Account access requires JavaScript and cookies to be enabled.

News, Reviews & Commentary on Gay and Bisexual Men in Entertainment and the Media

The 2009 AfterElton Hot 100

15. Matthew Mitcham

Rank last year: N/A

Arriving at #15 on our countdown with nary a splash is cutie Matthew Mitcham, who won Olympic Gold in Beijing last year with the highest diving score in Olympic history. But before he won the medal, he won our hearts when he casually came out to the world in a newspaper interview three months before the Games.

What makes Matthew hot isn’t his amazing abs or his occupational hazard of running around in a Speedo all the time, although those certainly don’t hurt. What makes him hot is his obvious joy in living life and assuredness of who he is.

While American swimmers celebrated victory by screaming and pumping the air with their fists, Matthew came out of the pool after his winning dive, grinned at the camera, and gave a little wave. It was endearing, just like everything else about him. As if that wasn’t enough, once his score was announced, he ran to the stands and hugged his partner, Lachlan.

At the games, Matthew was 1 in 10,000 – the only openly gay athlete among the thousands competing, and while he says he’s staying focused on his diving for the London Games in 2012, he understands what his newfound status means. According to him, “As soon as anybody looks up to you, you automatically become a role model whether you choose to be or not, and you can either embrace it or not. I choose to embrace it and try to be the best role model I can be.”

Matthew, we’re all looking up to you.

14. Gareth David-Lloyd

Rank last year: 11

Gareth David-Lloyd may actually have the best job on earth. And it’s a job that even allows him to stay on earth, most days. As the droll Ianto Jones on Torchwood, he plays the straight man to John Barrowman’s double entendres as well as the not-so-straight man to Capt. Jack Harkness after he saves the world. Ianto can make the perfect cup of tea, stop an alien invasion, knows creative uses for a stopwatch, plus all the rules for naked hide-and-seek.

Gareth doesn’t seem to take life too seriously though, and it’s his general zest for life that just adds to his sexiness. On Torchwood, Ianto's suit is always Seville Row, but on the weekends you’ll find Gareth  in jeans and a t-shirt, fronting his heavy blues band Blue Gillespie. 

The cast of Torchwood is a notoriously cheeky group, and you’ve got to have a sense of humor to get by. Recently appearing on a panel about the show, Gareth somehow got goaded into taking off his pants. We can report he remains just as hot in a pair of black boxer briefs as he does in a snazzy suit. That’s our kind of man.

13. Anderson Cooper

Rank last year: 9

He’s known as the Silver Fox by some. Others refer to him as Gloria Vanderbilt’s son, while one prominent blogger refers to him as Mah Boo. By whatever name, there’s something about this smart news guy that inspires you to listen to what he’s saying, whether he’s wading through a devastated New Orleans or reporting on the latest world crisis.

While we’re not going to discount the piercing blue eyes hypnotizing us, his huge appeal is likely because he does something unique in this day and age: he reports actual news and talks to us like grownups.

That’s not to say Anderson doesn’t have a lighter, even – dare we say – snarky side. He just doesn’t display it on his news broadcast where he is the consummate pro. But sitting next to Kelly Ripa, he can display an encyclopedic knowledge of trashy reality TV, from Living Lohan to Real Housewives. He might not understand himself why he watches, but he never seems to miss an episode of his favorite reality shows. He even passes notes a ten-year-old might write to the Insult Comic Dog while at the Democratic National Convention.

He’s smart. He’s handsome. He likes reality TV and foul-mouthed puppets. Yes, he’s unconventional, but that’s much of what makes him so undeniably hot.

12. Jared Padalecki

Rank last year: 43

Jared Padalecki is living proof that things are bigger – and hotter – in Texas. Clocking in at 6’4”, this San Antonio native looms over his equally hot co-star, Jensen Ackles, as the brooding Sam Winchester on Supernatural.

This mop-headed demon hunter brings a thoughtful element to the show that inspired the concept of Wincest. While his TV brother was into heavy metal and chasing girls, Sam was headed to Stanford before getting sucked into the world of angels and demons. Now he’s the brother who always has the answers, often quoted from a third century Greek poet.

Padalecki’s first major gig was setting teenage girls’ hearts aflutter on Gilmore Girls at the tender age of 18, but since then his roles have taken a decidedly darker turn, whether dashing around the Midwest every week trying to save us from the coming Apocalypse, or starring in the latest Friday the 13th movie.

Obviously, Jared likes things dark and scary, which is fine with us, as long as he’s there to hold us when the monsters come at night.