News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Survivor: China (Episode 1512) Did Todd get blindsided by Amanda?

*** WARNING SPOILERS***

If you are a Todd Herzog fan, watching the last two episodes of Survivor: China has not been a particularly fun experience. Whether via outstanding editing and/or actual representation of the game, our gay powerhouse player has looked like he’s been in serious danger of being voted off.

Last week’s previews made it seem like Todd would finally be blindsided by Amanda, who, after masterminding James' unexpected offing, is starting to remind me of the title character in 1950’s Oscar-winning All About Eve. Will our beloved Todd’s torch be snuffed before its time just as Margo Channing’s was by the outwardly meek Eve? If Todd has not seen Bette Davis’ classic tale of deceptive ambition, I hope that he has enough Mean Girls wisdom to finish off what he started.

The show gets to business right away with a Reward Challenge that has the Final 5 using a replica of a 4th Century Chinese crossbow concoction to fire arrows at a target that has their names randomly written on it. To give it a wicked edge, the number of arrows that each player will fire will be based on how each player “secretly” distributes the 5 arrows that they are given. The winner will get to go on an overnight trip, via private jet, to the Great Wall of China.

Out of the total of 25 red roses (wrong show) arrows to be awarded, there are no surprises, as non-challenging Courtney receives a whopping 12 arrows. Outcast Peih-Gee receives only 1. Denise gets 2, Amanda 4, and our Todd 6. If the game were based on acumen, Todd would have won hands down as he was able to hit his own name with 5 out of the 6 arrows that he received. He would have been followed by Courtney and Denise who tied with only one hit each; however since the winner is based on how many times a player's name gets hit, urban hipster Courtney accidentally hits Denise’s name 5 times to give the Lunch Lady her second reward over Todd in as many weeks.  

Denise is allowed to invite two other players to join her in her reward excursion. She picks Courtney  and Todd, who always gets picked by the members of his alliance as they want to be on his good side. Amanda and a whiny Peih-Gee get sent back to camp with nothing. The winning threesome take off on the private jet, and we are entertained by our favorite flight attendant, who works it by welcoming all on board, announcing that they are on “Survivor Airlines Flight 15”, and making reference to how cool the passengers are. All in all, a cute sequence with Todd being the charming man-boy that he is.

Back in camp, Amanda decides to talk to Peih-Gee. At this stage of the game, the smartest players start being human to even the least popular kids school as they want their votes when they join the Jury. Eve Harrington Amanda manages go from the equivalent of “what was your name again?” to almost braiding Pieh-Gee’s hair and perfecting synchronized swimming routines in the pond. Todd would not be happy seeing this love-fest as it makes so much sense for these two to get rid of him, which they could easily do by bringing Denise on board.

People come back from the Reward Challenge, get in passive-aggressive tiffs, the “nice” Lunch Lady throws "meanie" Todd under the bus, too much rice gets eaten, people complain about others being greedy/thankless/backstabbing/blah, blah, blah. What becomes very clear is that unless Todd wins Individual Immunity, and especially if Peih-Gee wins yet again, he could be joining the Jury before the hour is over.

The Individual Immunity Challenge is another Survivor cycle-ending tradition as it combines elements of previous challenges. To make a long story short, Todd does not win and actually is the first one out of the running. Amanda and Peih-Gee are the last two remaining, but Amanda wins it.

This must have given Todd marginal relief as it makes his leaving tonight less likely, but still very possible. He knows it and says that he will be “livid” if he gets voted off, but also gives the ladies a “big ups” for figuring out how to get rid of him. These words are uttered on his way on Tribal Council.....

At this late stage of the game, Tribal Council is one of the only places where there can be some humor as everyone is so serious. In this cycle, the laughs are generally provided by Courtney as she mocks someone saying something really stupid or self-serving. I am taking to you Amanda! She is also is managing to look even more beautiful with each passing day. I smell Playboy calling. Super stud host Jeff always goes for the jugular at these meetings by asking leading questions to get information that would otherwise not be revealed. Tonight he gets all sorts of dirt. One player says a few seemingly benign things that I predict will secure her loss if she makes it to the finals.

There is a hilarious segment that has Courtney referring to herself as a “Negative Nancy.” Peih-Gee looks disgusted at Courtney's negativity and starts to go on and on about how much she hates that attitude as she's such a “positive person.” This delusional self-assessment elicits a laugh like I’ve never seen from James, followed by the now classic Courtney eye-roll, and a Todd guffaw. Positive? Peih-Gee is more like Debbie Downer's bitter sister, but she has reason to feel  frustrated as she's been putting on a great fight with no one to help her. I grossly underestimated her and actually thought that she was going to be the firt person voted off at the end of the September premiere.

I continue to laugh as Peih-Gee is still going on and on and on about being "honorable" and deserving of being there. Not a smart move as she should continue to play intelligent mind games to secure her spot. The players do their thing, and by a vote of 4 to 1, the 12th player voted off Survivor: China is .... Peih–Gee. I start breathing again for the first time Todd lost Individual Immunity. Denise and Miss Harrinton Amanda give the about to become 6th member of the Jury fake hugs, surely hoping that this will generate good will when it comes to the final vote. I love my Todd as he makes no attempt to hide his youthful happiness by smiling, laughing, making-faces, fake crying for the Jury, and even doing a sitting-down Cabbage Patch, a 1987 short-lived dance club move move that was en vogue when Todd was all of 2-years old. Todd rocks!

Next on Survivor: China! “4 players, 3 Tribal Councils, 2 Hour Finale, 1-Hour Reunion Show” Who says that these writers don't belong with their fiction-writing counterparts? They did lose some steam by billing of the last four players as follows: The “Lunch Lady,” the “Long Shot,” the “Schemer,” and the “Chameleon.” After all this time this is the best that they can do? I would have preferred if the Amanda “billing” would give us clues as to why her backside is perpetually blurred by editing. Does she have an unusually low-hanging butt? The worst wedgie ever? Are there genitalia issues that even my warped mind can’t even contemplate? The editors also blurred her sister last week. Inside joke? What gives? I demand answers.

I am going to win $1,000,000 and I will pay all taxes

Predictions: I am going out on a limb regarding Todd's winning this game because I believe it and to allow people can make fun of me if I am wrong. I predict that no matter which other two players Todd is up against, he will get votes to win from James, Frosti, Jean Robert (yup!), and the one remaining woman who will be the final member of the Jury. Erik and Peih-Gee will likely vote for anyone but Todd. Jamie is my only wild card, but even without her vote, Todd will win!

Check back in on Monday to discuss the finale and live reunion show results! I now even think I know why Amanda's back has been blurred, and now have the stunning picture to prove it. 

JBE's picture

Excellent blog

written like a cliff-hanger.  I was sure you were going to announce that Todd was bye-bye!  I must admit he is looking a bit the worse for wear, he definitely needs some TLC and 3-square meals a day for awhile.  Don't envy him though facing off against those three women in the final four.  Hope your prediction comes true, with all that dough and working for an airline, he will really be able to see the world!

Next week we get to see Josh & Jon in their underwear, now that will be an interesting vblog!

Cheers

JBE

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
jimmyjazz's picture

A GAY GUY WON SURVIVOR!!

HOLLER AT YOUR BITCH!!!!!!!

itsmecoe's picture

about amanda

Will we be able to see what you know about amanda's back ? I wish you were doing these recaps from the beginning of this season. You make it all so interesting.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
northerlites's picture

lot of bows and aarrows..

NorthernLITES

but no quivers? loved you review. are you sure when Amanda returns to camp it was not band camp? i think you have to be right about Todd...he's too decrepit and the choice for the needy vote....i mean who else could it be without losing sponsors..staying tuned to inet and catv...

love it ..thanks..

Raiden251's picture

Sometimes...

..it just seems like this site/blog is totally bias just due to the fact that a person/contestant is gay. No criticism are stated if they even sound slightly negative. I mean, can no one tell that Todd has become so unbelievably smug and some-what unlikeable because of it? I mean, "youthful happiness by smiling, laughing, making-faces" Really? It's smells more like smugness and arrogance to me. I bet if Todd is revealed to be a rapist killer, this site would still go "Awww" and call him cute.
Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
springintoaction's picture

I can only speak for me, but I strongly disagree with the post

You say "I bet if Todd is revealed to be a rapist killer, this site would still go "Awww" and call him cute."

Not at all.

I am a huge fan of Survivor and probably have seen every single episode. My favorite player ever is the amazing Rupert Boneham, who is not gay and some would argue downright Hagar The Horrible meets Fred Flinstone. I was rooting for him more than for any contestant EVER, and that in includes even Todd this season. I thought that Rupert was so cute too.

Todd is the 10th only gay contestant on the show, and with the exception of two lesbians in cycle 9 (Scout and Amy), none of the gay contestants has done nothing for me in the least bit. I quite enjoyed Richard Hatch's game in season 1, but would never call him anything cuddly as he was possibly reality TV's first gay villain. For me it was great to see a gay male uncontrolled by fiction to be as bad as he wanted to be. Without him and Susan Hawke, maybe Survivor would have not become 2000's runaway hit. Richards's play on the show was amazing, but apparently not quite a role model in life. But this to me is about winning $1,000,000 and not the 700 Club, that most players like to convince themselves it is when asked why they should him. I can put money on the table that Todd won't be begging for votes using revisionist history

With regard to Todd, I've loved him from day 1 and not even because he is gay (icing on the cake for sure) as he to seems not to even be an issue as he actually seems to downplay that even more than I'd like. I think that mainstream media is loving any chance to portray him as a Richard Hatch. Jr because it's easy short-hand.

Laughing and making faces? Yes he was. Out of arrogance? I doubt it as his butt was so on the line. It was probably relief. If you find him smug and somewhat unlikable, that's ok, as maybe he's not looking for our approval, which sometimes even makes one even more likable. I loved straight Rob Mariano ("The Godfather") on his two visits to the show as he was fun to watch.

I find Todd to be a really good player as he understands that this is a social game. Amanda gets called a Chameleon on the show while she got rid of James and plotted to get rid of Todd. She called Denise all sorts of bad things when talking to PG. Denise too has been working the angle. Courtney seems to be the only player not have any game and I actually like her now, even with her remarks about Todd. Todd is pure entertainment for me and I've called him on not winning challenges and getting beaten by even Courtney.

My little crush on Todd and my picking him to win it from day 1 was based on seeing a video on cbs.com in whic he highights what his plan to win is. If you watch that, you'll see that he's stayed on course. Win or lose, he will be in my list of favorite players that the show has had. Will he head the list? Nope. Rupert and Ozzie (straight too), and porbably even Ricahrd Hatch are still ahead of him as there is something to be said about being the first winner of show that had never aired. Great game player, who seemingly like to take short-cuts in life. Not a role model, but Todd may actually be one. If I were a confused closetted gay kid and saw Todd on TV, I would be psyched as he is out there living his life and not portraying self as a victim.

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
nf63's picture

Who plays George Sanders?

I absolutely love the comparison between Amanda and Eve Harrington. You really kept the tension going with the play-by-play. Now I'm curious as to the blurry butts, LOL! Todd's face in that photo twith the million dollar caption has the wicked, playful sneer of Neil Patrick Harris's devious but lovable manipulator Barney Stinson in How I Met Your Mother. Makes me wonder what's going on in that noggin…

And two questions about the Cabbage Patch: How do you do it, and How do you know (in that you were hardly out of short pants yourself when that dance was around)? I was a punk rocker at the time, so I'm sadly lacking in 80's dance knowledge.

springintoaction's picture

George Sanders played Addison DeWitt

Sanders, played acid-tongued, cold-blooded theatre critic Addison DeWitt in All About Eve, winning an Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for this role

Factoids:

Married both Eva Gabor and her sister Magda Gabor later in life

Sanders committed suicide with an overdose of barbiturates, leaving behind a suicide note that attributed his action to boredom. His friend David Niven recorded in his autobiography that Sanders had predicted his own suicide many years earlier. The note read: "Dear World, I am leaving because I am bored. I feel I have lived long enough. I am leaving you with your worries in this sweet cesspool. Good luck."

Hmmmm. The marriage part  sounds fun, the latter not so much 

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
nf63's picture

what I meant was...

I was trying (and failing miserably) to be witty, by suggesting that since you'd turned Amanda into Eve, you might have another Survivor playing the part of Addison DeWitt. Once again, I fall flat on my face. The upshot is all the knowledge that your readers gained about George Sanders (who also voiced Shere Khan, the evil tiger, in the animated Jungle Book movie) and All About Eve. Maybe there are some young whippersnappers out there who haven't yet discovered this classic, and thanks to you they just have.
luvluke1's picture

Todd Gay!

Give me a break! Todd has been a great player. What does his being gay have to do with anything? He has not made a big deal of it which is what I think is fantastic. He is just another player. He is not the strongest player but he is the smartest. Why is everyone so intimidated by "little" Todd? Because they are afraid of his ability to manipulate people and situations. Remember as Courtney said " a mad Todd is a bad Todd". I hope he takes it all. As far as Amanda goes please I beg you do not show me what is behind door #1. I'll be back to see what you have to say on Mon. I just hope Courtney makes it out alive...she will need some serious IV work to get some meat on them bones.. I want to see a wrap up that was as good as this recap.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
jimmyjazz's picture

GO TODD GO!!!!! YOU TOOK SURVIVOR

WORK THAT TALK SHOW CIRCUIT TODD!!!!!! AND PUSH PUSH PUSHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!YOU WON ONE FOR THE TEAM. THIS IS THE SECOND TIME AN OPENLY GAY MAN WON THAT SHOW. WORK THAT TALK SHOW CIRCUIT. PUSH IT AND CATCH IT BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

luvluke1's picture

YESSSSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!!!! TODD is the man

Todd gave the best answers and he was the best player. Amanda and the "DOE EYE's" great line. J.Robert what a pompous sucker. 2 votes for Cortney? What a joke! Denise is a bitter woman.  Todd hats off to you Gay or not I love you... spring you've got a great story go for it.
JBE's picture

That is great news

Todd winning Survivor.  I still think his job of being a flight attendant was a real help.  It is a job where you have to interact a lot with people, sometimes under stressful conditions.  Combine that with his inner strength (being gay and Mormon can't be easy) and intelligence made him a good possibility from the start.

Cheers

JBE

mai-ku's picture

Cheers for Todd

Late coming in on this one, but I gotta say I'm glad Todd won - if only because he always approached it as a game (which it is, duh).  The players who go on about personal integrity and refusing to play it a certain way make me insane.  Todd saw it as a game to be won, played using a pretty decent strategy, and bested the rest of 'em.  Good on him!
dccutejock's picture

Where are the mad recaps for this season?

Chet is no Todd, but as a fan I appreciate all the nuggets afound in this recap and would love to see what Guillermo has to say about Crazed Kathy or the Incredible Hulk wannabe who was voted off on Thursday. Also Chet may need a little help from AE as he looks like he's on his last legs. Just when you think he's gone, Cerie saves the day. This site can be so much fun.


User login

Recent comments

After Elton home page on logo online