probably the best performance of the night, but I'm not as crazy about him as others seem to be. I also find his personality a little fake, so he annoys me. It's that thing where you can tell a kid has grown up on a stage. Also, does anyone else suspect the poor kid is a closet case? Belting out "And I Am Telling You" for Kelly Clarkson? And on YouTube there's a clip of singing "For Good" from Wicked. I know singing showtunes doesn't automatically gay, but still...
Speaking of the more than likely gay, I thought David Hernandez was really great last night. I think he's technically the best singer of the men... just lacking a little in the personality department. But he even seemed to improve that last night. And you could tell Danny was told to tone down the flame. He was trying hard, bless his heart. I love him to death. It's got to be hard for these kids who have grown up being completely themselves to suddenly have to step back into a closet. (Not that I know for sure he's gay... but come on!)
Wow... this got really long. Not that I'm obsessed with this show or anything...
Not a music critic
I thought David Hernandez
I thought David Hernandez had the best vocals last night. He definitely pulled it up a notch this time and I really love his personality. I'm just in LOVE with his voice. I kinda think he is this year's Elliot Yamin, only prettier and more gay, lol.
I loved little David Archuleta's cover of ''Imagine'' as well. His voice is very mature for a 17 year old boy and he's something really soulful about it. Both of the Davids are definitely my favorites along with that adorable dread guy Jason Castro.