Anthony Rapp hosts Broadway Beauty Pageant

After Robinson's performance, Susan Blackwell called him over to check if he was wearing Spandex. (He was not.)

Another big hit in the talent portion of the evening was “Mr. A Chorus Line,” Tommy Berklund.

Marty Thomas, “Mr. Xanadu,” showed off his amazing vocal chops in “Proud Mary” — a song that took on new meaning in this context.

After delivering the first part of his song nice and easy, Thomas broke into a roof-raising dance routine, with a little help from his friends.