Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

MSNBC's Keith Olbermann takes on Anderson Cooper

MSNBC talking head Keith Obermann is well established as one of the few news anchors out there willing to really speak up about controversial topics. (For the record, I think he's great.) He's repeatedly taken on the Bush Administration, Bill O'Reilly, Rush Limbaugh, and pretty much anyone else he suspects of being a hypocrite. Turns out Olbermann's outspokenness extends to his fellow news anchor Anderson Cooper of CNN. In a recent interview with New York Magazine Olbermann has this to say about Anderson (recently "outed" so to speak by Out magazine):

Don’t tell me you don’t want to talk about personal life when you wrote a book about your father’s death and your brother’s death. You can’t move this big mass of personal stuff out for public display, then people ask questions and you say, ‘Oh, no, I didn’t say there was going to be any questions.’ It’s the same thing as the Bush administration saying, ‘We’re going to war, but you really aren’t allowed to know why.

Don't hold back there, Keith! But that isn't all. Olbermann goes on to say:

Don’t tell me you can’t talk about your personal life and then, when they send you overseas and you do a report that consists of your voice-over and pictures of you in a custom-made, blue-to-match-your-eyes bulletproof vest, looking somberly at these scenes of human devastation—like a tourist—and that’s your report. Your shtick is your personal life.

I think I've made my feelings about outing pretty clear, but I have to say Olbermann has a point. I've long felt that if a celebrity doesn't trade on their personal life to garner publicity (see Ian McKellen) then their private life is off limits. But if they do make appearances with "dates" or, say, write books that spill all the personal beans except for whom they spoon with at night, then they are being a hypocrite and I can't get too outraged when they get questioned about the part of their personal life that for some reason isn't as relevant as the rest.

I think Olbermann's remarks significantly up the pressure on Anderson to come out as Olbermann is main stream media and I wager his remarks are going to be widely reported. Hmm, perhaps I should start writing that coming out blog post now.

(Hat tip to Wayman for sending us the article! And Olbermann's comments about Anderson appear starting at the end of page 5.)

 

Evan's picture

What's it to Him

I have a real problem with a straight person demanding that a gay person come out.  What's it to them?  They do not have to deal with all the consequences.

I stand by the belief that gay people should come out when they are ready.  Having these forced outing makes being gay look bad.  It makes gay people look like they "eat their own." 

As I said in an earlier post I think Jodie Foster should have already come out.  She makes only a film every few years due to a self-imposed rule.  Regarding international reporters it's a different story.  It is not safe at this time for an out gay international reporter.  Do gay people want to see the destruction of an international gay reporter's career just to make a statement?

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

olbermann

are you kidding? a straight person demanding AC come out? How do you know KO is straight? with all that rage, he has to be gay, and also, didn't his girlfriend say he couldn't get it up? Wonder why? As KO would say, grow up, Evan.
Anonymous's picture

Anonymouson

I think you are Bill Orally.
Anonymous's picture

Anderson

I think as a American abroad, Mr Cooper will be on the receiving end of a lot more hate than as a gay man.
Anonymous's picture

I totally agree with you

I totally agree with you Evan - I've always thought that it's a bit of a nerve for straight people to demand that someone come out, or to make fun of them for not doing so, given that they have never had to deal with any of those issues in their own life. If Keith Olbermann was gay, who's to say whether he would have the courage to come out? And, Anonymous Poster 1, if you truly believe that Olbermann is gay and closeted, then that makes it all the more ridiculous for him to call for Anderson Cooper to come out.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

Anderson's Problem

I would have to disagree with the comment that Anderson Cooper would recieve more hate as an American than as gay. The world recognizes the power of journalism to get out the message or point of view.In these times of worldwide access anyone with an internet connection can search for information about anyone else.Also Mr.olbermann seems to be sitting in the cheap seats as it were.Considering some of the places and people that Mr. Cooper reports on he could be setting himself up for problems.In places like Africa there is rampant homophobia and the network would be irresponsible to put their lives in jeopardy.Since there seems to be a light crew when they go off to cover some of these stories it could be tempting fate.So Anderson is supposed to sit at a desk just so someone can feel better about themselves.How sad is that?
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
StraightFemale_YeahThatsRight's picture

I DONT THINK AC HAS A PROBLEM

call me naive but come on guys if he was really gay he would not hide it....why would he not say he is gay if he is not gay...there is no shame in being gay and AC is very open about himself and if he was gay he would say so.  I dont think he is "in the closet" to protect his career...if he was that would contradict everything about him.

How many other "single" news anchors do we hear abouot their SO's...

Anonymous's picture

He should come out

The problem with staying in the closet is that his message to young gay people is that they should be afraid to come out. If this big powerful journalist can't even come out, how could they possibly do it?

The same goes for the guy who played Jack on Will & Grace. It's shameful to me to be part of the biggest gay show in history but refuse to come out. It's embarrassing when everyone else is talking about their partners and their babies in interviews and he's just silent. And given that I can't even remember the actor's name at this point, what does he have to lose by coming out?

But I think the most compelling reason is the Keith Olbermann situation. If you're known to be gay and in the closet, we're at the point where straight people will be willing to do it for you. So if you're a celebrity you have a choice, either come out on your own or be dragged out. Have some dignity.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

Do we really care what Olbermann thinks?

Keith Olbermann cares only for ratings and is simply jealous of Cooper. In his world, he thinks "outing" Anderson, will somehow impact ratings. MS-NBC currently is running a promo with a tag line "Anderson OUT, Keith IN" He has "picked" on Cooper in other publications (Rolling Stone for one). For a man who has a history of bedding his co-workers, interns and fans, and at 48 finally has his FIRST live-in girlfriend (age 23), do we really care what he thinks?
Anonymous's picture

Yes, we should care.

Olberman doesn't deny who he is - he loves cooch and gets as much as possible. He's also very sharp and champions more gay issues than Cooper has the balls to even acknowledge. You can bet your ass that if Olberman interviewd Thomas Roberts he wouldn't have whitewashed Thomas' homosexuality.
Anonymous's picture

I Agree....

Olberman has never hidden the fact that he likes to get as much tail as possible and as long as his partners are willing he's not lying to anyone, what's the big deal? And a middle aged man dating a woman half his age? Shocking. Personally, I'm bored with Anderson Cooper. I used to admire him (and I still do as a newsman). But as a person, I think he's a coward. That said, I understand why he would feel the need to stay closeted (though he really isn't closeted since everyone knows what is painfully obvious) even though I don't think it's necessary. News is filled with openly gay reporters (okay, not filled maybe, but I know of a few here in DC) whose faces and stories we see and read regularly. It doesn't seem to affect their work. I think it would be no different with AC.

Anthony (who recently saw Thomas Roberts in person and he's even better looking than on TV)

Anonymous's picture

Here is why Anderson Pooper stays in the closet

CNN has given Anderson Cooper a huge pay boost -- $50 million over the next five years, the New York Post's "Page Six" column reported today (Thursday). The newspaper quoted a source as saying that Cooper "just got an incremental amount added on to his original contract to keep him happy for the next two years and then will make a much larger amount for the following three years -- all of which will be worth $50 million."

12/04/2007

Source

Anonymous's picture

Anderson = Cheney? Who's really the dick here?

Hey Keith, Why are you being a jerk? If you think you're helping the LBGT population, this isn't the way. If you want to kick up some dust for the sake of ratings, that's despicable. Anderson lists Scissor Sisters and Bob Mould on his top ten playlist, and he's not chaperoning any females around town. He's not frightened of having people connect the dots. Comparing A-Coop to the Bush administration is lunacy. Take a vacation before you get any weirder, please. Andrew
Anonymous's picture

Scissor Sisters means you're gay?

Anonymous wrote:
Scissor Sisters and Bob Mould on his top ten playlist

I guess it's just not the straights that stereotype.

StraightFemale_YeahThatsRight's picture

THANK YOU! I know (i am one)

THANK YOU! I know (i am one) plenty of people regardless of their sexuality who like them...
Anonymous's picture

"He's also very sharp and

"He's also very sharp and champions more gay issues than Cooper has the balls to even acknowledge." Mattie, what gay issues has Olbermann championed? He hasn't had Michael Musto on Countdown since they made fun of Cooper together during an American Idol segment (almost 3 weeks ago). The guy can read a telepromter and retain sports stats. How hard can it be to do special comments against this administration and the way this war is going? The title of this "New York" article is called "Limbaugh for Lefties" Just because he seems to have liberal views doesn't necessarily make him "very sharp". Trust me, he's not that deep, it is all about ratings, money, and professional jealousy.
Anonymous's picture

What has he done?

He's spoken out A LOT about gay rights, gay adoption, gay marriage, gay protection laws, anti-bullying laws, the xian rights attacks on gays. You obviously don't watch the show or look at his clips on Crooks and Liars, You Tube, America Blog and Daily Kos. Keith is WAY more a friend of the community that closeted and scared AC. Keith writes his own editorials, he reads the news.
Anonymous's picture

Olbermann: gay activist, gay baiter or just a Hack?

Mattie: When Olbermann makes statements like this, "It’s the same thing as the Bush administration saying, ‘We’re going to war, but you really aren’t allowed to know why.' When he compares Cooper's "outness" to this administration's WAR policies, it really is insane, and is very transparent in it's hackery. Honestly, when the man makes statements like that, don't you think it kind of lessens any any gay support he may have given in the past? (By the way, reporting "gay" stories, does not mean gay support.) Another example being the racist statements by Imus, he didn't make IMUS a WPITW or do a special comment, because he said, he doesn't go after people in his own network and his bosses wanted him not too (MSNBC was hoping this thing would blow over). Now that it "safe" he can tell the world how much he hated IMUS. It makes one wonder was he "allowed" to do earlier special comments against BUSH because the we are swinging back left and we can safely say the war is a nightmare? Will he have to “ask” permission for future special comments? Maybe he'll have to check with a focus group as well. Really, for Keith Olbermann it is all about ratings, and somehow in his mind, outing Anderson will somehow impact ratings. Whether Anderson Cooper comes out is NOT an ideological issue for Olbermann, it is a "business" decision.
Anonymous's picture

You obviously don't watch him

Anonymous wrote:
(By the way, reporting "gay" stories, does not mean gay support.)

This is commentary, not story reporting. He WRITES the commentary and then does it during his nightly rant. A lot like Bill Maher. He constantly draws comparisons to the hypocrisy of the Bush Administration with their view on gays, gay rights and anti-gay policies.

Until you know what the hell you're talking about or at least watch the show, save your outrage over the treatment of a coward like Anderson Cooper. I'm not talking about reporting the news, I'm talking about his commentaries. He's talked about the gay marriage myth that the religious right and republicans are trying to spin, gays in the military after they lowered the entrance requirements, gays in the military after the translation specialist report, gay adoption after FL passed laws, gay gay gay gay gay. ALL of it was written by him and his POV, NOT a story he was reading off a screen.

Anderson has addressed which of these?

Anonymous's picture

Olberman Only Cares About Ratings? You Can't Be Serious!

Olbermann, who has again and again crafted some of the finest and most intelligent MSM commentary regarding, among other things, gays in the military, first amendment rights, and habeas corpus--at a time when no other major network figure would touch the current administrations assaults against these same items with a ten-foot pole, is a hack and only cares about ratings!?! How arrogant of you to presume that your assessment holds some sort of holy water finality over the substantial amount of articulate Olbermann supporters posting here. There is no logic in your statement, only opinion and raw bias. Olbermann is exceedingly consistent and authentic, and has repeatedly held sway against the tides for and against him. You can like him or not, but as the other responder said, don't speak of things for which you clearly have a limited knowledge. Your absolutist statements, such as an assessment of insanity resulting from your interpretation of one statement from a man you clearly despise, are what's truly transparent in your tirade above. On a final note, every one of us works within the environments in which we exist--and which support said existence. Olbermann must work within certain systems relevant to MSNBC, just as we all must, on occasion, cede power to the entities that provide our livelihoods.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

You win Mattie

You win Mattie, You have ISSUES with Anderson Cooper, and I have ISSUES with Keith Olbermann. I believe we are discussing apples and oranges. By the way Olbermann's program has both NEWS and OPINION.
Anonymous's picture

KO's Kool Aid Show

News and Opinion.....BS**t... KO is a hack that is obsessed with O'Rielly and his ratings. It is pretty well known that he is at least Bi even though anyone who read the blog of Karma knows that he can't get it up at gunpoint. If Dan Patrick didn't give him time on ESPN his Q factor would be single digits. Countdown is just a preview of the Democratic Convention.....never a guest who disagrees just those who drink the same Kool Aid. Now we know because of the Imus stink that everything he says he has to clear through management. Remember recently when he went in for a new contract and they laughed at him. He's just another MSNBC Bush-hater like Matthews, Russert et al.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

Nice Little Rant

Way to stay on topic--I bet you find just about any means to slam the "Democrats," as if we live in a one-party country where it's your way or the highway, right? Most Olbermann fans don't give a rip about his stint on ESPN. His expository speech is far more relevant than anything I've ever heard emerge from your hero O'Reilly, who turns the mic off of anyone who gets the best of him on his show. The topic was whether a straight, or bi (who gives a damn) socio-political commentator like Keith Olbermann, who I deeply admire, has the right to demand that a peer "come out." I feel he does not. Olbermann is hardly the only "Bush-hater," as you so eloquently phrased it, out there. And as if you are some sort of media insider who knows what happens in contract negotiation meetings.
gayerthanu's picture

Straight gay doesn't matter ...

People who are living gay lives are not in the closet. It's my understanding from friends in DC that he's quite openly gay, and is just not saying so for his careers sake. That said, I'm tired of people who won't come out because it's inconvenient. So many people have come out in so many fields that we thought one could never come out in. My partner is a blue collar factory worker, and there is a great deal of machismo in his organization, yet he had the courage to come out and they love him for it. He's made them grow. I think that's our responsibility, and when someone who can have the impact to society like Anderson Cooper, they should be especially ashamed. My belief is that I won't out you if I don't see you in a gay bar, with a man romantically, or anything else that is a benefit you receive because of the courage of someone who came out somewhere along the way. But if you're reaping the benefits, you're fair game!
StraightFemale_YeahThatsRight's picture

IF HE IS OPENLY GAY

then how can he be in the closet??
Anonymous's picture

Anderson Cooper

I don't think Anderson Cooper is gay.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

I love them both, wish they wouldn't fight

Though not a gay person myself, it seems that it would be really helpful to people afraid to come out to see someone like Anderson out in the public eye. Sure, there are other openly gay reporters, but none with his fame and respect. That being said, there are a lot of reasons why I can see why he wouldn't want to come out. Chief among them is the fact that the penalty for homosexuality is death in a lot of the countries he reports from. What bothers me most is the attitude of "don't bother coming out, we don't want you" that I see among certain public figures in the gay community (such as Ann Northrup and Andy Humm). How much harder must that make it to come out, when the people who should accept and embrace you are attacking you instead?
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Anonymous's picture

Olbermann not original in this

One thing you have to consider here is the fact that Olbermann is actually friends with Micheal Musto, and he was basically quoting him here (except for the part where he compared Cooper to Bush. That made no sense, and I know Keith is usally better and sharper than that.) I don't think that Olbermann would ever do something so politically incorrect as to tell a gay man when and how to discuss his private life if he hadn't heard the opinion first from a gay activist.
Anonymous's picture

keith olberman

This man is such an IDIOT!!!! He is so jealous of fox news, especially Bill O'Reilly. Can't believe he really is still on the air, considering how biased his rantings are.I do hope that he will be taken off the air, and a better program will be put in it's place.
Anonymous's picture

keith olberman

This man is such an IDIOT!!!! He is so jealous of fox news, especially Bill O'Reilly. Can't believe he really is still on the air, considering how biased his rantings are.I do hope that he will be taken off the air, and a better program will be put in it's place.
Anonymous's picture

Anderson Cooper

I think the strange part of this is that you think Anderson Cooper is a journalist. Have we sunk that low?

Recent Comments