Marry, Hump, or Dump! Men of "Smallville"

Left to right: Justin Hartley, Tom Welling and Alan Ritchson

This week's hunky players all portrayed superheroes on the long-running CW series Smallville. That show wrapped just last week, and as a parting tribute we figured we'd ask AfterElton readers which of them they would....

Tom Welling

Ten years playing Superman, and we never got to see him in the blue tights and red panties! Too bad, because we think might have been able to pull it off. After all, the actor got his start modeling for Abercrombie & Fitch and Calvin Klein.

Justin Hartley

The tall blonde actor got his start on the NBC soap Passions. He landed the lead in a CW pilot for Aquaman, but the proposed series tanked. The CW was impressed with Hartley however, and he was signed for a guest turn on Smallville to play The Green Arrow (Oliver Queen). Hartley was so popular (and, seemingly, so willing to go shirtless) that he eventually became a regular cast member.

Alan Ritchson

Fun fact, Alan Ritchson was one of the top 87 contestants for American Idol season 3. Like Welling, he's a former model and the interwebs are teeming with pics of him in his underwear. (totally Google-worthy) He's perhaps best known for his role on Blue Mountain State, but on several ocassions he showed up in Smallville in board shorts and neck gills as Aquaman. Most recently he could be seen on 90210 sharing a hot Cabo San Lucas one-nighter with Teddy Montgomery (Trevor Donovan)

Now that you've voted, please share your reasoning in the comments!

Last week's poll...

Marry Nicholas Brendon
Hump David Boreanaz
Dump James Martsers

You'll find previous contests here.