News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

IMHO: "Degrassi" episode 8.05, "The Man with Two Hearts"

 

 

For six seasons Degrassi: The Next Generation has included a variety of queer characters including Marco Del Rossi (played by out actor Adam Ruggiero), lesbian Alex Nuñez, bisexual Paige Michalchuck as well as Marco's various dates and boyfriends, including Paige's brother Dylan. But by the end of the last season all of those characters had been written out or had been dropped to "recurring" status.

Friday, Degrassi outed one of the new characters introduced this season. Does this new story have the potential to live up to Degrassi's gay-friendly past? In short, yes and no ... find out about Degrassi's new gay — and why I'm giving this the sideways arrow — after the jump.

Football player Riley (Argiris Karras) has been floating in the background so far this season, basically acting like your basic cretinous high school jock character (arrogant and quick to tease anyone who doesn't fit in). This week we learn he's become close friends with Peter, which makes sense considering that Peter used to be an arrogant jerk as well. We're quickly clued in that Riley is nursing a crush on Peter by the way the music changes when their hands touch when Riley tries to help him get up from a fall.

Things get extra tense when some Wii Boxing turns into actual boxing lessons. When Riley leans in to correct Peter's form, he goes in for a kiss. When Peter isn't receptive to the move, Riley runs away.

Peter quickly compensates by diving into a relationship with Mia, apparently needing to wash away the taste of Riley's lips by kissing a woman. Peter tries to talk to Riley but he's quickly brushed off. When Peter tries to bring up the topic again, Riley turns violent and shoves Peter into some lockers. Finally, when Peter tries once more to approach Riley, Riley calls him a "fag" in front of his teammates.

My immediate problem with "The Man with Two Hearts" is that we see the story entirely through the eyes of straight guy Peter. Riley obviously has a lot to work out, but the episode focuses largely on Peter. The way Peter rushes into a relationship with Mia, worries if he led Riley on and generally holds the focus of every scene, it almost feels like Riley's struggles exist only to give Peter something to do.

Still, there's plenty of potential here. Riley tells a different story from Degrassi's past gays. He's not sweet and sensitive like Marco. He may be a jock like Dylan but Dylan was much more confident about his sexuality. Riley is a young man taught to suppress his emotions with alpha male behavior and very much in denial about himself. Gay characters in teen dramas are still rare, so it's great to see a teen drama that is willing to explore the variety of experiences queer kids goe through.

I'm not sure if Degrassi can really meet that potential, though. The show has really been struggling since last season when a bunch of new characters were introduced. Riley isn't the focus of the next four episodes and considering how frustrating the pacing was last year, I'm not sure that Riley's story will come close to Degrassi's previous gay storylines.

What do you think? Am I just being too cynical after a bad season of Degrassi? Is Riley a student you're eager to get to know?

  • LyleMasaki's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Brent Hartinger's picture

    I just talked to some of the

    I just talked to some of the folks up at Degrassi, and it seemed like they were definitely going to get into the story and the character as the season progresses. But right now, there's not a lot to be done with the Riley character because he's in total denial, and is acting like a total jerk. I'm intrigued by the storyline.

     

     

     

    Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes

    see individual ratings
    Anthony D. Langford's picture

    Hmmm...

    ..... I see what you mean, but I actually liked it.  I think given Peter is an established character and this is really the first time we've actually seen Riley with more than a few lines of dialouge this season, it makes sense to tell the story through the eyes of someone we know and are familiar with.  Plus, Peter's first reaction was a typical 'straight guy' kind of thing, but unlike other soaps (anything that would air in the US), the story ultimately was not Peter trying to adjust to his friend being gay, but Peter wanting to help his friend deal with how he was feeling.  It would have been a completely different story if  they had of focused on Riley and I think it would have been a bad storytelling decision to tell it through the eyes of a character we don't really know, especially since the other half the show was focused on newbies.   I do think the show made a bad decision to introduce so many new characters all at once though.  But I'm certain that as the season unfolds, the story will come to tell it through Riley's POV.  I'm intrigued.
    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    SteveBerman's picture

    I think the problems with

    I think the problems with the episode are indicative of why the written word works better than television for exploring gay teen issues (and I think Brent will back me up on this).

    Because television is based on scenes, you have moments that are so artificial - such as when Riley rushed off after the kiss. In a book you could expand upon the scene - Peter could have rushed out after him, they could have had further confrontations, etc. You're not competing with the other A or B storylines as much. Plus the POV can be more fully explored and shifted.

    My problem with the ep is that it seems a bit dated. Yes, plenty of gay teens are in the closet, but I'm disappointed that we don't see the growing post-gay trend emerging in the mass media. It's like Canadian television is 2 yrs behind real life (and American television is 10 yrs).

     Now Steve's New & Improved with Andre Norton Award Finalist power for Vintage!

    www.steveberman.com

    Brent Hartinger's picture

    It's a good point, Steve

     

     

     

    Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes

    see individual ratings
    GayTV's picture

    Riley kissing Peter

    I finally saw the episode, it played on the N here the other day.

    I don't get the criticisms, not one bit. I thought the episode was excellent and the way they played the Riley/Peter kiss really worked.

    I don't think they had to have Peter rush out after him. Peter was just as jarred by the moment as Riley was. The next scene where Peter tried to discuss it and then Riley had his violent denial was perfect. They didn't have to give him a lot of script because what he did with those few minutes really showed the internal struggle he must be going through.

    To me, the episode and the storyline are not dated at all. The struggle that Riley is having is one that is very much a part of the lives of gay youth. Especially a gay youth who is active in sports. There are amazing things they can do with this character if they decide to continue with his story.

    Edit: The commercials on The-N show some pretty big storylines coming up for Riley. Starts again Feb 14th.

    jjose712's picture

    I think the story

    has potential to be interesting. It depends of the writting to develop all this potential
    zeowads's picture

    The problem might be...

    I think Degrassi's first problem is that The N only airs it in 6 or 7 episode chunks, making it very disconnected. This season they're trying to reboot with a bunch of fresh faces since the old cast has now moved on. I think they brought in too many though.

    Riley's story has potential, because it's another way people deal with being gay - denial and unacceptance. Hopefully they will deal more with it in the future. Though who knows, maybe Peter's rush to hook up with Mia was indicative of his hidden desire for men!

     

     

    http://zeowads.blogspot.com

    LyleMasaki's picture

    Scheduling is definitely...

    part of the problem. It doesn't sound like Riley's next major episode will happen until after a hiatus (The N is advertising only 2 more eps until hiatus.) I think, too, part of the problem was that this is the second season of revamping as last season tried to introduce new characters while continuing to focus on old faves... but since only a few of the old faves and new Lakehurst characters interacted, it was a difficult transition at best. This season has introduced new characters more smoothly but considering what has aired so far and some of the ambitions voiced so far (besides Riley there's also Connor's story, which hasn't even started) has me wondering if there'll be time to tell those stories. Maybe it'll work out if they Degrassi team gives up on the tedious Anya/Holly J/Mia who've been pretty heavily used this season.
    jai's picture

    I think this season of Degrassi is great!

    I'm happy with Riley's story so far and it doens't bother me that it will be returned to later in the year and slowly progress rather than being focused on for the next few episodes.  It is part of Degrassi's not wrapping things up neatly at the end of episodes and making people think, and its being an ensemble show rather than having stars.

    I also think the point made by another poster about why it was a good decision to do this episode from the point of view of Peter to introduce Riley, and then switch later in the season to episodes from the point of view Riley, makes a lot of sense.  I hope Peter will remain a part of this story though. 

    Connor's story about his autism has started.  The seeds are all the times he has complained about his routine being disrupted, such as how KC took his seat in class, and how they switched tables in the cafeteria at lunch, and how the group working on the robot always meets at Clare's house so they shouldn't change that. 

    Agree they should lay off a little on Mia/Holly J.  Anya has potential which should be explored further instead of her remaining in Holly J's shadow.

    justaloe's picture

    I listened to the podcast

    I listened to the podcast with Argiris Karras on the Degrassi website and I must say that he gave perhaps the most comfortable interview I've ever heard from a young  actor who's playing a gay part. Not a bit of homophobia or I'm really straight but or anything like that. He even seemed very comfortable with having to kiss his co-star 6 times for the kissing scene. You guys should check out the podcast.

     

     

    The Canadians are so far ahead of us in the US. There gay characters actually get to be affectionate with each other on screen and kiss, even if they are teens. If you want to see the difference check out how GREEK handles Calvin's relationships as if they were handling nuclear waste or something. They seem to think that if they let Calvin and Heath kiss then peoples heads will explode.

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    AnnieO's picture

    Degrassi / Riley

    Aha, I called it! I knew Riley was going to end up being the gay character that all the commercials were hinting at.

    Anyway, I'm pleased with the storyline. Degrassi works in much the same way as Mad Men, so Riley will never be more than an ensemble character, but experience shows that he'll end up having his own episodes here and there along the way.

    Marco's story arc lasted for six years, and he progressed from an insecure high school kid living in the closet (with a fake girlfriend) to an out-and-proud college student.

      

    Average (1 vote):
    see individual ratings
    syrus's picture

    Are my eyes deceiving me or

    Are my eyes deceiving me or is there something off about that picture?

    The football player looks like he has an erection!

    jai's picture

    I listened to the podcast too

    I didn't think he seemed all *that* comfortable in the podcast (although not uncomfortable either) ... But I found it interesting that he mentioned the "first kiss" between Riley and Peter, suggesting perhaps there will be more?
    GayTV's picture

    Episode is on today - 1/2/09

    Short notice but ths episode is on today at 1:30 (CST, I think). It airs on The-N network.

    GayTV's picture

    Riley on Degrassi

    I've been Tivoing the reruns on The-N and they are pushing the Riley storyline hard. Anybody else notice this? It's the only character that has their own commercial.
    GayTV's picture

    Riley's commercial on YouTube


    User login

    Recent comments

    After Elton home page on logo online