Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

San Diego school censors sixth-grader's report on Harvey Milk

This is sad and frustrating in so many ways. According to the ACLU, a San Diego County school stopped students from hearing a sixth-grader's report on Harvey Milk.

Natalie Jones decided to do her class project on the gay rights leader after watching his story told in the Oscar-winning film Milk. The day before she was supposed to present her report to the class, however, her mother was told that Natalie's classmates would need to have their parents sign a permission slip before they would be allowed to see Natalie's presentation, which would not be presented during class but rather during a different period, outside of the classroom.

The school decided that Natalie's report dealt with a "sensitive" topic and fell under its sex education policy, thus requiring the permission slips. Apparently the school board believes that it's just impossible to discuss Harvey Milk's accomplishments without a side discussion on human sexuality.

You can check out Natalie's presentation for yourself. It doesn't bring up anything that I'd categorize as "sex education", unless you don't see gay people as being anything more than their sex lives and consider acknowledging the existence of gay people as being "sexual content".

  • Lyle Masaki's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Liz T's picture

    HA

    so ridiculous, i laugh. HA!

    was harvey milk fighting for rights to have sex with men? ah, of course. that's all gay men seem to be about (for some dumb reason, lesbians get off free) sex, sex, sex!!!

    the mind boggles at the ignorance of all this. wow.

     

     

    Hollywood Marie's picture

    In what world

    ...do "lesbians get off free?" Not only are women (straight or gay or bi or whatever) the sex class, but lesbians are only here for men's enjoyment, ie porn. The first thing straight men (read: society, well the part that has the power) think of when they hear "lesbian" is "threesome." Are you saying that lesbians aren't (over)sexualized? Lesbians are automatically part of two oppressed groups. That comment just wasn't thought out at all. Other than that, yes, very ignorant indeed.
    Liz T's picture

    what i mean is...

    I think those uncomfortable with gay issues mainly have a problem with gay MEN. gay women usually aren't seen as threatening or gross or even sinful to some people. that's what i mean. sorry, didn't mean to offend.

    Crabby Lioness's picture

    So sad.

    Good to see the kids understand it better than the grownups.
    db's picture

    Harvey Milk Report

    I'm so impressed--I would never have been brave enough to do a report on Harvey Milk when I was in 6th grade.
    MyNumber99's picture

    I did a report on Oscar

    I did a report on Oscar Wilde in 12th grade.  I certainly did not get the most mature reaction when mentioning his realtionships with men.  I can't imagine what a sixth grade response would be.
    bienvert's picture

    Crazy

    As a citizen and teacher in San Diego county, I find this to be shameful that the school district is preventing this powerpoint from happening. How would people react if a student couldn't do a report on Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., Ghandi, or other civil rights leaders. Or, to prevent research based on someone because of their sexuality. Bye bye Shakespeare, Achilles, Alexander the Great... Education is about training our students to think critically for themselves, not censor them.  Too bad for Natalie and her classmates that small-mindeness is prevailing in Ramona, CA.

    Unfortunately there is a lot of fear from the other side.  How can we change their hearts and minds?

    Average (2 votes):
    see individual ratings
    Mister 2's picture

    Time

    Politics was a code word keeping Strange Fruit out of major record labels and now they're using 'sexuality'. 

     Oh sure, it's not political when it's maintaining the status quo. And how is this http://samej-eh.deviantart.com/art/Happy-kiss-Zoro-Luffy-color-117911875 more sexual than this: http://Natthy.deviantart.com/art/Nami-y-Sanji-Kiss-101000813 

    Crabby Lioness's picture

    Unfortunately education is seldom about critical thinking.

    All too often it's about training people to, in the words from South Pacific, "hate those your fathers want you to hate."
    Gravity81's picture

    That's...

    ...ridiculous. Harvey's life and activism has nothing to do with "sex ed" or "family life". It's fighting for justice and equality!
    RJ's picture

    I wonder how that school will handle "Harvey Milk Day"?

    Will it refuse to acknowledge the day at all?