News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Where have the good gays gone?

Is any one else bothered by the fact that the only gay men that ever seem to be shown in the media are all stereotypes? Every gay character in the media seems to be flaming, awkward or distrustful of straight men, uninformed about current events outside of Hollywood gossip, loud with a lisp and having a poor vocabulary (Jack from Will & Grace, The Queer Eye guys, Marc from Ugly Betty (and I really like Ugly Betty and have a crush on Marc), The QAF guys, etc).

Chris Crocker and Michael Buck, both of youtube.com, well, I don't want to call it fame, but for lack of a better term, I have too. Loud, limited vocabulary, seemingly proud of the fact that they don't challenge the neanderthal-straight men stereotypes, and proud of the fact that the only thing they know relates to Britney, Paris or America's Next Top Model.

There are gay men who like/love sports. Gay men who like/love/know/understand hip-hop (Lupe Fiasco, Kanye West, De La Soul, Common) and not just bubblegum pop or what Whats-Her-Name was wearing at the last award show. Where is that gay man? Where is the gay men who has straight male friends who are comfortable having an out gay friend? Where, for crying out loud, is the gay man who drinks beer?

Perhaps my experience is tempered by the fact that I live in Ann Arbor, Michigan, one of the most liberal cities in the country. Maybe its also tempered by the fact that I love hip-hop, ESPN, beer and red meat. But I also love Kylie Minogue, sweet vodka drinks, Will & Grace and Ugly Betty. Most of my guy friends are in fact straight males, none of who are bothered by the fact that I am an open homosexual.

Am I the only one like that? Am I the only one who tires of loud, obnoxious, uninformed, stereotypical gay men in the media? Please, I hope not.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings

GayTV's picture

What? You can't afford a webcam?

If you're so tired of "stereotypical" gay men and you're such the archetype of what a gay man should be then what is stopping you from stepping up to the plate and being the face of the gay community? Michael Buck is an entertainer...if you look at his Peron75 YouTube account you'll see that he is just an average gay guy. Michael Buck isn't afraid to have his face all over the internet introducing his husband. Michael Buck isn't afraid to talk about gay issues. Sorry but I'm tired of the bitching. If you want to go after someone in the gay community go after the boys in the closet who won't talk about their sexuality. There are plenty of gay men and women in all areas of society with a voice...you're just too focused on your own internalized hatred..."I don't want the world to think I'm like that."

Chad Allen, Clive Barker, John Ameachi, Levi Kreis, Chip Arndt, Mark Bingham, Sacha Sacket...I could go on and on and I haven't even named one lesbian yet.

You only need search this site to see that we are a very diverse community.

Like Hip-hop? Athletes? Gamers? What happens when they do show average gay guys on tv like in Sarah Silverman? Some people bitch. It's a no win situation.

BTW...don't blame the gay community because straight America likes to portray us as extremes...that is their comfort level. But to say there are no shows showing us as average everyday guys is incorrect...Brothers and Sisters, Degrassi, Greek, Sarah Silverman, Six Feet Under, Book of Daniel, Wire, Rescue Me...

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
Celtic Tiger's picture

Sigh

The Book of Daniel was one of the few TV shows I actually watched.  It was well done and the son would probably made a very positive role model had not the network caved under pressure.  Such a shame, it had real potential.

"It's your will against mine and you will lose."  Clint Eastwood - Heartbreak Ridge

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
GayTV's picture

Book of Daniel - Never given a chance

The worst part is that the show was never even really given a chance. The protests started at the very idea of the show and it went downhill from there. I wonder if the show would have been cancelled as quickly if it were released now. The xians and the red staters have less pull right now and I think NBC would be more willing to let it play out...at least a little longer.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
JBE's picture

The Media is not yet comfortable

showing gays in a true light.  Remember it is not that long ago that homosexuality was "the love that dare not speak its' name."  When I was a teenager in the 70's gays and lesbians were virtually invisible on TV and in the movies. So we have made alot of progress.  In recent years more mainstream gay characters have made it into shows (e.g. Kevin in Brothers & Sisters).  Over the next 20 or 30 years you will see more and more characters like Kevin.

That being said there will always be stereotypical gays being noticed.  People like Chris Crocker thrive on publicity so it is not a big surprise that you see him in the media, that is what he wants.  I am not sure though why you care so much about the coverage the more flamboyant gays are getting.  Does it affect your ability to meet gays with similar interest to you?  If you like sports then check out websites like Outsports.com or RealJock.com, they are full of so called "straight-acting" gay men who love sports.  Also the social networking websites like MySpace and Facebook would also be good ways of meeting gays with similar interests.

Finally I find it a bit worrisome that you view some gays as "good" which implies that the ones that do not fit your definition of "good" are "bad" and flawed.  The more effeminate gays are just trying to live their lives as open gay people to the best of their ability, I don't see anything bad about that.

Cheers

JBE

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
niksuncle's picture

The good gays are out there - if you look hard enough!

I'd say skip the entertainment aimed at the general public and look at smaller shows or independent films.

I know it's the fantasy genre but I don't remember anyone talking about show tunes in Dante's Cove!!

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
homoguy563's picture

What i've been saying all along.

 I think we, as gay people, get in to this thing where it's like "i'm not being represented in this way, or i'm being represented in that way", and I totally hear that.Anyone on this site that's seen my threads can tell you i've brought this up several times.I'm one of the biggest complainers, so I aggree with you to an extent, but not all of the gay men in the media are stereotypes.I can think of some great gay role models.GayTVluver listed some, but yes, you have to go through a lot of gay chocolate bars before you find one with a golden ticket.(....My bad attempt at being clever.It's hard.All I could come up with was this Willy Wonka reference as an analogy.)

GayTVluver was right about another thing.Gay characters who break the mold of the gay best friend, or assistant, or whatever usually don't last that long.One character like you described was Jake Dunne from Love monkey.I think he was an ex-football star turned sports commentator.He was also one of the group of four guy characters that the show centered around and they all accepted him.I think you would've liked him, but the show only lasted three episodes before it was pulled.The show came back later on VH1, but was canceled again.

There was also Playmakers on ESPN, which lasted only one season.The criticism of that show came from the NFL for once instead of us.admittedly, I took a little bit of glee in this because I wish more people would understand how not fun it is to be on the other side of such a negative portrayel.Anyway, Thad Guerwitcz, the gay character on that show was another self hating closet case.I was interested in seeing where it would go because they had the potential to do something with this character, but he ended up beating his boyfriend, and in the end was blackmailed by the team owner in to staying in the closet.

As far as gay men who are portrayed as distrustful of straight men, that's something I connect with.I have this kind of tribal, or clanish mantality.I'm not heterophobic, but I can understand the resentment that builds up in some gay people over living in a heterosexist society.Just look at the way they treat, or make fun of gay guys on straight guy channels like Spike TV, Which i'll elaborate on later in my own new forum topic.Ofcourse I can seperate the actions of a few from a group of people, but when I see some of the stuff i've seen in the realm of macho straight guys it just pisses me off.

Just the fact that we are so limited in the mainstream TV and movie media makes me feel that way.I think Heroes is one of the coolest shows around, and a huge hit, but the fact that there's never a lead gay character with a love life on shows like this urks me and makes me distrustful.It's gotton to the point where when a character like Calvin on Greek shows up i'm pleasently surprised because the given is that there aren't going to be any gay characters, or atleast none worth watching.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
JBE's picture

As I get older

I find my straight friends and I are drifting apart.  I think it is partly their lifestyles and mine have diverged (kids for eg.), but also I have also gotten the feeling that although they tolerate my sexual orientation they really don't want me to talk about it, as if I am living a second-class life (does anyone else feel this way?).

That is why I now live outside my work almost exclusively in the gay community.  I play in gay sports leagues, do volunteer work in the gay community, play poker with gay friends, etc..  So I guess I can understand where you are coming from Homoguy563, it would be nice to see another QAF with maybe less focus on the fast-lane gay lifestyle and more on the other kinds of gay lives that are out there.  For example, in Ontario a lot of older gay couples are moving out of Toronto to live in smaller communities, because they feel that the gay community is no longer welcoming to older gay people (there is a certain amount of truth to that).  The so-called gay lifestyle is rapidly evolving, it would nice to see programs that reflect some of these changes.

Cheers

JBE

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
GayTV's picture

Your chocolate analogy was charming...

...and funny. But the thing to remember is that there's a lot of good chocolate between the first bite and that golden ticket.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
chisoxfan's picture

In regards to my calling of

In regards to my calling of good and bad; do you really think that Chris Crocker is a good example of gay society? he's going out of his way to fit into stereotypes; i don't for a second believe that's his actual personality. Buck is another who doesn't care that all he knows is Britney. I want something more; and the problem is that networks and the media don't listen to a single voice. I'm wondering if others feel like I do, and are tired of seeing the screeching, ignorant queens. Apparently not.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
GayTV's picture

He's not a good example...

...so don't let him be your example. If you can't find a strong gay voice, a voice just like yours on YouTube then you haven't taken the time to look around. They are there. The fact that you think Buck is only about Britney tells me you haven't taken the time to actually listen to him. Buck's What the Buck Show is exactly what it's suppose to be...a nightly commentary on pop culture...not politics or social issues. He does talk about politics and personal issues on his Peron75 v-blog. He's talked about coming out, political scandals, his marriage to his husband, falling in love, life on Broadway and all sorts of other things. Buck is not Michael Buckley's personality...that is his entertainment personality. But as much as I like Buck, he doesn't represent me. Chris Crocker doesn't represent me. John Ameachi does not represent me. I represent me. All of our voices together represent our community. they represent our community because they are all part of our community...agree with their point of view or not...agree with their personality or not...they are part of our community. You say that one voice doesn't get listened to...well then how did Chris get heard? How does Bruce Vilanch get heard? How does anybody get heard? They speak up. Am I tired of the mass media in America only showing the extremes in their gay pride coverage? In their coverage of gay issues? In virtually every area of media coverage? You bet...that is the reason I write letters to networks and newspapers when they do a bad job. I don't try to silence other people in our community. I'm tired of us being portrayed as killers or fems for shock value or gym bunnies and muscle heads, vain men obsessed with sex to pull in ratings with eye candy...but I don't want them gone...I just want a more balanced coverage and presentation. Here you are Art, one voice and you've already gotten the attention of a handful of guys...imagine what you could do if you took it a step further. YouTube is yours for the taking.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
JBE's picture

Actually I think

Chris Crocker is being himself, he is just not somebody you see everyday of the week, even in the gay community.  Although he is not my cup of tea, he is pretty harmless in the grand scheme of things.  I agree with GayTVluver if you are tired of what you are seeing, get on MyTube and show yourself.  Recently there was an article in AfterElton on Gay Internet Stars of tomorrow, which featured gay young people that are more mainstream and less flamboyant than Chris Crocker.  The Josh and Josh blog I read at least once a month, it is pretty entertaining.  There is a young film student from Maine who has been featured on YouTube (Michael is his name I think).  I have watched his short videos and they are very articulate and entertaining.

As for the mainstream media, things are changing but perhaps not as quickly as we would like.  I keep hoping that there will be a show featuring a gay jock (or jocks) since I am a big sports fan, no luck yet, but there is a hockey movie coming out by the end of the year that is a positive sign of things to come.

Cheers

JBE

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings

User login

Recent comments

After Elton home page on logo online