News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Mensa names Frasier one of the smartest shows of all time

You might have heard that Mensa, the organization for people with very high IQs, has assembled a list of the Smartest TV Shows of All Time. Frasier makes the list at number 8 (aided, no doubt, by the performance of David Hyde Pierce as natty Niles) and four shows known for occasionally tackling gay themes - The West Wing, Boston Legal, Mad About You and All in the Family - are also included.

The full list:

  1. M*A*S*H
  2. Cosmos with Carl Sagan
  3. CSI
  4. House
  5. West Wing
  6. Boston Legal
  7. All in the Family
  8. Frasier
  9. Mad About You
  10. Jeopardy

As always with a list like this, a number of omissions come to mind, ones that makes the inclusion of Boston Legal and Mad About You seem even odder. Seeing Mensa chairman Jim Wardell explain the choices doesn't help things, since there doesn't seem to be on over-arching rationale; CSI and House are considered smart for the way they use science in their stories while Frasier and M*A*S*H are praised for their characters and dialouge.

While a list of this always inspires people to think of their favorite deserving shows (I always go with Wonderfalls, myself) there are a couple general omissions that I find interesting. All of these ten shows originally aired on broadcast television, so critical darling cable networks like HBO and fx are not represented.

Animated and science fiction series don't make the cut, nor do any gritty, emotionally exhausting dramas like Homicide or Six Feet Under. One could almost say that Mensa picked shows that were intellectually challenging but not too intellectually challenging.

The most glaring omission is probably The Simpsons, a show that playfully challenged its audience's attention to detail almost constantly. Does the fact that Lisa Simpson is a high-ranking member of Mensa Springfield mean nothing?

But there are plenty of other gay-inclusive TV shows that could fit on the list. Earlier, I mentioned Homicide (which gave us an unflinchingly realistic look at police work and characters who developed over time, including Kyle Secor's Det. Bayliss becoming comfortable with his bisexuality), Six Feet Under and Wonderfalls, and would also think Oz and The Wire would be deserviing nominations.

What are your favorite examples of smart, gay television? Which shows do you think challenged audiences' brains the most? Let us know in the comments!

  • LyleMasaki's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • KatieD1456's picture

    M*A*S*H

    FYI, in it's second season (1974) M*A*S*H had an entire episode "George" revolving around a decorated, gay soldier. My memory is fuzzy about the plotline, but I did an internet search to find out that he told Hawkeye he was gay, and Frank Burns found out and wanted him to be dishonorably discharged. I remember that Hawkeye and Trapper kept his secret, but were incredulous that he had a way out of Korea and wasn't taking it.
    cobaltmale's picture

    US dominance

    I assume all non US shows were excluded ...

    http://theworldfromhere.blogspot.com

    you_will's picture

    frasier....hell yeeeeah

    number 8? (more like number 1...haha) hmmm. it was definetely smart in it's humor. i saw one episode and then went out the next day and bought the next 7-8 seasons.

    funny show. :-)

    Jay's picture

    CSI, smart?

    Not the way they have the characters explaining things to each other that they already know. These shows have the clunkiest exposition of any show I've ever watched. I had to give it up, it was just so maddening. I only watch CSI: HORATIO. It's so campy, and Miami is so beautiful, the sting of hearing characters tell each other things they already know is less painful than on the other two. I haven't watched the original in five years, I'll bet.

    Popular, yes. Smart, nuh-uh.

    brandon2384's picture

    If your a MENSA and you

    If your a MENSA and you watch CSI because you think its "smart", then you are proving that IQ means absolutely dick.
    LyleMasaki's picture

    CSI

    While I'd agree that it's not a show I'd put on a list of "smart" shows, it's explained that it's on the list not for the plotting or characterization, but because of how science is used in the show. (And that's one aspect I don't feel up to judging.) Personally, if I were to throw a show on the list for making science entertaining to the masses, I'd go with Mythbusters.

    User login

    Recent comments

    After Elton home page on logo online