Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

A Tale of Two Cities: How New York and Los Angeles Treat Their Out Actors

Compare and Contrast

So is it easier to be an out actor in New York than in Los Angeles? Everyone AfterElton.com spoke to says yes, emphatically so.

“[In New York] your reputation is everything,” Cheyenne Jackson told the site last year. “People know if you've got the goods, if you're easy to work with, and if you can get the job done. Besides it's New York theater. Everybody's gay!”

But as for being openly gay in Hollywood, ”I think it's been a detriment, probably just a little bit,” says Jackson. “Had I not been out and open, I think I might have gotten some movies that I screen-tested for. People may have said, ‘The dude's gay how are we going to market this?’ But it's not an issue for me because being out is very freeing.”

Cheyenne Jackson

Photo credit: Bryan Bedder/Getty Images

Ironically, Jackson says being out probably didn’t even help him get his most prominent screen role to date — playing “gay hero” Mark Bingham in the 2006 movie United 93. “The director didn't know anything about me. I think one of the main reasons I got the part was that I was the biggest guy who auditioned. Mark Bingham was 6'5”, and I'm almost 6'4”.

In short, some anti-gay prejudice still exists, though more in Los Angeles than in New York. Much depends on the actor in question, the medium they work in, the level of their celebrity, and the kinds of roles they hope to get.

Without a doubt, the presence of attractive, admired openly gay celebrities has personalized the struggle for GLBT acceptance and made the world a more tolerant place. But all the actors AfterElton.com spoke to agreed that coming out is a complicated decision that should only be made by the person involved.

“I can’t judge other people for what they do,” says Sieber. “All I can say is to each his own.”

Everything comes with a price,” adds Batt. “In a perfect world, it wouldn’t matter. But this ain’t a perfect world.”

 

RJ's picture

Thanks, Brent...

...for a fascinating article. A very interesting topic indeed.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Brent Hartinger's picture

It was fun to write. I feel

It was fun to write. I feel I learned a lot! Thanks.

 

 

 

Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes

see individual ratings
Fieldboy's picture

I second that...

....what an amazing article - great job Brent.
David Ehrenstein's picture

Great work, Brent, but --

you didn't go with any of the Kevin Spacey dish I gave you.

Faint heart n'er won fair blogger.  

 

François Peneaud's picture

Well, you can publish that

Well, you can publish that dish in the comments :) 

François
---------------
http://gaycomicslist.free.fr

Brent Hartinger's picture

Thanks for the help, David.

But we generally don't dish!

 

 

 

Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes

see individual ratings
David E is a Fraud!'s picture

Were you trying to 'win' Brent...

...or were you referring to yourself as the 'prize' when you wrote, "Faint heart n'er won fair blogger"?

RE: "you didn't go with any of the Kevin Spacey dish I gave you."

Thank God he didn't go with the dish - but in your chronic self-centeredness and need for attention, you just went and did what you wanted to do anyway...  

Once in a while you write something really interesting, but most of the time you just waste your time (and the reader's) by trying to pass yourself off as being 'esoteric'.

_________________________________________

-Sibelius

"It's curtains for you, Dr. Horrible. Lacy, wafting curtains..."

David Ehrenstein's picture

Well Francois --

I trust you're familiar with what happened during the shooting of The Usual Suspects, right?
François Peneaud's picture

No, and I shudder to think.

No, and I shudder to think. "Shudder" as in "Please don't be a tease".

François
---------------
http://gaycomicslist.free.fr

Steven Frank's picture

Fantastic Job!

Thanks Brent for such an insightful, smart article about such an interesting, and complicated, topic. It made me wonder about closeted actors who work in both film and theater, and how when they take to the stage, they must feel costarring with actors who are comfortably out.

Oh, and I've had a major crush on Christopher Siebert ever since "It's All Relative," so any chance to get a big photo of him, not to mention great quotes, is always appreciated.

Brent Hartinger's picture

Christopher Seiber seems

Christopher Seiber seems very much worthy of your crush. A very nice guy!

 

 

 

Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes

see individual ratings
David Ehrenstein's picture

Are you sitting down Francois?

Well of course you are.

 

Anyhoo. The principle players were being called to the set for a Big Scene when Mr. Spacey was discovered in his trailer in flagrante avec un petit ami particulier de M. Singer.

This piece of news flew round Hollywood faster than the speed of light. At the end of the day, however (no not that day, I'm speaking figuratively) Messers Spacey and Singer were friends and went on to shoot Superman Returns. In and around the time of his two (count  'em) Oscars, La Spacey was seen publically with a female assistant/manager (to whom he delcared his love on the Oscar broadcast.) Don't know where she is these days but Spacey is in England where he's had some rather awkward Adventures in Dog-walking on Hamstead Heath (cha-cha-cha.)

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
François Peneaud's picture

Gosh. It's a good thing I

Gosh. It's a good thing I was sitting down. Are you telling me that Singer is gay?
I'm joking :)

Well, that anecdote definitely deserved to be told. Merci beaucoup.

François
---------------
http://gaycomicslist.free.fr

Insideguy's picture

Excellent Insight

Having had a long career in Hollywood I have known many stars and the different standards they are held up to for various reasons.  It is incomprehensible that still in this day and age of Lindsay, Brittany, and that there is still a morals contract in every actors's contract no matter how lowly the role. Though simple and short it still carries a lot of weight. It is due in part to Louis B. Mayer's firing of William Haines for refusing to deny his lover's existence thasn any Hay's Office restrictions.

James Whale's, Edward Goulding's, George Cukor's, Henry Willson's, Rock Hudson's, Leonard Grant's and Allan Carr's all male parties are far from fiction.

The best thing about gay people is that they prevail depite horrendous mistreatment and derision.

Joseph's picture

But isn't even Lindsay shattering that "contract"?

I don't know if this has been covered over at our sister site AfterEllen, but Lindsay Lohan's relationship with Samantha Ronson is being treated by the tabloids as a big love affair, and, perhaps more importantly, as a positive thing in light of her past dubious behavior. Even more striking is the fact that neither La Lohan nor Ms. Ronson have confirmed the exact nature of their relationship, yet neither is in a fit to stop the story from being flogged around the world. Of course, Lindsay's career isn't at the heights that it was a few years ago, but, still.

It will be interesting to see if a male celebrity of Lohan's stature were to become involved with another man, would he (and the bf) be as nonchalant as Lohan (and Ronson) seem to be...?

Psionycx's picture

Fascinating article!

Very interesting read.

I wonder as to the extent of corporate influence in New York theatre versus Hollywood TV and movies?  Theatre is so much less of a mass-market product, since there is a defined maximum audience size for a show, whereas in TV and movies the sky's the limit.  This would match your observation about the lighter impact on theatre during the black list days.

Still, it's funny (in a tragic way) how little things have changed in Hollywood despite all the conservative ranting about the "gay agenda" there.  But I suppose it is, again, a side effect of entertainment as a mass-market product.  TV and movie stars are much more visible public figures (sometimes unwillingly) than stage performers.  Consequently they too are product.  How many awful movies nonetheless turn a profit just because some heartthrob superstar is playing the lead?

Such a shame though, because it means the enormous contribution of gay people to culture is often under-appreciated.

Brent Hartinger's picture

I basically think that's the key

 

 

 

Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com no votes

see individual ratings
David Ehrenstein's picture

The Tabs are having a field day with Li-Lo and Sam

Partially it's because straight men see lesbians as figures of sexual fantasy, and partially it's spill-over from Ellen's success, on tube and off. What's fascinating is that LiLo + Sam is seen as infintiely more benign that Li-Lo + Vicotin & Vodka. This in turn feeds into the fact that gayness -- in and of itself -- is no longer a "scandal." It's fast becoming a simple state of being and fact of life.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Frank Anthony Polito's picture

Gay Soap Box

Thanks, Brent, for this informative article!

Back in 1997, I appeared in my first off-off-B'way play here in NYC, a gay play festival.  While I was not yet "out," an agent came to see the show and called me in for a meeting.  First thing he says: "If I send you out, you're not gonna get up on your gay soap box, are you?"  And he, himself, is a gay man! (Is it any wonder I eventually switched to writing?)

I think part of the keeping young gay actors in the cloest comes from the older generation who once tried to "make it" themeselves, but suffered the discrimination.

I know a few 20-something actors from my days at Carnegie Mellon who were gay and proud in college, but now list "seeking women" on their Facebook profiles... Perhaps their paychecks are worth giving up their dignity?

On another note: I had the pleasure of serving as the publicist for David Ehrenstein's OPEN SECRET when it was revised and updated in 2000.  Great book!

BAND FAGS! by Frank Anthony Polito

Kensington Books/ISBN: 978-0-7582-2265-7/$15.00

www.bandfags.com

Frank Anthony Polito's picture

Gay Soap Box

Thanks, Brent, for this informative article!

Back in 1997, I appeared in my first off-off-B'way play here in NYC, a gay play festival.  While I was not yet "out," an agent came to see the show and called me in for a meeting.  First thing he says: "If I send you out, you're not gonna get up on your gay soap box, are you?"  And he, himself, is a gay man! (Is it any wonder I eventually switched to writing?)

I think part of the keeping young gay actors in the cloest comes from the older generation who once tried to "make it" themeselves, but suffered the discrimination.

I know a few 20-something actors from my days at Carnegie Mellon who were gay and proud in college, but now list "seeking women" on their Facebook profiles... Perhaps their paychecks are worth giving up their dignity?

On another note: I had the pleasure of serving as the publicist for David Ehrenstein's OPEN SECRET when it was revised and updated in 2000.  Great book!

BAND FAGS! by Frank Anthony Polito

Kensington Books/ISBN: 978-0-7582-2265-7/$15.00

www.bandfags.com

Strepsi's picture

Here's What I Just Don't Get...

About the real or perceived "housewife fantasy" that will be shattered if she finds out that a Leading Man is gay.  Many straight leading men are happily married and there is no chance they will love you anyway.  Does this nominal "housewife" ACTUALLY think she can bed Brad Pitt -- never mind break up his family -- never mind compete with Angelina Jolie?  NO-ONE competes with the Jolie and wins!  So how can there be a perception that a "straight male" is in any way "attainable" anyway?  Or do I just have the gay ability to fantasize and not understand straight women's level of delusion?

Any ideas?  Brent?  David?

...

Anyhoo, as usual, I love AfterElton because it attempts to critique and theorize as well as gossip.  Bonus: anything Cheyenne Jackson.  Well done! 

Brent Hartinger's picture

I think it's, in part, about

I think it's, in part, about homophobia, the fact that being gay is kinda icky rather than hot. Although we've since learned that many MANY housewives are totally turned on by gay guys...The only equivalent I can think of is back when Mel Gibson was semi-hot and not a nutcase. When I learned he was a devout, converatgive Catholic with, like, 12 kids, it was a TOTAL turn-off. It's not like I ever saw myself WITH Mel Gibson, but the idea of what he was doing on his off-hours--cranking out unneeded kids at the bidding of the Pope and railing about non-Latin mass--it just make him totally icky in my mind, just someone that I wouldn't even want in my sexual fantasies. Perhaps for some homophobia housewives, it's the same kinda thing.

 

 

 

Read my books! Explore "Brent's Brain" at http://www.brenthartinger.com Average (1 vote):

see individual ratings
Mister 2's picture

I think it's generational

I think it's generational too. With all these teenage girls reading yaoi instead of Harlequin, you're bound to see a shift.

Anyway... The biggest difference I've seen between the coasts is this: I don't think I've ever seen a LA doctor's office with gay mags. New York? Oh yeah. :D

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
David Ehrenstein's picture

You're onto something Strepsi!

Straight housewives know full well that can't get Brad  -- or any other famous, desireable and genuine certifiably heterosexual male celeb. That's why the "if they're gay they'll lose their audience" bit is such a cheap canard. Did his female public hate Rock Hudson when they discovered The Truth (and far more than you would imagine knew the truth before it was officially announced)? Of course not. He was a fantasy figure to start with and therefore, even if straight, utterly unimaginable in their ordinary everyday lives. In my far from humble estimation the "if they were known to be gay their careers would end" line is really directed at ordinary everyday gays -- to insist they stay closeted.

 

Well that game's over now.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Lily of the valley's picture

did anyone ever ask us

did anyone ever ask us straight women?

I mean - how many of those watching queer as folk were straight women? 60% or so? that's quite a valuable audience - as a tv-station, producer I would like to know why - so maybe someone already has made some nice statistics about what kind of women are into gay things ... or wouldn't mind if a heartthrob turned out to be gay etc.

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
Janet's picture

So right.

As a straight women, I can say that I have never been turned off by finding out an actor was gay. I have no illusions about having a chance with them. No one with a brain does. In fact, I kind of like them gay. When watching a scene with two men, I am attracted to them both, which just ups the eye candy. And many of my friends wish that straight men were more like the gay men we know. Then, they would be the perfect boyfriends. I'm not going to say anymore about that!

 

 

I say we take the warning labels off everything and let nature take it's course.

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Strepsi's picture

Thanks everyone!

It's gratifying to see thoughtful responses on a blog -- another reason I like this site.  And strangely, I agree with ALL the responses. There is a generational shift thanks to yaoi, and you can see young girls more actively wanting slash fiction and loving their 'mos.  There is also an upcoming generation of younger gay writers and talent that has never been "in", replacing the older gay guard who come from a time when ANY career would have been ruined by being "out".  There is also still homophobia -- but I agree straight women have less of a problem than given credit for...  It's probably more the male producers BLAMING the perceived straight women for their own panic at not wanting a gay hero.  Remember the scene in Jeffrey when the guys kiss?  The camera cuts to 2 straight couples in the 'movie audience":  the guys go "Ewww!!" and the girls go "Awwwww!".  LOL - So true!  And I agree with David that it's more a cheap canard piece of "common wisdom" than fact in any way -- so the question is, who's going to break it to the straight male and closet-case Gatekeepers?
Lily of the valley's picture

well, I don't even think

well, I don't even think it's very new or just because of all the girls reading yaoi.

For example, there's a german gay comic-author who started writing gay themed comics in the 80s. He became quickly quite popular and was very puzzled to learn that half his readership were straight women. The few straight women in his books weren't even displayed favorably, most of them had overbites, were cross-eyed and either sluts (usually with hot boyfriends, though) or frigid ex-girlfriends. 

Another very good example is a popular singer: Patrick Lindner. He is a singer of what we call Volksmusik - you can NOT translate it with folkmusic . It's a style of music involving simple tunes (everyone can easily sing along with) overly cheesy and schmaltzy lyrics (without any hint of intelligence or humor in it) and it appeals mostly to well, housewives, elder ladies . Usually (ah well, I don't want to sound too dismissive,, that's all a cliche/prejudice - but you know: also true ;-) ) - so usually not the kind of people that want to think too much or be bothered with problems other than romatic she and he stories AND more likely to be conservative in thinking and voting. Traditional people not very open to homosexuality etc. 
Patrick Lindner was very famous amongst them - the perfect son-in-law, every grandma's darling. And around ten years ago he came out, maybe was forced to come out, I don't know. He was then in a long term relationship and he even adopted a child. He and his partner (they split up a few years ago) were all over the gossip-papers sold to exactly his audience. I don't think it did much to his career. I read that he changed his style of music slightly - don't know about that - and I don't know if his audience changed in those years - but he never became unpopular and is now back to singing traditional Volksmusik again (if he ever stopped) and with huge success amongst all the ladies.

 


Recent Comments