Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Battle of the Network Gays: September 17, 2009

Every week we pick the gays who we think have made the biggest splash in television (or pop culture in general) and leave it to you, the keepers of the flame, to decide who will be crowned Gay of the Week. We'll announce the winner in Friday's BGWE column, and that champ will reign until a new set of challengers are introduced the following week to try to steal his title.

Last week newly married couple Jim Verraros and Bill Brennan won your hearts and took the crown. This week a number of very strong candidates are in the running. We've got a fashion designer turned acclaimed director, a Glee club denizen with a poignant coming out scene, some same-sex ballroom dancers who charmed even Nigel Lythgoe, and a shameless (male) hussy on Melrose.

Check them out after the break, and vote for your favorite!

This week's contenders:

  • Fashion designer and first-time director Tom Ford made a big splash at the Cannes Film Festival with the premiere of his first film, A Single Man. Not only did its star Colin Firth win the prize for best actor, but A Single Man also took the Queer Lion Award for best gay film! Oh, and the trailer  is absolutely gorgeous...

  • Glee's Kurt Hummel (Chris Colfer) came out to his best friend Mercedes what was definitely the poignant highlight of a very uneven episode of Glee. Congrats to actor Chris Colfer for being able to turn on a dime and make the audience care about his mostly cartoonish queer character. (Our Glee recap here.)

Kurt comes out on Glee

  • Same-sex ballroom dancers Jacob Jason and Willem de Vries were the perfect vehicle for So You Think You Can Dance judge Nigel Lythgoe to concede that maybe two guys dancing together is not so bad after all. Jacob and Willem's performance was good enough to land them a trip to Las Vegas. Even better was their quiet dignity in explaining their choice to dance together to the judges. (Our SYTYCD recap here.)

Jacob Jason and Willem de Vries face the SYTYCD judges

  • The hotly anticipated (and very hot!) Caleb (Victor Webster) finally made his entrance on Melrose Place and while the jury is still out on the show, there's no denying that the morally ambiguous, hypersexual, unapologetic and commanding Caleb is unlike any gay character we've ever seen on network TV. (Our Melrose recap here.)

Caleb stirs things up on Melrose Place

Vote for your favorite by 10 PM EDT Today. And be sure to check back for tomorrow's BGWE column to see which network gay our readers have carried to glory!

DalTXBear's picture

Decisions, Decisions.....

So many choices and all good.  Does the saying "Vote Early, Vote Often" seem applicable here???
Androjai's picture

This week

 

 I actually agree with all of the choices! Thisis a tough one, but I am gonna have to say

 

KURT!

O Liberté, que de crimes on commet en ton nom!

Whitetee's picture

This is really hard....

I kinda wanna vote for three of them.

The hardest part is,all four of them might have a few more chances for the crown down the road.

Kurt`s big episode is next week(can`t wait!), Caleb I haven`t decide yet and hopefully will get to like in the next few weeks. Tom Ford is awesome and I`ve been a fan but still need to see the actual film first.

Jacob Jason and Willem de Vries are talented and have a wonderful dance partnership going on.(And let`s not forget the latest Mores for Gays episode when they teach Daniel same sex dancing! - I was surprised though that this part was not mentioned here.) My major concern is that they probably gonna show up again in the Vegas episode for SYTYCD, but their scenes might got cut short and/or they got sent home very early on. That`s the major reason why I end up voting for them since this might be their only shot at this.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
PanButNotPeter's picture

Chris Colfer is lovely.

The 'A Single Man' trailer and same-sex ballroom dance were both lovely as well, but I have to give my vote to Chris. His performance last night was perfection.

My favorite Kurt line from Acafellas: "If by 'someone' you mean the tender crook of my elbow..."

Oh, and when he called Vocal Adrenaline "sweaty nazis." And when he apparently wore a corset (!!!) that we didn't get to see. And when he... I have to be at work in an hour, so I'll stop. But not before adding that I think Jane Lynch is rubbing off on Chris, because the way he delivered his "I have no idea who that is" line was very much like her.

Yes, the show is uneven, and I don't care much about most of the other characters, but I'm STOKED for next week's Kurt-centric episode.

 

netogeno's picture

Kurt

Kurts simple and heartfelt coming out scene deserves the win. Kudos to Colfer for doing it so well.

db's picture

This is a hard one.

Between Kurt and the SYTYCD couple. 
Alxmouse's picture

More Balls Than Pong

I voted for Tom Ford...The trailer did it for me. I don't normally watch reality TV so it's difficult to vote for the dancing couple. However, dancing as a gay couple in front of millions takes more balls than having a character to hide (for lack of a better word) behind. It's the difference between playing tennis and Atarri's Pong.
Dave Doty's picture

BotNG

Well, I don't watch reality TV, so it's the two fictional characters for me.  I actually found Kurt's coming out a by-the-numbers affair from a very stereotypical character, so it's Caleb by default for me.
miltongold's picture

Where Did the Voting Option Go?

I couldn't decide between Chris and Jacob/Willem, but it seems I won't have to.  It's only 9:45 p.m. EDT and the voting mechanism is already gone ... Perhaps a longer voting window could be provided in future.

 

miltongold's picture

... And now it's back

Must have been a temporary glitch...