Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

NBC Signs Do Not Resuscitate Order for "Trauma"


Trauma goes down quietly.

Time of death: 7:59 PM October 28. NBC has canceled their freshman drama Trauma, of interest here at AfterElton.com because of gay paramedic Tyler Briggs, who had such a touching coming out scene this past Monday.

The show has been plagued by mediocre ratings since the premiere, but had shown a slight uptick during this week's Halloween episode where Tyler and San Francisco's Castro neighborhood featured prominently. And it was seen as a good sign when NBC announced that they were keeping it on their schedule through November sweeps. Despite these positive indicators, the plug was pulled on ordering a full season last night.

Tyler and Boone may never resolve their issues.

Conventional wisdom has NBC showing the remaining seven episodes through their broadcast of the Winter Olympics. They'll use the promotional high from the Olympic broadcast to launch their spring lineup. The cancellation coincides neatly with an increased order for Chuck, bringing that series to 19 episodes, which seems about right for a season with an Olympic broadcast.

Trauma was an old-school drama, with location shoots and special effects. The pilot episode, complete with the helicopter crash, was rumored to have run $4m. Regular episodes were ringing the cash register for $2.2m each, which is probably what ultimately killed it.

This can't have been cheap, and even NBC doesn't deny that accountants run the network.

For those keeping track, I'm showing three major cancellations this fall for the broadcast networks: Trauma and Southland on NBC, both with innovative gay characters, and The Beautiful Life on The CW, with a horrible gay character. Just like that, using GLAAD's numbers, we've gone from 3% of network primetime to 2.5%.

  • Ed Kennedy's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • marQ's picture

    This sucks. I just watched

    This sucks. I just watched the episode last night & vowed to DVR the whole series and now it's gone. 
    Latherr's picture

    Booo!

    Booo!
    monica_ca's picture

    Blasted!

    I seriously loved this show...probably my favourite new show of the season.  Le sigh...
    woodroad34's picture

    "The show has been plagued

    "The show has been plagued by mediocre ratings since the premiere"....sounds like the Jay Leno Show.  How come that dinosaur isn't going anywhere? You know Jay's salary could match the production costs of "Trauma".
    xanthis2001's picture

    It is cheaper.

    It is much cheaper to produce an episode of Jay Leno plus you get "guest star" power without having to pay for it.   Advertisers will pay for the Leno name and the network doesn't have to produce five different shows(with writers, staff, etc.) weekly just one consistent format.  Even with low ratings it MIGHT make sense economically it just isn't giving a large number of viewers what they want which is scripted shows.
    David N's picture

    I think Leno will be to blame for other cancellations

    By giving Leno the end of prime time I think that will be the downfall of a lot of shows. Ratings aside, both Southland and Trauma belong in that later time slot. Also NBC's Mercy could probably benefit from the later time.

    I can't help but feel that if all three shows aired when Leno's show is on that it would have given them an improvement in the ratings. What parent wants to watch a show with blood, guts and adult situtations when their child is still watching TV with them?

    Average (2 votes):
    see individual ratings
    Kraylessa's picture

    And then there were two.

    Well, NBC has just lost another hour of my viewing time. I'm now down to only two hours a week watching their network. I only have Mercy, The Office, and 30 Rock left. Since it's highly likely Mercy will be the next show to get the axe, I suspect I'll be down to one hour soon. The sucky thing is I actually *liked* Trauma and looked forward to it every week, unlike Mercy, which has it's moments but overall isn't that great. /sigh

    At least I still have a little hope that Southland will be picked up by TNT. I don't really see the point in continuing to watch Trauma knowing it will be ending.

     

    "It's weird. It's just different. It's not men. It's just him. It's only him." - Ianto Jones

    xanthis2001's picture

    I'm down to one hour out of geek loyalty.

    I'm still watching Heroes until its eminent cancellation because I have watched it from the beginning.
    The_Intangible_Fancy's picture

    Heroes

    I too continue to watch Heroes out of a misplaced sense of loyalty.  Why did they have to ruin a show with such great potential?  And why did they feel the need to include a 'lesbian' storyline right as the ship was about to go under?  Talk about adding insult to injury.
    RJ's picture

    I still like Heroes

    In its first season, Heroes was placed on a lofty pedestal with some unrealistic expectations but I don't think it deserves the extreme level of criticism that it's been getting lately. I've liked some episodes and characters more than others but overall, I'd still give it a positive endorsement.

    I think Chuck is the only other NBC show I still plan to follow regularly, whenever it gets back on the air.

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    netogeno's picture

    Ahh...Heroes

    Sadly we ended our relationship a couple of weeks ago. Unbeareable...to watch, I mean. Just wasnt interested anymore.
    Mia's picture

    Is there any chance

    Is there any chance this will get picked up by another network or channel? I remember there were talks about selling Southland to TNT, so it might happen with Trauma too, right? I'm trying to stay positive here, but yeah, I know it's kinda unlikely. I really liked Tyler's coming out episode too. This sucks! 

    Oh well, at least they will air the rest of the episodes, so that's something..

     

    Harvey Milk: You gotta give 'em hope.

    monica_ca's picture

    Budget's too high for TNT

    I would imagine that the budget of the show is waaayyyy too high for TNT, though it could be slightly retooled with less cool explosions to be cheaper.
    Ed Kennedy's picture

    Not a whisper...

    Mia, there's not been a whisper of that, and I find it pretty unlikely. It's just way too expensive a show for cable to support. Anything above $1.5m/episode is way too pricey for cable, and that's a stretch, something reserved for maybe 3 networks, and shows that can be guaranteed hits. And I could be wrong, but I think NBC owns the production of this, unlike Southland, which Warner owned.
    netogeno's picture

    Ahhh...thas a shame.

    Ahhh...thas a shame.
    mamxnb's picture

    guests will go where now?

    i have to wonder where leno gonna get himself guests for his shows? doesnt leno need  guests to be on his show 5 nights a week, if NBC doesnt have shows on NBC networks or just NBC having  less and less shows and  that means  less  NBC shows to promote on the leno show at night, really there not much left now, i know leno has movies stars and music stars he could draw on , but who left from NBC to come on his show to talk about their shows or project , i cant think of any show i watch on nbc now mmm , mm perhaps merlin yeah that it  i think is all the show  i watch on  nbc  wow. but all this has been done before with tv networks having lot of vairety shows in the 1970s and not drama or sitcom or movies on the networks and somehow them night talkshows thrived , but now it games or reality shows aand mm what else on tv now? i wonder if NBC is just operatiing  just so badly now  by bad management and so on etc, dont they get fired or  the chairboard cry  more money ? procter owning  the soaps is just strange to me  . tv is  not tv anymore i think , it too changed and dinosaur are runnng the networks  nowadays it seems like. pardon my bad spelling and  grammar , i dont proofread myself , i tend to miss , overlook my own mistakes  , it  bad failure on my part eeeeks eeps eeks!
    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    JC's picture

    NBC

    The only show's I'll watch on NBC are Heroes and Chuck. They really don't have a good grasp on how to catch and retain viewers. I loved Jay at 11:30, will not watch at 10. There are better shows on that some drivel of a talk show.
    Ricky's picture

    What's the mother***ker wrong with NBC???

    I am shocked to read  about NBC cancelling another show with gay character in favor of Jay Leno?  Southland with gay cop, Now gay EMT?  Now I quit watching NBC's evening shows!   Someone need to protest at Rockfeller Building  which have  NBC office and store.   FUCK YOU, NBC and JAY LENO!!!!
    GaySpouseDotCom's picture

    Trauma on Syfy

    Since NBC owns the strangely-renamed Syfy (Sci-Fi) channel, they should use Trauma to replace Stargate Universe which is so boring and has no characters interesting enough to care about. It makes you wish the ship had plunged into the star and been destroyed.

     

    Ricky's picture

    It sounds good idea to replace Trauma in Syfy

     Stargate Universe bored me out after 3th episode. I quitted on it.
    RJ's picture

    enjoying SGU a lot

    Totally disagree. I'm enjoying Stargate Universe a lot. It's way more character-driven than previous Stargate series but I actually find that a refreshing change. I think the ratings have been pretty good for SGU so far. The Friday night companion series Sanctuary has been quite good as well.

    Trauma is too expensive for basic cable and besides, it's not in the sci-fi genre.

    Darrien's picture

    Me, too

    I dearly love SGU. It's my 'appointment' viewing for the week here. We get to see it on Tuesday so it's SGU at 8pm and then Chuck at 9pm. It's a perfect two hours of TV viewing. The previous Stargate shows were a guilty pleasure, but this one is so different and has learned so much from Battlestar Galactica that it has me gripped.

    I have a deep passion for Robert Carlyle as an actor and tremendous appreciation of his bum from The Full Monty, but the character he's creating on SGU is totally fascinating. He's able to be revolting and compelling at the same time and that's such a difficult balancing act to pull off for an actor.

    I'm not quite a fanboy about the series, but I think I'm a fan-man.

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    netogeno's picture

    I would agree with that

    Who knew darker meant boring.
    GaySpouseDotCom's picture

    Syfy not strictly sci-fi, Stargate Universe {zzz...}

    Um, not to point out the obvious, but Syfy produces and runs movies about rock creatures, giant sea monsters, and dragons, not to mention Ghost Hunters - none of which have anything to do with the sci-fi genre, so Trauma not being sci-fi isn't a barrier to it being on the Syfy channel.

    As far as SGU goes, being the third series in a well established show "universe", Stargate Universe needed to step up the action and stories. Instead they did what the last Star Trek series, Enterprise, did, which is turn into a total yawn-fest by becoming more simplistic than its predecessors and dumbing down the action for an audience already well versed in the lingo and setting of the show. Snooze.... snore.... yawn.... sorry even writing about it makes me bored-to-death drowsy. :P

    I agree Sanctuary is entertaining. Then again, it's not predictable.

    RJ's picture

    sci-fi label

    The sci-fi genre is generally accepted as including fantasy, horror, comic books. Realistic dramas like Trauma don't fit the genre. Basically, if it's not something suitable for a panel at San Diego Comic Con, it would not belong on SyFy. However, if you set Trauma 50 years in the future and play up the potential advances in medicine, that could be considered sci-fi.
    GaySpouseDotCom's picture

    sci-fi

    I would agree only that comic books include sci-fi, fantasy, and horror. Otherwise Syfy being more than just sci-fi is specific to the sci-fi channel. Sci-fi sections of bookstores are limited to actual science fiction (whether comic-book, anime, or standard fare). Sci-fi conventions are limited to science fiction. Sci-fi film festivals are as well. Fantasy including high adventure is its own category in bookstores, conventions, and film festivals. As is Horror. Comic-con covers comic books so it can cover any and all genres including sci-fi, fantasy, and horror. There of course can be items that are sci-fi genre that are also fantasy, horror and/or comic books, but Syfy shows traditional fantasy and horror without any sci-fi component. They also show things set in contemporary times so Trauma would fit in. And some people would say being set in San Francisco would qualify Trauma as a horror show. :P Have you seen the housing prices in San Fran? :P

     

     

    cdm.rn's picture

    I've only watched the first 4 episodes

    but it seems to me that they are trying to go too big with the big gory accidents all the time.  There has been a big car accident, a workplace shooting, someone driving through a market, an arm torn off, and a pole through someone's abdomen with major vascular surgery in the field. I wish they scaled back on the big dramatic accidents and focused more on the EMTs and what they actually do more of on a regular basis, which is far less dramatic calls. (and it would save $)

    I realize that it is a tv show but if they don't go all out allof the time, then we can learn even more about these characters that have already shown to be pretty interesting. Instead of trying to fix the show to get it better ratings, NBC would rather just cancel it and keep Leno.  I guess NBC is showing everyone how to destroy a network.  Just my 2 cents.

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings