IMHO: "Brothers & Sisters" (3.05): "You Get What You Need" and that includes Scotty finally showing up
Did you see last night's Brothers & Sisters? Scotty (Luke Macfarlane) showed up! In more than one scene! And he was eating the food — not serving it! Can you believe it? Okay, I'm being rather sarcastic, but the presence of Scotty is just part of the reason I'm giving this episoe an up-arrow. To find out the rest my reasons, click through the jump! (And if that isn't enough reason, I'm posting more pics of Kevin and Scotty from the episode where they visited a nudist camp. Hey, I know what sells!) ***(SPOILER ALERT)*** This episode picks up Kevin's work storyline from episode 3.03: "Tug of War" with Kevin's boss, AKA Agent Skinner, inviting him to a cocktail party where, it is implied, the big announcement will be made that Kevin has made partner. Agent Skinner: "Now that I know how this storyline finishes, I wish I'd gone for the part of Saul's boyfriend instead. I hear Rifkin is a pretty good kisser."
As in partner in the law firm, not Scotty's partner. If you have to ask why the firm isn't celebrating Kevin's civil union, then you haven't been paying enough attention. But Kevin isn't the only with a storyline tonight as Scotty's less-than-tolerant parents, Bertha and Wally Wandell, have driven over from Arizona to visit their son and the lawyer/sodomite who seduced him into the gay lifestyle. Scotty's mom: "I can't believe I'm missing my Touched by an Angel marathon for this!" Scotty's dad: "Hmm, you know Kevin might just be a hotter guy than my wife is a woman. Way to go, Scotty!"
In order to make it to the cocktail party where it will be announced he's made partner, Kevin has to reschedule dinner for 9 PM instead of 7 PM which is very off-putting to Scotty's parents as apparently only the French and queers eat after seven at night. In order to mollify them, Kevin shanghais Kitty and Robert into coming to dinner. Turns out they are heroes to Scotty's winger parents. Frankly, I pegged them more as Rush Limbaugh/Newt Gingrich Republicans. Kitty: "I can't believe I'm missing my Ally McBeal marathon for this!" Robert: "I am SO the prettiest thing at this table! Hell, I'm the prettiest thing in the restaurant!"
Naturally, Kevin is late forcing Kitty and Robert to make small talk with the sort of folks who actually support their polices. Awkward! In this scene, poor Scotty looks like a damsel strapped to the railroad tracks as an out-of-control train hurtling toward him. And that train happens to be named Kevin!
Presuming his sweetie pie has been named partner, Scotty has the champagne ready to go to toast Kevin when he finally arrives. Of course, this leads to mucho grande awkwardness on Kevin's part. Matthew Rhys really rocked this scene. His embarrassment and anger here are palpable. Scotty: "Kevin is the only Walker here, so there won't be any yelling, right? Right?" Kevin: "I can't believe I'm missing my All Things Wine marathon for this."
Being a Walker, Kevin is naturally prone to wearing his emotions on his sleeve, but Scotty's mom behaves like such a beyotch — making digs about how approrpriate it is for Robert and Kitty to adopt but looking horrified when it's suggested Kevin and Scotty might and whining how they were supposed to be seated on the patio — that Kevin finally loses it and tells her off as well as annnouncing he turned down being partner and is now going to work for ... Robert! Personally, I loved the moment he told Scotty's mom off even though it was wildly inappropriate. I've spent too much time with folks behaving exactly like this to not enjoy watching her get her comeuppance.
The Wandell's storm off just as Scotty realizes Kevin forgot to book them a hotel. (Which raises the question, where has their stuff been all this time? They spent the day sightseeing with Scotty and have definitely changed clothes. Where? The restaurant bathroom?) The storyline wraps up with Kevin coming home to find Scotty sitting on the couch fuming. Kevin immediately starts with the mea culpas (which I think is Latin for "Is there anymore wine around?). At first, Scotty doesn't soften, but when Kevin tells him that he didn't get the partnership and that all he wanted was to look into Scotty's eyes and get a hug, Scotty softens and puts down the baseball bat he'd been hiding behind his back. The next day, we see Kevin dropping by Kitty and Robert's to — surprise, surprise! — take the job for real. All in all, I found the episode very solid Kevin and Scotty-wise. First, it was nice to see so much Scotty and not just gliding around in the background. I also very much enjoyed seeing them as a couple with all the issues couples face — bitchy inlaws, job problems, general personality conflicts. The writers promised us that Kevin and Scotty would face issues other Kevin's commitment problems and it is nice to see them follow through. I also thought it was an especially nice contrast in comparison to Justin and Rebecca's storyline about finally getting it on. See gay people aren't just all about sex! With the vote on Proposition 8's anti-gay constitutional amendment just a week away, I think it's great for Middle America to see Kevin and Scotty having some of the exact same sorts of problems they do. Of course, that's just IMHO. Who else watched the episode? Thoughts?
Submitted by on Mon, 2008-10-27 12:00. Kevin working for a Repub.Submitted by
retropian (125 points) (26 posts) on Mon, 2008-10-27 16:19.Well, I know I'm no genius yet Kevin not making partner and acceptng the job offer from the Senator is what I predicted last week. This almost make me think the show has jumped the shark, at least for me. A story line is pretty weak if even I can predict it. So why watch? I'd rather be surprised by a story line. The part that really pissed me off though was when Kevin shows up at the Senator and Kitty's place to officially accept the job and states something like "Demonizing the other cuts both ways." that he's guilty of demonzing Scotty's mother to his own detriment is true. That is valid on an individual level, hate poisons both parties. But, working for somebody who represents a political platform that in large parts uses hate and bigotry towards gays, that makes demonizing gay people, fellow Americans as part of its political platform is repugnant. The idea that by working on the inside to change a party platform is wishfull thinking. The Log Cabin Republicans are case in point. If anything the anti-gay stance of the party has intensified over the last 20 years despite their efforts to gain respect. If anything they have little repect from their own party or from the gay community. What a success. The best way to oppose a platform is by just that, opposing it. vote its adherants and supporters out of office.
I agree with CatSubmitted by
atweaver (365 points) (69 posts) on Mon, 2008-10-27 17:05.I agree with Cat that the scene where Kevin and Scotty 'make up' could have been stronger. There needed to be more than just a hug.
Have To DisagreeSubmitted by
Dave Doty (4877 points) (1065 posts) on Mon, 2008-10-27 23:23.Kevin had a really bad day. In his own words, or close to it, all he really needed was a hug to make him feel better, which is what he got.
I also liked the confrontation between Holly and Nora. It was far from a classic moment for the series, but so far this season the big confrontations have been a little too emotionally raw, with too few of the played-for-comedy type fights that I remember fondly from past seasons. So while the scene may have been lukewarm, at least it was an attempt at something I've been missing.
I prefer humor injected into the fights/ family dinners, with the real emotion coming through in subsequent quieter scenes.
And did anyone else see flashes of Arvin Sloane in Saul tonight? Don't be so quick to joke about Uncle Saul rubbing her out, Tommy... he's done much, much worse.
There's been a definite learning curve for the new showrunnners, and I don't think they're there quite yet, but I'm starting to have faith that they will get there in the end.
Most of my thoughts haveSubmitted by
LgH (160 points) (35 posts) on Mon, 2008-10-27 21:26.Most of my thoughts have already been expressed above, but I will add that while Kevin's actions at dinner can be excused partially by Colonel Caldwell's news ( never knew him as Agent Skinner ), I will not overlook his complete blanking on the agreed preparations for Ma and Pa W's visit. IE the Bourbon, the photo, the HOTEL !! Scotty should NOT have let him off the hook for that..
I'm Sorry, But....Submitted by
Anthony D. Langford (7385 points) (1615 posts) on Mon, 2008-10-27 23:11.I thought that Scotty was much, much, much too forgiving to Kevin. Kevin ruined the evening, embarassed and humlilated Scotty's mother (even if she deserved, he shouldn't have done it out of respect for his spouse) and all because of his own issues. Not to mention forgetting about the hotel!? It wasn't their fault he didn't make partner so why should they have to pay for it? The speech about needing a hug was sweet, but it still made it all about Kevin and his issues and pretty much swept what he did under the rug. I think Scotty has been declawed since he married Kevin. He used to challenge Kevin and stand up to him and not take any of his crap. Now he's a spineless wimp. And Kevin going to work for the Senator reeks of a bad plot device (not to mention it'll give Robert and Kitty even more airtime). Does Kevin really think he can change things from within? Really? Does he watch the news, pick up a newspaper, ever? Kevin is supposed to be smarter than that. It's as if he had no other job options when surely there is a gay friendly office he could work at or start his own firm. But to completely give up being a laywer? It is utterly, utterly implausible. I'm bored with Rebecca and Justin. Move on please. I hate the hausfrau Sarah has become. And Tommy and Saul are as tedious as ever. And I love the actresses who play Nora and Holly, but even they couldn't save that badly written final scene. The episode was okay, but overall this season is lacking the sharp writing and interesting plotting of the previous years. The plots are getting sloppy (sometimes boring) and hard to believe and the characters aren't acting like themselves. The acting is always wonderful. I just wish the stories were up to the talent of the people playing them out. Sadly, it's still one of the better show on television... which tells you state of TV drama, IMO. Kevin/ScottySubmitted by
Marea67 (390 points) (101 posts) on Tue, 2008-10-28 03:21.I don't think that Scotty turned into a wimp. He told Kevin exactly how he felt, at the same time he was willing to listen to Kevin, rather then hold on to his own grudge. Which is a rather mature thing to do. When he gave Kevin the hug, it was not all 'forgiven and forgotten' yet. And it would be hard for Kevin to apologise to Scotty without explaining what happened to him and HIS life. Kevin took Scotty's anger very seriously, he understood that he had crossed a line and he didn't try to wipe it away as if Scotty's feelings didn't matter. I do feel that Kevin was very insensitive to Scotty before though. Scotty wanted to book the hotel, but Kevin insisted he would do it. Scotty didn't ask for the picture in an forgetable moment, Kevin himself suggested that the picture should be signed by both Kitty and Robert. And then he completely forgets about his own suggestions and Scotty and his parents? Rather careless. And of course we never got anything more then a hug. Had you expected anything more? Be glad we got a hug, it is as 'physical' as they seem to be allowed to get. (I would have NO objections to ABC to prove me wrong on these words.) Did anyone notice?Submitted by
Randy (584 points) (117 posts) on Tue, 2008-10-28 08:06.This episode was directed by Rob Lowe's brother Chad. Considering this it is surprising that the whole episode didn't focus on Kitty and Robert. Live Long and Prosper liked this episodeSubmitted by
Bountiful (1290 points) (344 posts) on Tue, 2008-10-28 21:02.I was happy with this episode. Kevin's emotions were so realistic, even when his actions wern't necessarily excusable. I ended up forgiving him at the end, because I felt as if he really did understand the extent of his mistakes. It was actually sweet that he was willing to be vulnerable about his emotional needs when Scotty was so mad at him. (If somebody does this could become a manipulative tactic, but I don't think Kevin is one to reveal his insecurities too often.) I'm just sad that Kevin's getting more involved with Robert, who annoys me. I definitely would like to see more of Scotty, though. At least he gets better treatment than Tommy's wife, and he's on about equal footing as Justin's girlfriend. But Kitty's annoying husband gets way more screen time than him. Tommy was slightly more likeable in this episode. He may become a full fledged character, yet. |
![]() Recent Comments
Recent blog posts
|





















It was good to see Kevin/Scotty, but...
...I was bit underwhelmed. I suppose I just have a very strong anti-Rob Lowe emotion, but why does Kevin constantly have to humiliate himself in front of the sanctimonious Robert?
And the whole forgetting the hotel thing was ridiculous, as if TPTB just wanted to humiliate Kevin more.
Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/
Underwhelmed, yeah.
The dinner....
The dinner scenes did make me uncomfortable due to bertha's blunt bitchiness towards Kevin and Scotty, but it got worse when Kevin confronted her.
I didn't agree with Robert standing up to Nora (er, his choice of words really), but i understand anyone wanting to defend their loved one/their relationship......that part i understand.I do think Kevin could've handled it better...maybe of waited till the dinner was over or maybe asked bertha to come outside with him for a minute or two....but eh, seeing as his night went from crap to pure hell...i guess it's understandable why he snapped.
Matthew Rhys ROCKED IT OUT!
The 8,000 emotions going on inside of him all being communicate through his eyes and his body. FABULOUS!
His just needing to be touched by Scotty and not being able to was so gut-wrenching. That moment with the hands, I held my breath.
That said, I thought Luke M. was amazing (I love how his nostrils flaire when he's angry and he was ABSOLUTELY RIGHT ABOUT EVERYTHING!)
Whether or not they confront his parents isn't up to Kevin. They are Scotty's parents. He has to negociate that relationship on his terms and Kevin has to support him. Who knows if they've ever even visited him or how much persuading it took from his father (most likely) to get them out to California to see Scotty.
I really hope they show more of Kevin and Scotty standing up for what he needs from their relationship.
I actually really liked the Justin and Rebecca storyline this episode. Both actors are cute as a bug and actually manifest real depth. I loved the writing for Justin who finally looks like he's growing up and I also love that he pegged what was going on for Rebecca (obvious to us but he could have just left and not made her deal with her fear).
I feel like the whole Saul/Tommy bonding and Sarah hanging with her kids thing could have been a separate episode.
More Kevin and Scotty reflecting on the visit from the parents and talking things out would have been a nice ending rather than the visit to Republican Manor! Sigh...
This show is such a soap opera!
Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes