Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Ten gay superheroes who broke new ground

With Shatterstar and Rictor's recent kiss in X-Factor #45, writer Peter David broke down barriers for gay superheroes by showing the first gay kiss between long-established Marvel heroes. (Marvel's first gay kiss would probably be X-Force's Bloke, who died in the same issue that introduced him.) "Ricstar" as fans have dubbed them, join the list of characters who've slowly broken down barriers in a long, slow path forward.

Enigma and Mikaal
DC's first gay kisses

Finding the first gay kiss in a DC comic is a complicated task thanks to the publisher's tendency to target different audiences with a variety of imprints, sub-imprints and, sometimes, unofficial sub-imprints. As one of the first titles to debut under the Mature Readers-focused Vertigo line, Peter Milligan's surreal mini-series Enigma ended with a kiss between the story's protagonist and the titular hero in 1993. Meanwhile, in 1998, James Robinson gave the DC Universe its first gay kiss when Mikaal Tomas, one of several heroes to take up the "Starman" title, kissed his boyfriend Tony. However, while DC's gay kisses pre-date their rival, Marvel, there hasn't been a gay kiss in franchise title X-Force.

Alya & Violet and Hulkling & Wiccan
First long-term same-sex couples

Romance is an important aspect of team books -- what would The Avengers's history be without the tempestuous relationship of Hank and Janet or the New Teen Titans without Changeling falling for Terra -- and slowly we've seen same-sex couples be a part of these team romances. When the couple-heavy The Legion of Super-Heroes relaunched in 1984, readers noticed Lightning Lass and Shrinking Violet were growing closer. In 1989, the series relaunched again and the romance between the two became clear. Their affection for each other was an important part of the series until the Legion was once more revamped in 1994. Meanwhile, in 2005 Marvel got its first gay team romance with Young Avengers' Hulkling and Wiccan. The couple generated some letters of complaining that a gay couple wasn't appropriate for a team of young heroes, but Marvel stuck with them.

Thom Creed
First gay hero in mainstream Young Adult Literature

Unfortunately, as Hulkling and Wiccan show, gay stories are still percieved as being more sexually explicit than the same story told with straight characters. Thus, it's pretty incredible that Perry Moore's novel about a young gay man trying to deal with both his sexuality and his developing superpowers would find the acceptance it did. Not only did it become an Amazon top seller but comics legend Stan Lee signed up to help adapt Thom's story to TV.

Timebomb
From: TV's first regular gay hero

While there's been a number of superheroes on TV, the only gay has been Timebomb in the dark Britcom No Heroics, a former drug addict. That, sadly, reflects a dynamic found in Perry Moore's list of dead, raped and mutilated gay heroes, where gay characters tend to be limited to mature titles where death and dark turns are more common. Hopefully, there will be good news for Showtime's proposed adaptation of Hero, which would give gay comic fans a new kind of hero to follow.

Apollo & Midnighter
First married same-sex couple

For a little over a year, Apollo and Midnighter inspired plenty of speculation, before The Authority writer Warren Ellis made it clear they were a couple. While Ellis did a great job at treating them the same as every other character on the team, later writers tended to define them by their sexual orientation and their relationship, which at least led to stories where they married and adopted Jenny Quantum as their daughter.

Madam Fatal
From: First Drag Superhero

The Golden Age has plenty of odd heroes to be discovered and one of the more notable ones is Richard Standon, a famous female impersonator who debuted in the pages of, I kid you not, 1940's Crack Comics #1. Richard used his drag skills to look like an innocuous old lady, who the bad guys would overlook until she turned out to be able to throw a punch like a healthy, young man.

Element Lad
First philosophically bisexual hero

While Starman gave us Mikaal, an alien whose bisexuality came down to caring about love more than the gender of the person he loved, The Legion of Super-Heroes gave us Element Lad first. In 1992, his longtime girlfriend, Shvaughn tearfully revealed she had been taking a gender-switching drug in order to have a relationship with him. He responded that Shvaughn's -- or Sean -- gender didn't matter to him as much as the person. The relationship continued, though Element Lad was already a barely-there character when the Shvaughn/Sean revelation happened.

Northstar
First hero to come out

There's a reason gay comic fans pay so much attention to Northstar. Not only had he been a major character for years, there were hints from the character's early days about his homosexuality. When he came out in 1992 -- however clunky the story or Jean-Paul's "I am gay!" declaration in the middle of battle -- it was a major breakthrough in comics.

Thanks to the Gay League's Joe Palmer for help putting the lsit together.

  • Lyle Masaki's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Aximill's picture

    A lil more nerdy geekdom

    To go along with Apollo and Midnighter, their adopted daugther, Jenny Quantum, is supposed to be the "essence of humanity" for the 21st century. Her mother, Jenny Sparks, was the embodiment of the 20th Century.

    So at least in the comic universe, GLBT people will be more accepted by the general populace since Jenny will be inlfuenced by her adoptive parents. 

    Grimm's picture

    Waren Ellis is supposedly

    Waren Ellis is supposedly writing a new Authority story set in the future where everyone is gay except one person.
    Cosmic Lad's picture

    A nice trip down memory

    A nice trip down memory lane...

    I think I was 'there' for amost all of those happenings, except the Madam Fatal one of course! 

    This helps show us how far we've come, and how far we have yet to go, I suppose...!  Thanks Lyle!

    8)

    Dave Doty's picture

    Hear, Hear

    I was there for all but Madam Fatal and whatever this Time Bomb thing was.  Well, I'm one of the three people who didn't love Starman, so I was aware of but not reading that one.
    Tygrlad's picture

    Lyle--YOU MISSED ONE

    Lyle,

      You forgot to mention the REAL 1st same sex kiss was DC's CAMALOT 3000 between Sir Tristan (female) and Isolde (this pre-dates even ENIGMA).

     

    Scotty

    Grimm's picture

    Thank you for

    Thank you for remembering.

    Tristan is also a sort of Transgendered hero. 

    Dave Doty's picture

    Camelot 3000

    Oh, good catch.  Although Tristan was very much a man in a woman's body, so lesbian may not be exactly the right word for that relationship.

    Camelot 3000.  Maybe I should reread that.  Or maybe just let it stay wonderful in my memory.

    R.E. Blakeslee's picture

    A new superhero!

    If anyone is interested, my novel, Origination, will be coming out soon.  You can read an excerpt and check out the cover at http://www.reblakeslee.com/

    Betylos: A superhero the world can take pride in...and maybe aspire to be.

    Origination by R.E. Blakeslee - Read the book!

    starri's picture

    I'm pretty sure

    I'm pretty sure John Constantine beat Element Lad to the "philosophically bisexual" category.

    Also, unlike Legion, Hellblazer hasn't been retconned fifty-seven times.

    Dave Doty's picture

    Hellblazer vs. Legion

    Edited to fix the error that made my subject line nonsensical.  "Hellblazer vs. Constantine?"  Really, Dave? :)

    I really don't recall any bisexual suggestions for Constantine prior to Azzarello's run.  Please correct me if I'm wrong, but if I'm right, that was WELL after Element Lad.  And about a bazillion other Vertigo characters, for that matter.

    I admit I slept through about half of the Ennis, and all of the Jenkins run, so I may be wrong.

    Synnerman's picture

    And Rob Liefeld throws a hissy.

    It's so fun to know that being gay means you can't be a warrior.

    http://robot6.comicbookresources.com/2009/07/liefeld-cant-wait-to-someday-undo-shatterstar-development/

     

    I was willing to cut him some slack until the warriors can't be gay comment. I also find it amusing since Liefeld is not Shatterstar's sole creator. I wonder if Fabian Niceza is having such palpatations?

    jjose712's picture

    I'm sure

    I'm sure that Spartans couldn't agree with him
    starri's picture

    Refreshing

    It's actually somewhat reassuring that in the midst of all the commentary about what a douche Liefeld is generally, people are calling him out on being, in fact, homophobic.

    I think it's kind of nice that when something like this happens, there are only a few regressives that pitch a fit.  It's been like that at PAD's blog as well.

    duckiestoy's picture

    Maybe, maybe not

    I'm at a loss over Rictor being gay because I remember him being into his female teammates like Boom Boom.

    As for Shatterstar and Fabian, I haven't seen any interviews to suggest he was at least equally Fabian's character but I recall Fabian was just scripting for Liefeld in those days.  Liefeld did plots and art. Also, Liefeld had drawn the character earlier in a "pin-up" at the back of a New Mutants annual. I don't think Fabian was even on the title yet.

    Of course this was almost 20 years ago and memories fade. 

    Dave Doty's picture

    Fabian

    Given the general incomprehensibility of most of Rob Liefeld's work, I suspect Fabian spent a lot of time taking his random spray of ideas and trying to turn them into some sort of focused stream.

    Also, Fabian was the one who was setting up the Rictor/Shatterstar relationship back in the day, but left the book before he could get there.

    And Rictor isn't gay, he's bisexual.

    Knightgee's picture

    Maybe it's just me

    But I interpreted Liefeld's comment to mean that Shatterstar was a warrior in the sense of being all about that, to the point of asexuality. While I disagree, since the subtle and not-so-subtle hints about the relationship have been there for a while (and contrary to Liefeld's view, characters are allowed to evolve beyond their original creators intentions), I don't think his implication was that warriors can't be gay but that Shatterstar simply isn't in his mind supposed to be sexual at all. Of course I doubt that he would have felt compelled to speak out had it been a woman and not Rictor. His complete lack of eloquence and overall juvenile demeanor make his comments seem less like a creator angry over a vital change to a character he invested energy into crafting and more like a petulant child whining because his dark, edgy and ultra-masculine  etreme 90s hero became gay.
    Psionycx's picture

    Liefeld

    Kind of funny really, considering that Liefeld's original Shatterstar looked almost shockingly effeminate. It was, of course the hair. I hate to be the one to point this out to the dear boy, but by and large long, flowing hair is a liability for a warrior. Aside from it's tendency to get in one's own eyes, it provides a very convenient hand hold for opponents.

    It does, however, make for an extra-androgynous look, which Liefeld oddly seems to favor despite his apparent homophobia.

    Nor does an argument about the original creation's personality hold up. All characters evolve over time, just like real people. One can go through the comics to see how characters change over the course of years.

    So really it does just come across as petty homophobia.

    Darrien's picture

    Timebomb

    The whole point about Timebomb in No Heroics was that in a bunch of losers, he was the most intelligent and best-looking - and had the most sex.
    Kate's picture

    Trans?

    There's a character in "Runaways" named Xavin who is born male but can change genders at will, and after falling in love with a lesbian (Karolina) notices that her default state has become female.  I don't know if she's the *first* transwoman superhero, but it's certainly a positive example!  They're also an interracial couple, which I think is cool.

     

    "Go, or go ahead and surprise me."  -- Rufus Wainwright

    DigitalLux's picture

    Not only interracial, but

    Not only interracial, but interspecies as well with Xavin being a Skrull and all... 

    Lyle Masaki's picture

    Runaways is great

    Though the first trans hero is a complicated question -- what with the shapeshifters (including Skrulls like Xavin), the body-switches (Sasquatch) and body-sharing (Comet/Andy Jones).

    My original plan was to note that Shapeshifter from elementals was the first bisexual shapeshifter (with the caveat that Shapeshifter fully played out the "evil bisexual" stereotype... it still was groundbreaking at the time to acknowledge that shapeshifters might see sexual orientation and gender identity more fluidly) even though Claremont was long rumored to have had that in mind for Mystique (well, that situation would have been more complicated than the Shvaughn/Sean retcon), but that got lost while putting the list together.

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    Dave Doty's picture

    Shapeshifter From Elementals

    Of course, there was that glimpse to the future issue that showed Morningstar and Shapeshifter in a seemingly happy same-sex relationship, so there may have been more to her than the "evil bisexual" if Williangham had been able to follow through with his plans.  Unlike many glimpse-of-the-future stories, that issue read more like a roadmap of where he actually intended to take the series, but he left only a dozen or so issues later.

    And to save me a second post, thanks for the Paul Levitz correction.  I only half-remembered what I read anyway, so I more than likely got it wrong.

    Lyle Masaki's picture

    That's right...

    I forgot about that story, maybe because its a reminder of how that series was mangled once BW sold the rights. Now I'm feeling nostalgic and might have to dig up those back issues.

    Grimm's picture

    I'm pretty sure that the

    I'm pretty sure that the first gay superhero was El Extranio.

     He was one of the New Guardians from Dc comics in the 80's. He was very gay and had a lover who died from aids but they never actually used the word Gay.

    He even would call himself "Auntie Pedro" to the girls in the group. 

    Dave Doty's picture

    Shrinking Violet/ Lightning Lass

    A quick google couldn't find the source, but I'm fairly certain that Paul Levitz has said he didn't have any lesbian intent in the scenes that so many, myself included, interpreted that way.  I don't recall him being particularly against the later interpretation, just that he didn't intend it in his scenes.

    Just a historical FYI. 

    Lyle Masaki's picture

    As I recall...

    He said that he didn't plan it but it was something dictated by the characters... or, to put it another way, he didn't plan it but when he read the final product he saw a relationship developing and went with it.

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    Bard23's picture

    I'm surprised no one

    I'm surprised no one brought up Question II (Rene Montoya) or Obsidian (Todd Rice) from DC Comics, or Mystique from the X-Men Comics.

     

     

     

     

    "We are all given one thing by which our lives are measured, one determination. Mine are the stories which can change or not change the world. It doesn't matter which as long as I continue to tell the stories." -Sherman Alexie

    Dave Doty's picture

    Mystique

    Mystique probably warrants a mention for being an early lesbian, or bisexual, or whatever, even if her relationship with Destiny was only hinted at.

    But I think Question II and Batwoman (is she two or one?  My brain is melting) came along a little too late to really be groundbreaking, although they're both excellent characters.

    Joe Palmer's picture

    Constantine

    To Dave,

    There is a passing reference in Hellblazer #51 about Constantine's bisexuality.

    http://www.gayleague.com/wordpress/2009/04/28/john-constantine/ This is the only reference I've found before the Azzarello story. There may be other instances that I'm unaware of because I haven't re-read all the issues in between.

     

    Joe

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    Dave Doty's picture

    Thanks

    Thanks for the info.
    Joe Palmer's picture

    Tristan and Isolde

    Lyle, so sorry that Tristan and Isolde slipped my mind when we discussed this the other day. Now that Scott posted about it, I recall the kiss very well. Thanks for mentioning them, Scott. They shouldn't be forgotten.

    Joe