Welcome to AfterElton.com!

Enter your AfterElton.com username.
Enter the password that accompanies your username.
News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

Clay Aiken officially comes out, says "Yes, I'm Gay."

After finishing second, Aiken released his first album The Measure of a Man which landed at number one on the Billboard 200 and became the highest debut for a solo artist in ten years. The album spawned the hit singles "Invisible" and "This is the Night," with Measure going on to sell two million copies. Aiken has since released three more albums including Merry Christmas with Love, A Thousand Different Ways and All is Well.

Aiken also made the New York Times bestseller list in 2004 with his inspirational memoir Learning to Sing: Hearing the Music in Your Life. Written with Allison Glock, the book debuted at number two and focused on Aiken's religious life as well as the people he identified as most important to him, including his mother, teachers and friends.

Aiken in Spamalot|

In January of this year, Aiken made the leap to Broadway, taking over the role of Sir Robin in Spamalot from out actor David Hyde Pierce.

Aiken is known for having especially devoted fans, nicknamed "Claymates," who have not taken kindly to speculation about Aiken being gay. They have been especially distressed over comedian Kathy Griffin's continuous speculation over Aiken's sexuality (Griffin frequently refers to him as "Gaiken").It will be interesting to see how they react to news Aiken has come out.

It was only last month that Aiken revealed his impending fatherhood. He announced the news on his blog, where he later announced Parker's birth, writing, "My dear friend, Jaymes, and I are so excited to announce the birth of Parker Foster Aiken. The little man is healthy, happy, and as loud as his daddy. Mama Jaymes is doing quite well also."

Parker's mother is Jaymes Foster, the executive producer on Aiken's last three albums. She is also the sister of record producer David Foster.

In an interesting coincidence, Aiken's announcement follows on the heels of Lindsay Lohan's confirmation yesterday that she is in a romantic relationship with DJSamantha Ronson.

Wolfi's picture

We have to find a new term.

Seriously.

Clay Aiken did not come out- he stated the obvious... 

But good for him, every celeb these days counts!

--

The Gays Of Daytime

seanID22's picture

too late

I don't have much sympathy for stars who conceal, or - in fact - actively lie about their sexuality during the years of their peak fame, and then come out when they're a punchline.

When Clay was a "moral values" "christian" golden boy, he pretended to be too good for sex, thereby spreading the myth that one cannot be both gay and christian, gay and a good role model.

 

Average (7 votes):
see individual ratings
RJ's picture

It's never too late

While you or anyone else may be rightfully upset with him for his past behaviour, I say let's see what he does from this point forward. Give him a chance to atone for his past missteps.

So many folks here are saying they're not surprised by the revelation. Perhaps not, but it does not diminish the fact that this is still a very significant announcement. He'll likely lose some fans but the rest will stick with him and eventually forgive him for lying to them. And he'll gain some new fans as well.

Average (8 votes):
see individual ratings
Eric's picture

Exactly

"So many folks here are saying they're not surprised by the revelation. Perhaps not, but it does not diminish the fact that this is still a very significant announcement."  Exactly!!!  Thanks for this comment.  Anyone who comes out, whether they be a celebrity or just normal every day person goes through the same stress.

 

Eric

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Stuart's picture

Well...

Duh!!

Curtis's picture

Good for Clay

I guess it was eating away at him all this time and he had no other choice but to bust that closet door completely down.  Once you have admitted to yourself that you are gay, then you hit up a few family members and a selective group of friends, the rest of the world seems like nothing to actually come out and say "I AM GAY & WHAT!?! 

There have been so many people who have came out later on in life because of fear of losing their family and friends but mainly losing everything they have worked for.  Even though we all face some kind of discrimination, I can't imagine being Clay with that kind of pressure and still able to go on stage and sing his little red-haired heart out.  Then turn around in interviews, with that Southern Charm that drives gays and girls alike crazy and act like nothing is wrong and everything in the world is great, when he was suffering because he couldn't be his true self.  Many see it as a masquerade or the performance of a lifetime but the person he was portraying to be, is really the person that he is.  Except for now, there is no speculation needed, he put a stamp on it and put to rest all the rumors that sometimes made it difficult to actually be a 'Clay Aikens' fan or supporter. 

 He was carrying the weigh of the world on his little shoulders and finally he can rest easy because he is free.

We should be good gay folks and welcome our fellow brother, into our little fraternity and not worry about where he has been or what he has said in the past because most of us know, that being gay at times is such a personal and very private affair.  It can get worse or better with time but that has alot to do with you and how you feel about yourself at that moment in your life.  It seems when your lifestyle choices are putting your career on a stand still, that is just the worst feeling.

 We all know Clay has worked so hard to get to where he is and he has rose beyond all the hype of American Idol and it's 15 minutes of fame clause, to actually establish himself as a true all-around entertainer.  We have to be a little compassionate for him, despite the fact that he is a little dorky, in a 'Geek Squad' kinda way but still I find myself completely attracted to him and I can't deny the simple fact that the man can sing his little red-haired butt off.  I have always like those red-hair boys.     

Average (7 votes):
see individual ratings
joeyhegele's picture

Yay for Clay!

I actually think every coming out is a good thing. The more the breeders get used to people coming out (even the "obvious" ones) is good for the gay community as a whole. I do not think what he did was particularly brave, but I do think it will ultimately be quite helpful for the gay community.

People magainze is everywhere. Every groccery store and pharmacy in the south and the midwest will be filled with the words "Yes, I'm Gay." Millions of housewives will read the article and probably rethink (even just a little bit) the way they view gay people. I especially think it is important to point out the power of his coming out as a gay parent.

Anyhoo, good for Clay. I just wonder how long it will be before GLAAD gives him an award. I think that is unneccesary, but probably inevitable.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
RJ's picture

Offensive term

Your use of the term "breeder" as a put down of heterosexuals is offensive. And especially ironic in this case, since Clay has just recently become a parent himself, and not through adoption either.
Average (8 votes):
see individual ratings
Joseph's picture

It seems to me...

...that these threads already have plenty of offensive terms in them. Astonishing how much a "freakishly effeminate" guy is hated by liberated gay men. Oh, the hypocrisy....

Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/

Average (8 votes):
see individual ratings
Janet's picture

I agree RJ...

...I have done nothing but support gay and lesbian people my whole life. When ever I read one of the guys here refer to me/us as a "breeder" it makes me wince. Where would you be but for the "breeder" that was your mother? You don't want us calling you "faggot"  so please, give the same respect that you desire. 

 

 

 

I say we take the warning labels off everything and let nature take it's course.

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
db's picture

Breeder

I will agree that the term "breeder" is offensive, but it certainly doesn't have the history and power of the word "faggot." You have to admit that heterosexuals do not have the same history of offense as homosexuals and to put the two terms on equal footing is pretty offensive in itself.
Janet's picture

not equal but still offensive

I never said the terms are on equal footing. How can you compare insults and say any of them are equal? Is it okay for you to insult me a little as long as I don't insult you a lot?

 

 

I say we take the warning labels off everything and let nature take it's course.

Average (6 votes):
see individual ratings
db's picture

Excuse me but you said "I don't call you faggot"

I didn't insult you. I said the term was offensive, you brought up the comparison.
GaySpouseDotCom's picture

Name calling at gay folks leads to assault more often than not

Just as a reminder to all gay people, name calling leads to assault more often than not. If someone calls you a derogatory name, do not turn and walk away. Keep them in your line of sight. Try to leave the area. If that is not possible, be mentally prepared to use whatever force is necessary to defend yourself. Take a self defense course which can teach you methods for remaining safer like defensive moves and proper firearm usage. Do not take drugs or too much alcohol because these make you more of a target and try to leave any venue with friends. Stay safe... too many of our brothers and sisters have died for you not to learn the basics of safety!

 www.gaysafety.org

 

db's picture

Offensive Term

When I hear people getting offended at the term "breeder" (which, other than message boards, I haven't heard since the 80s) I think of the white people getting all upset at the word "honkey" back in the 70s--I mean, get real.
Knickie's picture

I have to say that in my

I have to say that in my experience 99.9% of straight people don't even know the term "breeder" let alone finding it an insult. It just doesn't register at all. And in my classes I deal with language and hate-speech usage all the time.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Bountiful's picture

Wishing Clay all the best

Michael, I would have appreciated if you also included some of Clay's charity work in this article. In 2003, Clay launched the Bubel/Aiken foundation, which works to promote the inclusion of children with special needs into the community. Clay has also been involved with UNICEF since 2004. I know he also helped raise money for Broadway Cares this year.

(Since you mentioned the tabloid stuff, it's only fair to mention some of the good things he's done.)

I'm wishing Clay all the best with his life. He's a good hearted guy who treats people kindly. I know some people will look down on him for not being out earlier, when they felt it was always so obvious. But, I don't know that he necessarily lied. Even if he did know his orientation before now, if he hadn't fully accepted it himself, then it wouldn't have been the time to talk about it to the world. 

I think some will accuse Clay of implied homophobia because he had always talked about being Christian while avoiding saying anything about gay people. But, he's not a malicious person, and he's never encouraged hate of any kind. I hope he won't get too much negativity directed his way. I'm sure he just wants to continue living his life, making music, supporting his charities, and raising his beautiful, beautiful child. I hope people will let him enjoy his life in peace.

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
beyondthepale's picture

About time.

It's a big step for him on a personal level as it was for all of us who are out, but let's face it Stevie Wonder could have told Clay he was a big mo. Now let's see what Ricky Martin and his surrogate born twins have to say.......
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
Gabrielle's picture

Man, i totally didn't see

Man, i totally didn't see that one coming! haha j/k.

Good for you, Clay!

 

dback's picture

This is like 2006 all over again

Remember in the span of a few weeks when Mark Foley, Ted Haggart, T.R. Knight and Neil Patrick Harris all came out at once?  Today Lindsay Lohan supposedly confirmed her relationship with Samantha Ronson on "Loveline" as well.  All this, plus a major McCain advisor, too!  Quoth the Chinese: "May you live in interesting times."

Congrats Clay--enjoy the sun on your skin.  It feels good to get out of the darkness.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
db's picture

Mark Foley and Ted Haggart came out?

I don't remember that. I thought they were caught in gay scandals but maintained they were straight.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
afhickman's picture

And baby makes two

afhickman

"The mountain has wings."

Welcome into the fold, Clay.  One thing's for certain, you won't want for baby sitters!

Shane's picture

Good for Him!

"Fans very nearly missed their chance to see the future pop star when he failed to make it into the show's round of 32."

 

Correction. He did make it into the top 32, his bad luck was to be in the same group of 8 as Ruben and Kim Locke. Those three ended up the eventual winner, runner up and 3rd place of the season. He is currently starring in Spamalot on Broadway reprising his Sir Robin role.

I say give the boy his due. So many gay men don't come out until they are much older and more established, if ever. He's a cutie and so is the baby. 

duckiestoy's picture

Rolling Stone "denial" in 03, Out to mom in 04

There's a short teaser at People's website which quotes Clay saying he came out to his mom in the car four years ago after they dropped his brother off before a deployment to Iraq.  Maybe more important, it also says she's still struggling with it.

I'd hope the article has some depth and answers questions like why now and so on.

David Ehrenstein's picture

I say Clay should be in the next revival of "Gypsy"

No, not as Mama Rose, or Baby June, or Louise -- but as one of the strippers. Why?

 

"Ya gotta have a gimmick," that's why. Clay's "coming out" is nothing more than gimmick designed to keep him "in the public eye" and therefore "viable" in a post-NPH world. It has nothing to do with Gay Pride (an alien concept to Clay.) Or Gay Anything Else.

 IOW --

"Once i was a scheppa, now I'm Miss Mazeppa!" 

And now what of the Ckaymates? Mass suicide perchance?  

 

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
RJ's picture

Such bitterness, David

You're the one who is always pushing for gay celebrities to come out of the closet publicly. Here Clay is doing exactly what you've been demanding. Shouldn't you be happy for him instead of second-guessing his motives?

I love NPH too but he's hardly the poster boy for voluntarily coming out of the closet to the general public that you've made him out to be.

Average (7 votes):
see individual ratings
David Ehrenstein's picture

Bitter? Moi?

Central to my feelings about Clay is my antipathy to his "singing." Nice that he's out. Wish he had talent.

As for NPH, as I have pointed out repeatedly he and David Burtka were out and about in public LONG before their official "coming out." This was during the lengthy period between Doogie-hood and his current level of world fame. He was just a working actor then and no publicity org (ie. magazine or "news" show) was interested in him. And as I said his media rep at the time did the standard thing when that Lavangaria creature went into his aria -- inspired not by actual reporting on his part but cribbing from a Canadian gossip column. Some 12 hours or so later NPH corrected the record.

David E is a Fraud!'s picture

Whew! What a relief

"he and David Burtka were out and about in public LONG before their official 'coming out.'"

I get it now! It's OK for NPH to be 'post-gay' (there really should be a better term for this), because *you* approve. Everyone else is living in 'fear' and 'shame' and is fair game for public disdain and ridicule.

Whew! Thank goodness that's cleared up! I do hope that NPH didn't have to pay a fee to get his card offically stamped...

"My Name is David Ehrenstein and I approved this homosexual."

_________________________________________

-Sibelius

"It's curtains for you, Dr. Horrible. Lacy, wafting curtains..."

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
db's picture

Bitter, Vous.

David, I don't like Clay's songs, I don't like most of the songs the AI people put out, but Clay certainly does not lack talent.
Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
Psionycx's picture

People is the new Advocate?

Anyone else notice that nowadays whenever a celeb opts to come out it's on the cover of People, rather than in gay rags like the Advocate?

While it's nice that Aiken has finally opted to stop insulting everyone's intelligence with blatant concealment of the obvious (et tu Ricky Martin?) I do wonder about the way the phenomenon now works.  People seems to be the official vehicle for the "I'm Gay" cover story, which leaves me wondering if the motives are really pure, or if it's just a way for B-list list celebs that are falling down to the C-list to generate some publicity.

Still, it has entertainment value.  I remember that right up until the day Lance Bass's People cover came out that there were still fans on various message boards adamantly insisting that he was straight and that anyone suggesting he was gay was a loser.  Talk about eating crow.  However, I'm left wondering how long this can go on, and how many more "I'm gay!" covers People is going to be willing to do.

nordic balance's picture

Breaking news.  Clay comes

Breaking news.  Clay comes out as gay and the pope comes out as Catholic.  Shockers.

It's convenient to come out when your career is in the toilet and you need the extra publicity to get back into the public eye. 

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Joseph's picture

If currently starring on Broadway...

...in one of the biggest and most successful shows is having a "career in the toilet," I'd gladly take a dive in that water!

Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
nordic balance's picture

He went from selling a few

He went from selling a few million CDs to a few hundred thousand.  I'd say that his career as a mega-selling recording artist is currently in the crapper.  I can't say that I'd willingly jump into the life of a prostitute bare-backing, freakshow in denial(until conveniently outing myself when the time was opportune) even if it meant landing a role as lead in a broadway show, nor would I consider myself as a success considering that I had thus far compromised my own integrity as a person and an artist to make a mint. 

 

David E is a Fraud!'s picture

It's *not* that I disagree with you...

RE: "If currently starring on Broadway...in one of the biggest and most successful shows is having a "career in the toilet," I'd gladly take a dive in that water! "

To be fair, Broadway shows that have been around for awhile (like 'Spamalot') often rotate affordable 'names' for short-term contracts after the show's box office begins to slow. This allows for the show to pull in those punters who normally wouldn't see a Broadway show, but would buy a ticket to see the 'name'. (like 'Claymates')

It's not really an indication of talent. (Case in point: casting Kelly Osbourne as Mama Morton in 'Chicago'.) I haven't seen Clay in the role but given he has no acting credentials at all, it seems more likely he was cast to draw in a demographic that won't mind if he can't act. He also has the luxury (as anyone would who steps into the role) of mimicing David Hyde Pierce's original performance to the letter, if he chooses.

Bottom line is that it's not such a big deal. It's a good opportunity for him though. 

_________________________________________

-Sibelius

"It's curtains for you, Dr. Horrible. Lacy, wafting curtains..."

Joseph's picture

Yes, you're totally correct, but...

...my point was that starring on Broadway clearly indicates that your career is considerably more healthy than, say, starring in amateur porn or having a picture of you wearing a Wal-Mart uniform splashed across the internet. When you're doing that, THEN your career is in the toilet.

Check out my blog: http://radicalsexy.blogspot.com/

Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
David E is a Fraud!'s picture

Yup! :^D

"...my point was that starring on Broadway clearly indicates that your career is considerably more healthy than, say, starring in amateur porn or having a picture of you wearing a Wal-Mart uniform splashed across the internet."

Yup! ...I don't remember if I read it in one of the Aiken blogs here or if I saw it on another theater site, but I do recall reading that when he played Sir Robin the first time, ticket sales went up. 

_________________________________________

-Sibelius

"It's curtains for you, Dr. Horrible. Lacy, wafting curtains..."

nordic balance's picture

Ah, I was just being,

Ah, I was just being, perhaps, a little defensive, as I know what you were trying to say.  I have the annoying habit of overdoing things a bit.  :)
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
bored2tears's picture

Clay's mother was shocked?!

The People report includes Clay relating that his mother was surprised when he told her he is gay.

To quote Karen Walker: "What is she, headless?!"

Average (3 votes):
see individual ratings
ceares's picture

Comeback? Not a smart choice

There's always a chance for a career comeback, but putting yourself in the public eye as gay isn't the smartest choice to attempt it. That's why I sincerely doubt any body that's come out so far has done so primarily for publicity. A hot chick saying she's bi? Sure, but a man coming out as gay? No way. That's a mark on your permanent record so to speak. Unfortunate, but true. And it's so much easier to make your comeback on reality t.v. these days.

Clay is going to lose a significant amount of scarily devoted fans behind this. Fans that bought his albums and went to his shows no matter what. A lot of people don't like him, and this isn't going to make them like him more, but less. His fans adored him though, so no, I don't see how this was in any way a publicity ploy. Yeah, he's on the cover of People-so was that guy they think murdered three wives...so what.

Despite the lovely old chestnut, any publicity is not good publicity, as I'm sure the Dixie Chicks and many others would agree.

 

Hmm...I just reread this and I hope it doesn't come off that I'm saying he shouldn't have come out. I thinks it's terrific that he did, I'm just trying to say I doubt he and his publicist were thinking it'd be a good career move.

Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
HighMaintenance's picture

I don't think it was a

I don't think it was a career move. I certainly agree he might lose fans, but at least he can be himself! I'm proud of him. And who knows? For Lance Bass it actually helped to endear him to fans and bring him back into the public eye.

I don't think it should be a publicity stunt...but if it happens to help their careers, then good! It's about time people began supporting this kind of openness!

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
David E is a Fraud!'s picture

RE: "at least he can be himself"

I wonder if it's more of a case that "we can be ourselves"?  

I'm not so sure that any of his personal behaviors will change.

I can see how the public and media behavior might change pretty drastically, though. No more opportunities for public put-downs and making him the butt of a joke, no more impossibly false hopes of marriage to a total stranger (or maybe new hopes?), we'll need for a new subject to 'dish' about... The possibilities are endless on this side of the coin. 

His behavior? It'll probably be pretty much the same.

_________________________________________

-Sibelius

"It's curtains for you, Dr. Horrible. Lacy, wafting curtains..."

zanefan's picture

I admit, I was a bit

I admit, I was a bit disappointed to see Clay actually DENY being gay back in that Rolling Stone interview.  I would have respected him more had he just not said anything at all.

But you know what?  I've learned that it's not fair for any of us to judge someone else's journey.  He was thrust from being a nobody in one of THE most homophobic areas of the country to a superstar, and everyone wanted SOMETHING from him.  He did his best, made some mistakes, but this interview seems to indicate a deep maturity has settled in.

Clay clearly made peace with his sexuality years ago, if it's been four years since he told his mother.  There's something to be said for him coming out now. 

I have to laugh at those that think this is somehow tied to him trying to "reignite his career."  What career?  He had one hit, the rest of his success has been based on concerts attended by legions of middle-aged women in denial.  How could this POSSIBLY help his career?

I take him at his word, he did it so that he could live an honest and authentic life for his son to look up to.  That's admirable and I respect him for that.

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Novinous's picture

I don't really know him

I only heard about Clay Aiken in Jeff Dunham's dead terrorist number (which I thought was really funny but anyway that's off-topic) a while back so I don't know the guy, I don't even know why everybody thought he was gay.

But I think that it's great that he came out in his own term, when he was ready and prepared. Don't you think that it's better to do it that way instead of answering to a question he has been asked a thousand times, just because he's just sick of being asked ?

Who cares if he "stated the obvious" as long as he did it when he wanted and how he wanted ?

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
WW's picture

Welcome to the community

Every coming-out, celebrity or non-celebrity, is important. And as belated as it might be, Clay Aiken finally did it. Good for him. It couldn't have been easy, especially if he was raised very religiously and didn't want to disappoint his mom. But the fact that it's on the cover of People magazine, a nationally recognzied publication, can be only a positive thing. I'd be curious to know what Kathy Griffin, who jokingly referred to him as ''Gay-kin,'' has to say now. I'll add something to what Bountiful said about what Aiken has done for charity. On Sunday, the Broadway Flea Market auctioned off VIP seats and a backstage visit with Clay Aiken in ''Spamalot.'' It raised $10,000, the highest bid of the auction, and it all went to Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS. Bravo!
Average (4 votes):
see individual ratings
Sethanel's picture

was this child planned?

I think it is kinda sad really. Deep down, he knew he was gay and he has been leading this woman around who is probably in love with him, pretended to love her and now he comes out to the world. Good he came out, but i do not applaud him having a kid with a woman who loves him in a way that he cannot love her back. It is wrong to do that and we (personally) should not be celebrating something that has brought harm to the mother of his child.
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
zanefan's picture

Jaymes, presumably, knew he

Jaymes, presumably, knew he was gay and offered to share with him the wonderful gift of having his own, natural child.  The child was conceived via artificial insemination, so there was no misleading going on.

Plus, Jaymes is nearing 50, so she likely realized this was an opportunity for her to have her own child as well.  The arrangement worked for both of them.

I wouldn't presume she was in love with him.  She likely loves him, yes, but as a friend and the father of her child. 

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
db's picture

I doubt this woman went into this thinking they had a lover

relationship. I'm sure she knew exactly what she was doing. I believe she's quite a bit older and they have been friends for a very long time.
Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Sethanel's picture

good otherwise the whole

good otherwise the whole thing would have been stupid
Average (1 vote):
see individual ratings
TheFabulousThomasJ's picture

Well, At Least He Came Out!

That's certainly more than Liberace or Paul Lynde ever did.

But Kathy Griffin just lost her source for comedy material! 

LOL!!

 

Congratulation to Clay. . .

 

Tom

 

 

Average (2 votes):
see individual ratings
Hephaestion's picture

up next....

Now it's Lindsey Graham's turn.