Idol Chat with Jim & Penny: The Top 4

After a week's absence, Jim & Penny return to talk about the most recent performances on American Idol ("Neil Diamond week" and "Classic Rock week").

They open up the reader mailbag and name their picks for most talented, most improved and most personable contestants from this season. Also, Penny asks Jim about recent comments made by Season One co-host Brian Dunkleman that the show's producers and certain judges were "mean-spirited and targeted specific contestants in an effort to break them."

Co-hosts Ryan Seacrest (left) & Brian Dunkleman
from American Idol Season One

Check out their video blog after the break!