Whether you think Archuleta was robbed or Cook rules, you'll enjoy Jim & Penny's last Idol Chat, where they break out the champagne to dish on all things good and bad during finale week.
Jim Verraros weighs in on season one co-host Brian Dunkleman's recent comments that the show was "mean-spirited and targeted specific contestants in an effort to break them."
This week on Idol Chat, Jim & Penny ask the tough question: Namely, what was up with David Cook’s unfortunate waist sash? Also, Penny breaks out her Laura Bush impression.
Jim Verraros and Penny Frulla talk about the past week's performances and the questionable fashions — including that unfortunate dress Project Runway winner Christian Siriano designed for Kimberly Locke.
It's curtains for Amanda Overmyer and her Beetlejuice pants. Jim and Penny dish the dirt on last week's performances, and also talk about why they think a closeted gay contestant would actually benefit from coming out while on the show.
Jim & Penny have a field day dishing on Chikezie's triumph, David Archuleta's crash & burn, Amanda Overmyer's Beetlejuice pants, and the untimely passing of David Hernandez.
It was eighties week on American Idol so Jim Verraros and Penny Frulla pull out the polo shirts, shoulder pads and rhinestones to critique the top 16 performances. It ain't gonna be pretty.
![AfterElton Briefs: "Taking Woodstock" rolls, David Archuleta "Crushes" and more!](/sites/www.afterelton.com/files/dsmcandisnatalietease.jpg "AfterElton Briefs: "Taking Woodstock" rolls, David Archuleta "Crushes" and more!")
