News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Seattle Men's Chorus sparks controversey

The Seattle Men's Chorus, which claims to be the largest gay men's chorus in the world, meant to get people thinking with their program "Scared Faithless: God and Gays in the 21st Century" but the topic has turned out to be more controversial than expected. Fliers for the performance included a picture of two anti-gay protesters carrying signs saying "God hates fags" and "You're going to hell." When local merchants (who had previously posted ads for the group's past performances) saw the fliers, many refused to display them, finding the words "fag" and "hell" offensive. Even members of the chorus paused at the image, worrying that displaying the posters would violate company policies.

Then again, the performance doesn't play things safe, either. The program, which means to explore the conflicted feelings gays have towards faith -- the comfort and healing faith can offer even as public dialogue makes them feel unwelcome in a church, temple or mosque. The performance will mix classical sacred music with songs meant to open a window into those conflicted emotions.

The mixed reactions to the fliers probably mirror the feeling the performance means to invoke in its audience. After all, people uncomfortable with the sight of anti-gay protesters would probably be similarly uncomfortable hearing a song titled "God Hates Fags." In some ways, I find the controversy comforting, considering how it was only a few months ago that we wondered if there was a double-standard in the reaction to an anti-gay slur, as opposed to the quick reactions to racial slurs. Maybe we're not ready to have a conversation about homophobia, but at least such openly anti-gay voices cause discomfort.

After the break, check out a promotional video for the performance. If you live in the Seattle area, "Scared Faithless" will be performed tonight and tomorrow night at McCaw Hall. You can find out more information at the chorus' website.

  • LyleMasaki's blog
  • Login or register to post comments
  • Brother Lyn's picture

    Someone goofed

    I commend The Seattle Gay Men's Chrous for this show. I wish I could see it but I'm on the other coast.

    However, and this comes from a background in broadcasting, when it comes to marketing this show someone really dropped the ball.

    Two fliers should have been made. One a generic for placement in "straight" businesses, the other, as it has been printed, for LGBT businesses.

    This would have accomplished getting the word out about the show to more people.

    With that being said (I can't believe I just typed that) "bad press" is better than no press at all. I haven't read or checked out (I will though) the Seattle press for any stories on the "controversey" which the flier may be bringing.

    Again great to put this show out there for people to see and perhaps learn from it, but whoever does the group's marketing may not have done them any favors.

    Mad Mick's picture

    Conflicted on Faith? I think NOT.

    "The program, which means to explore the conflicted feelings gays have towards faith..."

    Hi Lyle,

    Don't want to be mean, but that's a VERY broad brush you used. The insertion of "some" or "many" or even "the majority of" before "gays" would have been acceptable but the fact is that a great many gays are not conflicted on faith. While I personally dismiss out of hand the Semitic and Neo-Semitic theological myths, I have gay friends who subscribe whole-heartedly to their visions of the Jewish and Christian versions of those myths (I don't know any faithful Muslims).

    In fact, the Seattle Gay Men's Chorus poster and presentation seem to assume that gay crises of faith only happen to Christians. That in itself is a pretty sad and limited vision.

     

    LyleMasaki's picture

    Sorry, Mick, you're right. I

    Sorry, Mick, you're right. I remember when I started writing this post I did make sure to say "some" but I must've lost it while trying to clean up the language.

    However, in reviewing materials about the story, I'd say they don't make that assumption. My impression is that the majority of the performance was focused on Christianity, but in the promotional material I remember Buddhism being discussed.


    User login

    Recent comments

    After Elton home page on logo online