Oprah asks what it's like to be "Gay around the World"
Yesterday's Oprah Winfrey Show was quite amazing to watch, as it featured the kind of coming out experiences we don't hear about very often. The show started with Prince Manvendra Singh Gohil of India, who came out after a nervous breakdown prompted by a miserable, closeted marriage. The Prince's coming out was a huge scandal in India, with his mother buying an ad in the paper announcing that she had disowned her son and wouldn't allow for anyone to refer to him as her child.
The Prince also explained how he struggled with his sexuality, eventually getting married in the hopes that his homosexuality was a phase he'd get past. Unlike many other gay men in India, he wasn't coerced into getting married, but went into his wedding willingly. Oprah questioned him quite a bit about his wife and how she felt in the marriage, getting him to admit that he made her miserable by ignoring her and showing no interest in her physically. Next she talked with Staceyann Chin, a New York-based poet, playwright and performer originally from Jamaica. Stacyann fled Jamaica after she was sexually assaulted by a gang of boys in a public restroom for being a lesbian. She explained:
Before introducing Stacyann, Oprah told the audience that there were over 100 violent incidents against LGBT people in Jamaica in a period of just six months, and hearing Stacyann talk about being the subject of one such attack brought the reality crashing down. Here's a clip from the interview: Stacyann also talked longingly about Jamaica, sometimes sounding homesick for the country where she was born. It's still home to her, even if it's not a place where she can feel safe. It was clear that the conflict between wanting a place that feels like home and wanting to feel safe was clearly a painful situation for Stacyann. Oprah also talked to John Amaechi, the NBA player who came out recently. Oprah quickly brought up the anti-gay statement made by Tim Hardaway and the fact that Hardaway apologized for what he said. Amechi expressed a need to see more contriteness from Hardaway:
Youths from around the world (the majority coming from North America) told Amaechi that they were feeling less safe after Hardaway's statements, that bullies had been emboldened by what he said. Amaechi seemed unconvinced that Hardaway was fully aware of this effect. Still, Amaechi was open to forgiving Hardaway: "Redemption is an important concept and he deserves that."
In the final segment, Oprah talked with Rachel Dowd of The Advocate. She identified Sweden as the country with the most progressive attitude towards LGBT people -- homosexuality has been decriminalized there since 1944, Dowd noted, while the United States took until 2003. Dowd had an optimistic attitude for the future of LGBT people: "We're making progress in pockets," she said, "It's not uniform and it's not happening all at once but the more people who are brace and come out, they balance the homophobia." Dowd cited Ellen DeGeneres hosting the Oscars as a sign of progress and Oprah agreed, telling the audience of how her participation in "The Puppy Episode" (where DeGeneres' character came out) inspired some of the worst hate mail she had seen in her entire career. Against that anecdote, it does seem like quite a distance traveled in a short time. The episode was also peppered with stories of the difficulties gay people face throughout the world. That included the United States, where she reminded the audience that a majority of states allow employers to fire someone for no other reason than being gay. Considering the audience that Oprah reaches, this was a landmark moment for gay visibility. This was a show that gave a glimpse of the experiences of gay and lesbian people in a way that was very easy to empathize with and emphasized that when the topic is hate crimes, discrimination or any kind of inequality, there are human faces paying the price of other people's ignorance. Submitted by on Thu, 2007-10-25 11:14. |
User login![]() Recent comments
Recent blog posts
New forum topicsPut AfterElton.com headlines on your site/blog: |





His mother was the first thing that Oprah asked him about and the Prince answered that he wasn't surprised by her reaction: "I don't blame her, I blame her ignorance." It wasn't so difficult to accept her reaction, he explained, since they were always distant (he was raised by governesses). When they did speak to each other, he explained, they never referred to each other by familiar names. Instead he referred to her as "Her highness" while she called him "The Prince".
Hearing Stacyann talk about her attack was one of the episode's most chilling moments. Stacyann talked about being frozen by fear: "I thought I was going to fight but I was petrified." She said she still blames herself for the attack, wondering if she did something to bring it upon herself and feeling frustrated that she didn't fight her attackers harder. She had always thought of herself as someone with a big voice, someone who'd fight to defend herself until she found herself unable to act when facing hostility.
When asked about his decision to come out publicly, Amaechi talked about attending a gay pride event in Manchester. Seeing Sir Ian McKellen had an affect on him: "I saw the way people reacted ... he uplifted people's spirits ... if I could have a small part of that it'd be marvelous." Amaechi's coming out turned out to be even more important than he expected, however. While he prepared himself for a backlash, he was surprised at how many people were willing to learn something about gay people through him. One woman he encountered in New York even told him, "Before you, I didn't realize Black people could be gay." 
Excellent Recap
Excellent recap. I think Oprah was really touched by Stacyann's wanting to go home. I thought that was a very powerful moment because that's a feeling many gay people experience whether it's with their family, job or hometown. They want to be with those things even though they may be hostile toward them.
I loves me some Staceyann
ugh....
LyleMasaki wrote:
Yesterday's Oprah Winfrey Show was quite amazing to watch, as it featured the kind of coming out experiences we don't hear about very often. The show started with Prince Manvendra Singh Gohil of India, who came out after a nervous breakdown prompted by a miserable, closeted marriage. The Prince's coming out was a huge scandal in India, with his mother buying an ad in the paper announcing that she had disowned her son and wouldn't allow for anyone to refer to him as her child.
The Prince also explained how he struggled with his sexuality, eventually getting married in the hopes that his homosexuality was a phase he'd get past. Unlike many other gay men in India, he wasn't coerced into getting married, but went into his wedding willingly. Oprah questioned him quite a bit about his wife and how she felt in the marriage, getting him to admit that he made her miserable by ignoring her and showing no interest in her physically.
Next she talked with Staceyann Chin, a New York-based poet, playwright and performer originally from Jamaica. Stacyann fled Jamaica after she was sexually assaulted by a gang of boys in a public restroom for being a lesbian. She explained:
Before introducing Stacyann, Oprah told the audience that there were over 100 violent incidents against LGBT people in Jamaica in a period of just six months, and hearing Stacyann talk about being the subject of one such attack brought the reality crashing down.
Here's a clip from the interview:
Stacyann also talked longingly about Jamaica, sometimes sounding homesick for the country where she was born. It's still home to her, even if it's not a place where she can feel safe. It was clear that the conflict between wanting a place that feels like home and wanting to feel safe was clearly a painful situation for Stacyann.
Oprah also talked to John Amaechi, the NBA player who came out recently. Oprah quickly brought up the anti-gay statement made by Tim Hardaway and the fact that Hardaway apologized for what he said. Amechi expressed a need to see more contriteness from Hardaway:
Youths from around the world (the majority coming from North America) told Amaechi that they were feeling less safe after Hardaway's statements, that bullies had been emboldened by what he said. Amaechi seemed unconvinced that Hardaway was fully aware of this effect. Still, Amaechi was open to forgiving Hardaway: "Redemption is an important concept and he deserves that."
In the final segment, Oprah talked with Rachel Dowd of The Advocate. She identified Sweden as the country with the most progressive attitude towards LGBT people -- homosexuality has been decriminalized there since 1944, Dowd noted, while the United States took until 2003. Dowd had an optimistic attitude for the future of LGBT people: "We're making progress in pockets," she said, "It's not uniform and it's not happening all at once but the more people who are brace and come out, they balance the homophobia."
Dowd cited Ellen DeGeneres hosting the Oscars as a sign of progress and Oprah agreed, telling the audience of how her participation in "The Puppy Episode" (where DeGeneres' character came out) inspired some of the worst hate mail she had seen in her entire career. Against that anecdote, it does seem like quite a distance traveled in a short time.
The episode was also peppered with stories of the difficulties gay people face throughout the world. That included the United States, where she reminded the audience that a majority of states allow employers to fire someone for no other reason than being gay. Considering the audience that Oprah reaches, this was a landmark moment for gay visibility. This was a show that gave a glimpse of the experiences of gay and lesbian people in a way that was very easy to empathize with and emphasized that when the topic is hate crimes, discrimination or any kind of inequality, there are human faces paying the price of other people's ignorance.
The Prince's Bravery
Sorry it just says my name up there with no comments. Just learned this system! Anyway....I think the Prince showed a lot of bravery coming out like that considering that he lives in a country where acting on your gayness can be punishable by death. Granted it may be easier for him because he is royalty...but on the other hand...he has so much more to lose that way. After all, his mother did "disown" him even though he is still living in the palace and they "run into" each other occasionally. It wasn't made clear whether or not he can still be king. It's tough for me to say what I would do in his situation. After all, the idea of wearing a crown on my head and sitting on a throne would be pretty tempting!
Seriously though, this segment of the show merely emphasized how easier it is in the US to be Gay even though there's still work to be done. Leave it to Oprah to land this interview....a crowned head from the Far East (where they take Royalty so much more seriously.....I mean they actually still "rule" over there unlike...say England ..where they're pretty much just figureheads. I wish good luck to him. I'm sure he doesn't have trouble finding dates though. Being a Royal gives you built-in props..ha ha!
A sober reminder to LGBTs
in the more liberal North American and European societies about how difficult it is for LGBT people elsewhere. I have noticed that societies that treat women as second class citizens quite often do the same to gays.
I am not surprised that Jamaica is a hotbed of homophobia, it is a society that is prone to violence. It has a high murder rate, mainly due to the drug trade.
A gay or lesbian from a Moslem country would have been an interesting addition to these interviews.
Cheers
JBE