Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Charles Nelson Reilly dies at 76

Charles Nelson Reilly was one of those celebrities whose name was widely recognized, but many folks--especially younger ones--had little idea what he was actually famous for. In fact, mention of his name over the past ten years often provoked the response "He's still alive?"

Sadly, that statement is now accurate as Reilly died this past Friday from pneumonia after a year long illness. His only survivor is his partner Patrick Hughes III, whom Reilly met in the early 80's on a gameshow called Battlestars.

I think what's most important to remember about Reilly is that he provided a stepping stone between the era of completely closeted actors and today when T.R. Knight and Neil Patrick Harris can be openly gay. Yes, Reilly was a somewhat campy figure, but for many gay men of the 70's he was daring and was a role model when there were precious few. Homophobia likely robbed him of the career he should have had, but he persevered nonetheless and improved life for those gay men who came after him.

Like many somewhat famous people, by the end of his life Reilly was well-known for mostly one thing, but actually had a multi-faceted career, much of which is long forgotten. In Reilly's case, he was tagged as the game show guy (along with Paul Lynde) having appeared on Match Game from 1972-1982. Reilly later lamented that being associated with the game show killed his serious acting career which included a Tony Award. In a 2001 interview with The Advocate Reilly said. "You can't do anything else once you do game shows. You have no career."

Like Hollywood Squares' Lynde, Reilly often adopted an exaggerated, campy persona on air. But Reilly also appeared dozens of times on The Tonight Show with Johnny Carson and had roles on shows as diverse as McMillan and Wife (with Rock Hudson), The X-Files, and Spongebob Squarepants.

Reilly didn't officially come out until his one man stage show Save It For the Stage: The Life of Reilly in 1999, but Reilly also said he never hid his sexuality and was even told being so openly gay hurt his career. The name for his play was inspired by his mother who used to interrupt him while speaking by telling him to "Save it for the stage".

Some other Reilly facts:

  • At age thirteen survived the Hartford Circus Fire which killed nearly 200 audience members. Reilly refused to ever sit in an audience again
  • Got his stage break in a minor role in Bye Bye Birdie in 1960
  • Won a Tony for his role in 1962's How To Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
  • As an acting teacher taught Lily Tomlin and Bette Midler
  • Received a Best Director Tony nomination in 1997
After the jump you can watch the trailer for film version of Save it For the Stage which gives you a much better sense of who Reilly really was rather than any of his campy Match Game appearances. Our condolences to Mr. Reilly's partner.

Sakhmet's picture

Good night, my fair

Good night, my fair darling.  Your star might not have burned as brightly as you wanted it, but I can think of none other so many have gazed upon and not wished.  Forever in my fondest, most cherished memories you will be.  Rest well, you earned it.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Bobbyjoe's picture

He Made Us Laugh Our [Blank] Off.

Charles Nelson Reilly was my first favorite villain back when I was a kid, when he played "Hoodoo" on "Lidsville" (and who wouldn't be evil if you lived in a town full of talking hats? In my opinion, headgear should be seen and not heard.)  I saw Jo Anne Worley (!) talking about him on CNN today and it was kind of the perfect, fun way for Reilly to be remembered.  She noted how they filmed five episodes of "Match Game" in a day, and how there was usually a party atmosphere where everyone would have cocktails during the breaks, so that if you watch the shows that would have appeared on Thursdays and Fridays everyone's a lot more, uhhh, creative.  So let's take our (talking) hats off and have a toast to Charles Nelson Reilly, who if you grew up in the seventies could make you feel like you were at a cocktail party, even if you were home sick from school, watching Match Game in the afternoon. 
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
BeNicetoPaulLynde's picture

:( We Miss You, Charles

A true classic. Just a few years back he was the Mad Hatter on a float in the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade -- a role that suited him to a "tea". He and Brett Sommers are having sidecars in one of heaven's classier hotel bars as we speak.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Brother Lyn's picture

One of the Good Guys

I was sad to read in the paper the passing of Charles Nelson Reilly. Between him and Paul Lynde, when I was growing up I wished they could have been my fairy Godfathers.

I use to roll on the floor laughing watching The Ghost and Mrs. Muir (first run, kids, not Nick at Nite) and the antics of Charles. And then when he was on Match Game, it was complete tears rolling down my face laughing, just like watching Paul Lynde on Bewitched and The Hollywood Squares

So now my two gay comedic icons are gone. I can just imagine what Heaven must be like with both Charles and Paul up there.

Hope the Good Lord has a few boxes of tissues handy.  He's gonna need them !!!

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings